You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
lighthearted
relaxing
When you setup a book premise about an aristocrat in Moscow in the aftermath of the Russian Revolution and enduring such events as two world wars, the Ukrainian famine and the rise of the Stalinist totalitarian state, it surely prepares a reader for a tale of dramatic social upheaval and ways of life turned on their head, bewilderment on a nation-wide scale. But this book instead trades national transformation for meditations in quiet, comfortable domesticity. The overhaul of political ideals translates into quotidian observations about hotel guests. The immediate curtailment of personal freedom and the growing influence of party loyalty and the state-surveillance apparatus is evinced in interpersonal conflicts between the staff of the Grand Metropol Hotel. And the furious passing of time from a barely industrialized state to the beginnings of a cold war of ideology takes shape through a young girl in a hotel, and eventually, her own young girl as well.
Our protagonist, Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov, is condemned by the victorious Bolsheviks in the wake of the Russian Revolution, to permanent house arrest within the walls of the palatial Metropol Hotel in Moscow. We see through his life as the decades whisk by and the new Russia takes shape in the microcosm of a hotel, observed from the hotel roof at night, tasted and experienced by the shortage or surplus or change in culinary ingredients and most importantly, addressed by a revolving cast of characters entering and leaving the hotel over the years. There is a remarkable similarity between this book and something like A General Theory of Oblivion by José Eduardo Agualusa wherein the main character is confined to quarters while the outside society undergoes revolutionary upheaval. The tricky part about this is that the main character has no true agency in such stories - rather the story generally happens to them (this weakness is also present in something like Circe by Madeline Miller). It happens to this book as well, and although it adopts a sophomoric playfulness in prose style (in which Tolstoy, Chekhov, Pushkin, Turgenev and Dostoyevsky are referenced as much as humanly possible) I can see how many will not find the story especially compelling. Rostov remains a great character through which to tell a story of quiet human dignity amidst difficult circumstances - but in the end those difficult circumstances rarely feel like proper challenges at all. The book has an ambitious lack of plot or conflict - beyond one acute episode, Count Rostov's house arrest is never seen as some existential obstacle to overcome or make peace with. The other weakness with the book is that it never found a way of addressing, even slantwise, any actual merits of the Revolution itself as the Count was and is too far removed from the plight of the proletariat to offer any perspective of contrast to his own privileged experiences in the increasingly draconian Soviet state. While the Count remains a memorable character throughout the book, in the end the story was somewhat middling, ideologically ambivalent and humanistically sincere (though quite trite at times).
Our protagonist, Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov, is condemned by the victorious Bolsheviks in the wake of the Russian Revolution, to permanent house arrest within the walls of the palatial Metropol Hotel in Moscow. We see through his life as the decades whisk by and the new Russia takes shape in the microcosm of a hotel, observed from the hotel roof at night, tasted and experienced by the shortage or surplus or change in culinary ingredients and most importantly, addressed by a revolving cast of characters entering and leaving the hotel over the years. There is a remarkable similarity between this book and something like A General Theory of Oblivion by José Eduardo Agualusa wherein the main character is confined to quarters while the outside society undergoes revolutionary upheaval. The tricky part about this is that the main character has no true agency in such stories - rather the story generally happens to them (this weakness is also present in something like Circe by Madeline Miller). It happens to this book as well, and although it adopts a sophomoric playfulness in prose style (in which Tolstoy, Chekhov, Pushkin, Turgenev and Dostoyevsky are referenced as much as humanly possible) I can see how many will not find the story especially compelling. Rostov remains a great character through which to tell a story of quiet human dignity amidst difficult circumstances - but in the end those difficult circumstances rarely feel like proper challenges at all. The book has an ambitious lack of plot or conflict - beyond one acute episode, Count Rostov's house arrest is never seen as some existential obstacle to overcome or make peace with. The other weakness with the book is that it never found a way of addressing, even slantwise, any actual merits of the Revolution itself as the Count was and is too far removed from the plight of the proletariat to offer any perspective of contrast to his own privileged experiences in the increasingly draconian Soviet state. While the Count remains a memorable character throughout the book, in the end the story was somewhat middling, ideologically ambivalent and humanistically sincere (though quite trite at times).
It's a testament to the understated but strong writing that the author can manage to hold my interest in a book about a cliché premise of orphaned children, an evil stepmother and lost birthrights in the middle-class, post-war America. Even writing this description seems unattractive but the book manages to be quite engaging and bring surprising depth to a tired collection of archetypes. The Dutch House, a pre-depression relic, the strange lost familial home becomes that classical device - a fixed object around which different characters have wildly varied relationships with. Rest assured, there is far more going on with this house and story than a symbolic nostalgia for simpler, pastoral times of childhood and innocence. People experience and are changed by memory differently, both their own memories and those of others, and its a fascinating bit of subtext that runs through the whole book. One of the central tensions I found is being unable to exactly locate particular scenes chronologically (involving sitting in a car outside the Dutch house); this playfulness and instability with regards to perspective keeps the reader engaged throughout the main character (Danny's) journey from age 3 through to his fifties. But it is his assertive sister Maeve who truly shines above her more passive younger brother. I'm not sure this book has left a huge impression on me, and I think the ending is too tidy for my liking, but it's a solid piece of writing that makes for an intriguing read.
dark
slow-paced
I think like most readers, the only true preparation or foreknowledge I had when beginning Lolita was its transgressive subject matter. I picked a digital copy as to read it more or less anonymously without advertising the fact with a hardcover at a coffee shop and I prepared for a book I'd likely have to read at full arm's length while holding my breath like it's some decomposing roadkill. Well, the book is transgressive but I was not at all prepared for the ways in which it does it. This is the story of a pedophile, a rapist and a murderer: we go inside the headspace of this depraved, twisted, demented soul and what fills the pages of the book? Not a deluge of pornography, scatology, obscene sexual scenes and nauseating lascivious indulgences (there are some), but instead we get some of the finest English prose ever written: sentence after sentence of sonorous beauty captured in phrases that feel far more like poetry than prose. It's almost impossible to overemphasize how stunning the writing is: Nabokov achieves something practically word-perfect. With works from most lauded novelists and prose stylists you will find some incredible sentence or paragraphs which are sharp and interconnected by perhaps some more perfunctory scaffolding required by the medium of the novel. With Lolita, every, single, line evokes some sort of irresistible pleasure in its reading and enunciation. I've heard people say stuff like Blood Meridian and Moby Dick are "prose poems", but Lolita is the only book I've read that truly lives up to that title.
And yet the linguistic beauty and the playfulness and inventiveness of the language is not superfluous or indulgent. When you think about the story being told, the great power of the writing is how it submerges its transgressions in a yolk of haunting imagery and oral brilliance, which somehow, is even more dark and disturbing than if the author chose to paint the pages with every depraved, perverted scene he leaves unwritten. The main character, Humbert Humbert, is not only monstrous in his sexual appetites, he's a deviously clever one, a snobby ex-patriat belonging to the European intelligentsia. He has such a mastery of language and its manipulation that he works over on the reader, the same tricks and ploys, facades and lures with which he entraps Dolores Haze: the girl at the centre of his perversions. In this way, the beauty of the prose becomes charged with a deeply disturbing and manipulative undertone. Each sentence I can be left agape with its incredible ornamentations, the pop of the alliterations, the voluminous adjectives burying short, routine nouns. And at the same sentence, I squirm as if I feel Humbert's disgusting tongue right in my ear whispering out the words.
It's an absolutely perfect novel, which buries its dark subject matter in layers and layers of aesthetic achievement, which serves to expose the transgression more clearly than ever. One of the greatest novels I've ever read, and however discomforting it might be to admit, I have no doubt I'll be re-reading this book for the rest of my life.
And yet the linguistic beauty and the playfulness and inventiveness of the language is not superfluous or indulgent. When you think about the story being told, the great power of the writing is how it submerges its transgressions in a yolk of haunting imagery and oral brilliance, which somehow, is even more dark and disturbing than if the author chose to paint the pages with every depraved, perverted scene he leaves unwritten. The main character, Humbert Humbert, is not only monstrous in his sexual appetites, he's a deviously clever one, a snobby ex-patriat belonging to the European intelligentsia. He has such a mastery of language and its manipulation that he works over on the reader, the same tricks and ploys, facades and lures with which he entraps Dolores Haze: the girl at the centre of his perversions. In this way, the beauty of the prose becomes charged with a deeply disturbing and manipulative undertone. Each sentence I can be left agape with its incredible ornamentations, the pop of the alliterations, the voluminous adjectives burying short, routine nouns. And at the same sentence, I squirm as if I feel Humbert's disgusting tongue right in my ear whispering out the words.
It's an absolutely perfect novel, which buries its dark subject matter in layers and layers of aesthetic achievement, which serves to expose the transgression more clearly than ever. One of the greatest novels I've ever read, and however discomforting it might be to admit, I have no doubt I'll be re-reading this book for the rest of my life.
Graphic: Pedophilia, Rape
emotional
reflective
sad
Never Let Me Go will not take you on some grand intellectual journey. It will not wow you by asking bold questions about science. It won't establish new literary frontiers for speculation or style. But it is an intensely moving story of adolescence and adulthood, assembled from the haze and jumble of partially ordered memories from the protagonist: Kathy. One needn't be afraid of the author's lofty status as a Nobel Prize winner; this book is extremely readable and sleekly put together. The prose works despite me being unable to articulate why it works. There was not a single passage that I found super profound or quotable or deeply poetic. There isn't any particular stylistic decisions I can put my finger on, no unusual diction or syntax or choice metaphors. Instead it's compelling without being manipulative and understated in place of bold and bright. It never drags (with exception to an extended monologue close to the end) and despite there being a certain element of mystery at play, it never feels like the narrative structure is indulging the suspense of the "secret" in any way that's forced. Instead this uneasiness and unexplained centre is fairly subtle and manifests entirely through ambience.
The book is not truly about some mystery anyways; I think it's reputation as a book with a big twist is guilty of burying the lede. What it is is a portrait of adolescence that feels frightfully familiar; so many interpersonal dynamics, social discords are so accurate and recognizable. The character of Ruth in particular is so realistic I feel like every reader can recognize her from someone (or an amalgamation of someones) from their past. The strength of the novel, I think, is the marriage between an uncanny environment and an intensely intimate narration. "Grand" realizations come about from very personal, quotidian and innocuous situations. The preoccupation of the text becomes not about the structure of the society our characters find themselves in, but rather how they navigate life within it. No story about adolescence can be without its requisite rebellion and defiance but here it is strange and diffuse, and cliched moments of anger give way to a melancholy that is stunningly human.
Some books float on the tongue, an assemblage of quotes or scenarios usable in any number of situations. Others dance in the brain, either at the forefront or in the forgotten corner, gestating for future contemplation. This book, however, sits directly in the gut; to remember it is to bear being winded again from those intense emotions that the text leaves behind.
The book is not truly about some mystery anyways; I think it's reputation as a book with a big twist is guilty of burying the lede. What it is is a portrait of adolescence that feels frightfully familiar; so many interpersonal dynamics, social discords are so accurate and recognizable. The character of Ruth in particular is so realistic I feel like every reader can recognize her from someone (or an amalgamation of someones) from their past. The strength of the novel, I think, is the marriage between an uncanny environment and an intensely intimate narration. "Grand" realizations come about from very personal, quotidian and innocuous situations. The preoccupation of the text becomes not about the structure of the society our characters find themselves in, but rather how they navigate life within it. No story about adolescence can be without its requisite rebellion and defiance but here it is strange and diffuse, and cliched moments of anger give way to a melancholy that is stunningly human.
Some books float on the tongue, an assemblage of quotes or scenarios usable in any number of situations. Others dance in the brain, either at the forefront or in the forgotten corner, gestating for future contemplation. This book, however, sits directly in the gut; to remember it is to bear being winded again from those intense emotions that the text leaves behind.
adventurous
mysterious
reflective
The idea of a murder mystery set in a 14th century remote Italian monastery sounds intriguing as a concept. But as a 500+ page novel, so many difficulties must be overcome: a homogenous cast of characters; each boringly devout and celibate and male, anachronistic motivations and investigations of characters playing the part of crime-solvers hundreds of years before the time we begin to associate with them, and an overly pious and simple social hierarchy and setting. And yet The Name of the Rose manages to be quite convincing as a book following from its premise. Beneath the nondescript monastic habits there are a plethora of unique characters, distinct roles within the abbey and motives. Within the worship of Christ exists every manner of fractures, conflicts and competing orders, calls of heresy and blasphemy. Pursuing a murderer are our main characters Adso of Melk and his master: William of Baskerville. Their obvious parallels as proto Watson and Holmes figures are cute but never jarring as their perspectives are justified in a pantheistic outlook on life and faith. For most the book will shock the reader in how much variety exists in such a devout subject and place. A reader will be lulled and perhaps bored by the frequent prayers, latin hymns of monastic life just as quickly as reawakened by musings about great geopolitical machinations, poisons, inexplicable deaths and at the centre: an ancient, mysterious library.
That being said, the book's best component is not retrofitting a fairly modern genre in far older trappings but rather the rich accompanying background, provocative questions about nature and faith, and the constant tension of heresy: be it debates about humour, bloody histories of inquisitions, appreciation of art, pursuit of knowledge, natural philosophy or deep schisms about poverty and property. This feels like a maximalist novel enclosed in the very narrow walls of a monastery - each page of the book is used expansively, evoking so many overlapping symbols, epistemological paranoias, intertextual references, and historical contexts in the midst of a murder mystery that one will quickly lose track as to what is cogent to the murder. Some, I think, will find this annoying and over-written (certainly there is a scene describing the mural of an archway in the beginning of the book that feels deeply pretentious) but it grew on me and is key to really enjoying the novel, which has much more to offer than an Agatha Christie novel in 14th century Catholic garb. While mechanically it should be familiar and satisfying to those whodunnit novels, the subtext and atmosphere and peripheral subplots really elevate the book to something special.
That being said, the book's best component is not retrofitting a fairly modern genre in far older trappings but rather the rich accompanying background, provocative questions about nature and faith, and the constant tension of heresy: be it debates about humour, bloody histories of inquisitions, appreciation of art, pursuit of knowledge, natural philosophy or deep schisms about poverty and property. This feels like a maximalist novel enclosed in the very narrow walls of a monastery - each page of the book is used expansively, evoking so many overlapping symbols, epistemological paranoias, intertextual references, and historical contexts in the midst of a murder mystery that one will quickly lose track as to what is cogent to the murder. Some, I think, will find this annoying and over-written (certainly there is a scene describing the mural of an archway in the beginning of the book that feels deeply pretentious) but it grew on me and is key to really enjoying the novel, which has much more to offer than an Agatha Christie novel in 14th century Catholic garb. While mechanically it should be familiar and satisfying to those whodunnit novels, the subtext and atmosphere and peripheral subplots really elevate the book to something special.
informative
reflective
At first glance, the title "The Dispossessed" immediately prepares a reader for a story about the marginalized part of society, robbed, denigrated and suffering under dispassionate power structures. How unusual then that this novel presents the case for a society, for whom dispossession is the chief organizing principle. What follows is a novel which uses the scantest trappings of science-fiction to explore two - or perhaps three - utopic societies each according to their own value systems with such depth, confidence and sincerity. This novel is far and away one of the most convincing and well-reasoned social speculations, advancing ideas from political anarchists and communists, yet never captive to them. The book explores a far-flung, almost Trotsky-esque arrangement of society which admits neither money, private property, laws or government; and it does so from so many different angles, which both extol and crucially scrutinize the virtues, limits and hardships of such a speculative system. Their society's planet of Anarres is a poor one; life on land is scarce, food security is rare, labour is un-commodified and unremunerated save for individual satisfaction and social standing. But even more than this, the lack of possession is explored in its interpersonal effects; how exactly do we reform our understanding of the family unit, parents and children, friends and lovers without trappings of ownership and possessiveness? The characters in this system find their place in society, suffer communally and face great personal hardships trying to uphold such a state.
Neither didactic nor prescriptive, academic or romantic, this book is an ambitious exploration of how ownership underpins every aspect of life as we know it, told through the eyes of an Anarresti physicist called Shevek as he makes the unprecedented decision to accept a position at an off-world university in the nation of A-Io (a more familiar liberal democracy). The common societal critiques are old news at this point, but through Shevek's perspective we gain new insight into the advanced and sophisticated capitalist utopia, which nevertheless is still slave to its transactional nature and forever keeping its impoverished suppressed and out of sight and mind. Here the instinctive idea of the dispossessed as the struggle of the marginal returns, but in a far more interesting and subtle fashion than merely another story about the plight of the proletariat. Because ultimately, while you may read this book a mere piece of speculative political fiction (and it would be among the best on these merits alone), its central theme seems to be about the margin beyond which is foreign and dangerous. Maybe its the wall of a spaceport; the image of twin planets mutually orbiting a common point with each believing the other to be their moon; a fearful past and a painful present.
This is a fantastic book overflowing with keen, honest observations and speculations about human and the walls and prisons they erect to try and make sense and order out of a hostile world. The prose is not super memorable and I had hoped that the Annares chapters were more stylistically/grammatically distinct than it ended up being (the author does elaborate on the local linguistic deviations of the but declines to write in them for the most part). But the writing does flow well and rarely feels clunky beyond the occasional overexcited use of commas. One part of the book does deal with a much more sci-fi, pseudo-academic outlook on time, which I admit, I struggled to find much real wisdom or subtext or thematic relevance with the rest of the book. But beyond that, this is such a complete and carefully reasoned book that does not cheat the ideas it means to explore and it does so without prejudice or preachiness. Probably the best "speculative fiction" novels I've read.
Neither didactic nor prescriptive, academic or romantic, this book is an ambitious exploration of how ownership underpins every aspect of life as we know it, told through the eyes of an Anarresti physicist called Shevek as he makes the unprecedented decision to accept a position at an off-world university in the nation of A-Io (a more familiar liberal democracy). The common societal critiques are old news at this point, but through Shevek's perspective we gain new insight into the advanced and sophisticated capitalist utopia, which nevertheless is still slave to its transactional nature and forever keeping its impoverished suppressed and out of sight and mind. Here the instinctive idea of the dispossessed as the struggle of the marginal returns, but in a far more interesting and subtle fashion than merely another story about the plight of the proletariat. Because ultimately, while you may read this book a mere piece of speculative political fiction (and it would be among the best on these merits alone), its central theme seems to be about the margin beyond which is foreign and dangerous. Maybe its the wall of a spaceport; the image of twin planets mutually orbiting a common point with each believing the other to be their moon; a fearful past and a painful present.
This is a fantastic book overflowing with keen, honest observations and speculations about human and the walls and prisons they erect to try and make sense and order out of a hostile world. The prose is not super memorable and I had hoped that the Annares chapters were more stylistically/grammatically distinct than it ended up being (the author does elaborate on the local linguistic deviations of the but declines to write in them for the most part). But the writing does flow well and rarely feels clunky beyond the occasional overexcited use of commas. One part of the book does deal with a much more sci-fi, pseudo-academic outlook on time, which I admit, I struggled to find much real wisdom or subtext or thematic relevance with the rest of the book. But beyond that, this is such a complete and carefully reasoned book that does not cheat the ideas it means to explore and it does so without prejudice or preachiness. Probably the best "speculative fiction" novels I've read.
fast-paced
Exit West is a novel that is quite more than it appears. A young man and woman endure the violence and dissolution of peace and order in their native homeland before at last making the decision to leave it behind and brave uncertain paths to find their futures on distant shores. This is a solid middle-brow premise, which will tug at a few heartstrings and allow some cursory reflection on behalf of the relatively well-off middle-class reader before they proceed on with their day. Instead, the story about refugees becomes less about the act and premise of leaving a war-torn past and more about where exactly are they going? When do they know that they've finally arrived? And what is left behind? This novel morphs into more than a personal tale of refugees into one of a world in displacement, where it is not clear when it begins and when it will ever end. In such a transitory world, our two characters Saeed and Nadia are the only ones which are ever named; others are introduced only in relation to them, or denoted by their occupation or anonymous features, and many more appear in vignettes with no attachment at all to the main story beyond the shared kinship of navigating a world increasingly unstuck by way of the conceit of mysterious doors promising transit to different parts of the globe. The writing style is pretty succinct and confident, though the author is far too happy to offer truisms in place of wisdom; which is slightly annoying because there are definitely some poignant and empathetic insights into the struggle of global migrancy hiding underneath somewhat trite sentence construction.
informative
reflective
fast-paced
Steppenwolf is a book full of intriguing ideas with deep and fresh insight into the dynamics of one suicidal man, his alienation from modern society, his relationship with art, his self-portrait and self-annihilation. For a book published in the interbellum years between world wars, it feels harshly prescient and relevant to this present age. That being said, this book does fulfill (to a T!) that tired cliche that literary fiction is ultimately about the wallowing of well-to-do middle-age men in the midst of their privileged existential crises.
The author (at least in this book with the English translation by Kurt Beals) sharply veers towards clarity and repetition in his writing to the point where even the story elements which are meant to be mysterious, supernatural or full of out-of-body spiritual wonder, end up being bled of tension and ambiguity through the writing style. This is my primary complaint with the novel: it's didactic nature is hard to square within the bounds of fiction and ends up feeling more like an extended parable of a pop-philosophy article. The furious heights of the Steppenwolf's brief moments of passion, escaping his own anxieties and self-hood and tumbling head over heels in the multitude of all his natures are muted by prosaic sentences and steady spartan-like description, to the point where a good portion of the novel is quite literally a pseudo-academic essay on the Steppenwolf character. While this embedded treatise is quite an interesting and impressive read in isolation, it again speaks to the unfortunate heavy-handed didactic nature of the book; particularly egregious in this case because the treatise itself was almost entirely unnecessary for the main character of Harry Haller, whose personal journey remarks on many of the same truths and realities of the treatise without resorting to lecturing.
Again, there are some very acute and original insights, melding proto-Jungian ideas with eastern philosophy, inhabiting a spirit full with Nietzsche-coloured nihilism in interwar German high society. But the way in which these truths and ideas manifest onto our main character of Harry Haller leave much to be desired. There is a closing burst of creativity through the novel's climactic Magic Theatre but for the most part any spiritual insight is conveyed by the most unsubtle means, be it an almost meta-textual editorial injection or by way of such famous men as Goethe and Mozart literally monologuing at Harry Haller as to what his problem is and the antidote to living well. This cannot entirely overshadow the wealth of interesting ideas and philosophies permeating the text so I think the novel is very much worth reading and considering, but perhaps has more power as an introduction to concepts explored more deeply elsewhere, than a novel with a singularly lasting impression.
The author (at least in this book with the English translation by Kurt Beals) sharply veers towards clarity and repetition in his writing to the point where even the story elements which are meant to be mysterious, supernatural or full of out-of-body spiritual wonder, end up being bled of tension and ambiguity through the writing style. This is my primary complaint with the novel: it's didactic nature is hard to square within the bounds of fiction and ends up feeling more like an extended parable of a pop-philosophy article. The furious heights of the Steppenwolf's brief moments of passion, escaping his own anxieties and self-hood and tumbling head over heels in the multitude of all his natures are muted by prosaic sentences and steady spartan-like description, to the point where a good portion of the novel is quite literally a pseudo-academic essay on the Steppenwolf character. While this embedded treatise is quite an interesting and impressive read in isolation, it again speaks to the unfortunate heavy-handed didactic nature of the book; particularly egregious in this case because the treatise itself was almost entirely unnecessary for the main character of Harry Haller, whose personal journey remarks on many of the same truths and realities of the treatise without resorting to lecturing.
Again, there are some very acute and original insights, melding proto-Jungian ideas with eastern philosophy, inhabiting a spirit full with Nietzsche-coloured nihilism in interwar German high society. But the way in which these truths and ideas manifest onto our main character of Harry Haller leave much to be desired. There is a closing burst of creativity through the novel's climactic Magic Theatre but for the most part any spiritual insight is conveyed by the most unsubtle means, be it an almost meta-textual editorial injection or by way of such famous men as Goethe and Mozart literally monologuing at Harry Haller as to what his problem is and the antidote to living well. This cannot entirely overshadow the wealth of interesting ideas and philosophies permeating the text so I think the novel is very much worth reading and considering, but perhaps has more power as an introduction to concepts explored more deeply elsewhere, than a novel with a singularly lasting impression.
emotional
inspiring
sad
How to be Both is a warm novel, full of compassion and playfulness, two stories separated by 400 years, in which at first glance all that's shared between them is a wall. As each story unfolds, largely unconscious of one another, poignant themes and motifs establish themselves and repeat, one story to the other; on sexuality, grieving lost mothers and difficult fathers, an indifference to the past, the desire for posterity, the intentionality and subversiveness of art, the tension between remembering and forgetting. In my edition, the story of Franchesco, the self-taught mural painter came first and it not only told a fascinating story from the perspective of a visual artist, but one of strange incorporeal posterity, allowing us to see the artist, the art being made, the art appreciated and the artist's reaction. There's a lot of textual creativity at work in this part and really unique writing that gives a glimpse into an artist whose world is defined by curves and colours, patrons and symbols, bricks and walls. It's an addicting, overwhelming view of the world that permeates into every sentence of this story's narration, from barely conscious early childhood to the final death rattle and it's been a long time since I've read anything quite so picturesque in a modern novel. The story of George comes second, and by contrast, this story has a modern day setting, grappling with a more conventional character with perhaps a more familiar set of struggles. It is told with limited sentimentality but with a deep compassion. The writing is less impressive in this part, perhaps brought down by its contemporary trappings but still relatively ambitious and with strong ties to the former part. Overall a great book, whose title leaves the reader searching through the text for duality it speaks of. No single one may be found, but a bevy opposing ideas and differences, poles for gender, sexuality, tense, and memory, the artisan's load-bearing walls and the artist's murals splayed upon it, the precision and labour of the artist and the transcendent elegance of the art. A very beautiful book.
adventurous
funny
fast-paced
A passable Discworld novel whose study of Golems, slavery and consciousness is a bit sharper and more meaningful than Men at Arms's trite gonne device; but only just. Still full of an ever growing cast of watchmen, Vimes takes centre stage as the lead copper once more and the book is better for it. The city of Ankh-Morpork is also given new depth, a grim glimpse to a state and people of abject poverty where in previous novels the author was content to chalk it up to pauper whimsicality and contrarian charm. There's no perspective better to explain this city which makes no sense, and yet works than Commander Vimes, recovering alcoholic, part-time misanthrope with a pinch of repressed incorrigible idealism. The humour is a step down from Guards, Guards, but that's a fairly high watermark to reach and there are certainly some funny puns and situations though the satire feels a bit half-baked at times. A decent book, but not especially memorable relative to Pratchett's large bibliography of comic achievements.