You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
chrisssl 's review for:
How to Be Both
by Ali Smith
emotional
inspiring
sad
How to be Both is a warm novel, full of compassion and playfulness, two stories separated by 400 years, in which at first glance all that's shared between them is a wall. As each story unfolds, largely unconscious of one another, poignant themes and motifs establish themselves and repeat, one story to the other; on sexuality, grieving lost mothers and difficult fathers, an indifference to the past, the desire for posterity, the intentionality and subversiveness of art, the tension between remembering and forgetting. In my edition, the story of Franchesco, the self-taught mural painter came first and it not only told a fascinating story from the perspective of a visual artist, but one of strange incorporeal posterity, allowing us to see the artist, the art being made, the art appreciated and the artist's reaction. There's a lot of textual creativity at work in this part and really unique writing that gives a glimpse into an artist whose world is defined by curves and colours, patrons and symbols, bricks and walls. It's an addicting, overwhelming view of the world that permeates into every sentence of this story's narration, from barely conscious early childhood to the final death rattle and it's been a long time since I've read anything quite so picturesque in a modern novel. The story of George comes second, and by contrast, this story has a modern day setting, grappling with a more conventional character with perhaps a more familiar set of struggles. It is told with limited sentimentality but with a deep compassion. The writing is less impressive in this part, perhaps brought down by its contemporary trappings but still relatively ambitious and with strong ties to the former part. Overall a great book, whose title leaves the reader searching through the text for duality it speaks of. No single one may be found, but a bevy opposing ideas and differences, poles for gender, sexuality, tense, and memory, the artisan's load-bearing walls and the artist's murals splayed upon it, the precision and labour of the artist and the transcendent elegance of the art. A very beautiful book.