chrisssl 's review for:

A Gentleman in Moscow by Amor Towles
3.0
lighthearted relaxing

When you setup a book premise about an aristocrat in Moscow in the aftermath of the Russian Revolution and enduring such events as two world wars, the Ukrainian famine and the rise of the Stalinist totalitarian state, it surely prepares a reader for a tale of dramatic social upheaval and ways of life turned on their head, bewilderment on a nation-wide scale.  But this book instead trades national transformation for meditations in quiet, comfortable domesticity.  The overhaul of political ideals translates into quotidian observations about hotel guests.   The immediate curtailment of personal freedom and the growing influence of party loyalty and the state-surveillance apparatus is evinced in interpersonal conflicts between the staff of the Grand Metropol Hotel.  And the furious passing of time from a barely industrialized state to the beginnings of a cold war of ideology takes shape through a young girl in a hotel, and eventually, her own young girl as well.

Our protagonist, Count Alexander Ilyich Rostov, is condemned by the victorious Bolsheviks in the wake of the Russian Revolution, to permanent house arrest within the walls of the palatial Metropol Hotel in Moscow.  We see through his life as the decades whisk by and the new Russia takes shape in the microcosm of a hotel, observed from the hotel roof at night, tasted and experienced by the shortage or surplus or change in culinary ingredients and most importantly, addressed by a revolving cast of characters entering and leaving the hotel over the years.  There is a remarkable similarity between this book and something like A General Theory of Oblivion by José Eduardo Agualusa wherein the main character is confined to quarters while the outside society undergoes revolutionary upheaval.  The tricky part about this is that the main character has no true agency in such stories - rather the story generally happens to them (this weakness is also present in something like Circe by Madeline Miller).  It  happens to this book as well, and although it adopts a sophomoric playfulness in prose style (in which Tolstoy, Chekhov, Pushkin, Turgenev and Dostoyevsky are referenced as much as humanly possible) I can see how many will not find the story especially compelling.  Rostov remains a great character through which to tell a story of quiet human dignity amidst difficult circumstances - but in the end those difficult circumstances rarely feel like proper challenges at all.  The book has an ambitious lack of plot or conflict - beyond one acute episode, Count Rostov's house arrest is never seen as some existential obstacle to overcome or make peace with.  The other weakness with the book is that it never found a way of addressing, even slantwise, any actual merits of the Revolution itself as the Count was and is too far removed from the plight of the proletariat to offer any perspective of contrast to his own privileged experiences in the increasingly draconian Soviet state.  While the Count remains a memorable character throughout the book, in the end the story was somewhat middling, ideologically ambivalent and humanistically sincere (though quite trite at times).