chrisssl 's review for:

The Dispossessed by Ursula K. Le Guin
4.0
informative reflective

At first glance, the title "The Dispossessed" immediately prepares a reader for a story about the marginalized part of society, robbed, denigrated and suffering under dispassionate power structures.  How unusual then that this novel presents the case for a society, for whom dispossession is the chief organizing principle.  What follows is a novel which uses the scantest trappings of science-fiction to explore two - or perhaps three - utopic societies each according to their own value systems with such depth, confidence and sincerity.  This novel is far and away one of the most convincing and well-reasoned social speculations, advancing ideas from political anarchists and communists, yet never captive to them.  The book explores a far-flung, almost Trotsky-esque arrangement of society which admits neither money, private property, laws or government; and it does so from so many different angles, which both extol and crucially scrutinize the virtues, limits and hardships of such a speculative system.  Their society's planet of Anarres is a poor one; life on land is scarce, food security is rare, labour is un-commodified and unremunerated save for individual satisfaction and social standing.  But even more than this, the lack of possession is explored in its interpersonal effects; how exactly do we reform our understanding of the family unit, parents and children, friends and lovers without trappings of ownership and possessiveness?  The characters in this system find their place in society, suffer communally and face great personal hardships trying to uphold such a state.

Neither didactic nor prescriptive, academic or romantic, this book is an ambitious exploration of how ownership underpins every aspect of life as we know it, told through the eyes of an Anarresti physicist called Shevek as he makes the unprecedented decision to accept a position at an off-world university in the nation of A-Io (a more familiar liberal democracy).  The common societal critiques are old news at this point, but through Shevek's perspective we gain new insight into the advanced and sophisticated capitalist utopia, which nevertheless is still slave to its transactional nature and forever keeping its impoverished suppressed and out of sight and mind.  Here the instinctive idea of the dispossessed as the struggle of the marginal returns, but in a far more interesting and subtle fashion than merely another story about the plight of the proletariat.  Because ultimately, while you may read this book a mere piece of speculative political fiction (and it would be among the best on these merits alone), its central theme seems to be about the margin beyond which is foreign and dangerous.  Maybe its the wall of a spaceport; the image of twin planets mutually orbiting a common point with each believing the other to be their moon; a fearful past and a painful present.

This is a fantastic book overflowing with keen, honest observations and speculations about human and the walls and prisons they erect to try and make sense and order out of a hostile world.  The prose is not super memorable and I had hoped that the Annares chapters were more stylistically/grammatically distinct than it ended up being (the author does elaborate on the local linguistic deviations of the but declines to write in them for the most part).  But the writing does flow well and rarely feels clunky beyond the occasional overexcited use of commas.  One part of the book does deal with a much more sci-fi, pseudo-academic outlook on time, which I admit, I struggled to find much real wisdom or subtext or thematic relevance with the rest of the book.  But beyond that, this is such a complete and carefully reasoned book that does not cheat the ideas it means to explore and it does so without prejudice or preachiness.  Probably the best "speculative fiction" novels I've read.