92 reviews by:

chrisssl

Filter
dark slow-paced

Blood Meridian is the most unrelentingly nihilistic book I've read.  Here is a portrait of a bleak, barren world of the frontier, peopled by savages and men far more evil, where scalps are the currency of the day and on and on it goes, day after day, inescapably.  The book has a mysterious, biblical and arresting beginning, already shocking the reader early with scenes of surprising sadism, and yet these bloody cruel affairs are but the prelude for a novel marked by escalating and horrendous images of violence.  A difficult read, nigh on impossible if not for the frightful and profound writing that vacillates between terse Hemingway like sentences and vivid, elaborate descriptions with one eye to the hypnotic visual poetry of Paradise Lost.

We follow a series of tiny characters born into this giant evil world, impenetrable in their deeper thoughts.  In place of this, we get instead the most detailed depiction of the fading frontier, day after day: the dusty wastes and dry cracked plains, the vastness of the sky, the despairing emptiness and bones of earth and life, then labyrinthine highlands, mountain-passes and switch-backs amid deep forests and snows, primal deserts and a country of strange pre-historic features.  This is an evil, hateful world and all the time we follow our characters through these forsaken landscapes we hope they find reprieve from the ever-present dangers of the West for the safety of the few settlements out there; only then to dread the fact that the settlements themselves are now in deep mortal peril from this gang of men we follow.

The setting is brutal, the violence inescapable and it can certainly feel depressing while reading a good middle chunk of the book; with the depravity, scene after scene, (no matter how wondrously written) approaching a novel both gratuitous and pointless.  But I would urge any who feel this way to keep on to the end, where the horror and conditioning of the novel prove entirely relevant for the truth and profound questions at the heart of the novel; terminating in a sort of dreadful clarity while leaving so many prior moments in an ambiguity that should leave the reader pondering over their meaning for weeks and months after.  An uncomfortable read but full of staggering prose, an unforgettable character in Judge Holden, and a thought-provoking ending.
adventurous funny

An surprisingly ambitious followup to Master & Commander that genuinely impresses in its breadth to write beyond the naval ambitions of Captain Jack Aubrey and his friend, Dr. Stephen Maturin.  The characters are more land-bound that they are at sea, dodging stiffed creditors, navigating naval bureaucracy and politics and playing suitors to women of high society and all the messiness that arises from it.  I'm not disappointed in the relative lack of sea action or rich naval description (there are certain vivid albeit brief episodes of this), but the book seemed to go on and on, in search of a clear purpose.  The meandering was unintuitive and the story felt circular, incestuous and strangely provincial, navigating the uneasy peace of Napoleonic France, journeys across the Spanish mountains and Mediterranean waters in episodes that feel like they could be arbitrarily reordered without much too much loss in coherence.  There is a pleasant correction in the lack of any women in the first novel and these are quite enjoyable and realized characters, the romantic adventures something out of Jane Austen  but they, along with everything else in the book, is not given enough attention for a story that is uncertain where it should go.
challenging dark funny fast-paced

I came to this short book expecting a unique but easy, breezy read-through that I could use to decompress from some of the thicker, denser novels I'd finished lately.  Boy was I wrong.  In under 200 pages, this book manages to be funny, profound and quite challenging, something which I needed to carefully think about after reading a dozen pages in each sitting rather than something I could easily inhale in a day.  The premise of this book is that we experience life through the eyes of powerless narrator in a world in which nourishment comes from the toilet, material possessions arrive via divine fire and the abyss of the trash heap, men break up with women before starting their relationship, and everyone, everywhere always seems to be giving you money.  The narrator is a consciousness moving backwards in time beginning at the end of the 20th century, entirely ignorant of the natural way of arranging cause and effect, slave to the ignorant whims of his host: Tod Friendly, incapable of any action beyond thought and observation.

This is not the first time I've seen a premise like this, but it is the first time I've seen a book commit to this idea to such laborious extent.  The result is a truly strange thought experiment that is so contrary to the way we understand stories and requires us to constantly and actively think in order to decipher what is happening in the perspective of someone travelling backwards.  But more than a thought experiment, it rises to a fine novel in it's own right, which manages to construct such a strange and poignant series of observations by flipping one dimension on its head.  The beginning of the book is charming in the narrator's wonder, his curious innocent observations and his sad bewilderment with the incomprehensible nature of the world.  The writing is well-thought and intelligent, but after the first hundred pages a reader might ask if there's anything more to this book: sure it's entertaining and occasionally thought-provoking to witness the 20th century in reverse, but is it at all cogent or applicable to our cause-effect world?  Is it any more than creative but irrelevant fantasy?  Yes.  Because rather than being just a more fleshed out version of that famed reversed film-reel in Slaughterhouse V in which atrocities and wars become visions of healing and restoration, the book forges ahead into events of historic horror, in which the direction one perceives both cancels out its atrocity and accentuates it to a heady degree.  I must remain vague for plot purposes, but it works to such a breathtaking creative effect, sticking to the rules established in the book, but changing the effects dramatically.

The story is thought-provoking and rarely cheats its own rules, however I find the prose to be a bit of a weakness.  It is clearly trying, reaching for profundity in occasional philosophical moments, but these never work all that well and these sections become awkward and unwieldy in their confused imagery and zany sophomoric imitations of stronger post-war writers like Vonnegut, Roth and Updike.  The story provides much depth to stew over and works  magically, in spite of a somewhat ambitious but cluttered style of prose.
dark funny sad

Generally, I expect a collection of short stories to not only wow on an individual story level, in that brief, compact way that only these short-form narratives can, but also impress on a collective level, with a great diversity of tone or creativity.  This collection works on the first level but falters on the second.  The author's writing is incredibly intentional and specific, and will floor you with a perfect oppressive, rote and occasionally hilarious style of prose that raises the story to fantastic heights.  Of these, Pastoralia, Sea Oak, and The End of FIRPO In the World are the standout stories.  Pastoralia is a powerful story on the numbing, euphemistic cruelty of management, and doing-the-job, in the face of harrowing personal struggles, uncaring corporate bosses and the tension of class solidarity.  Sea Oak is devastating in its portrayal of sad people born into sad circumstances, unable to escape the gravity of their tragic situation and a horrifying perversion of those who pass through life and back again unthanked and unfulfilled.  The End of FIRPO In The World is a wild ride in the mind of a spastic kid, the prose is just hilarious and perfectly matching that preadolescence without being overbearing, tiresome or patronizing.

On the other hand, George Saunders has a talent for richly and unreservedly describing the neuroses and invasive imaginations of maladjusted, self-absorbed old men with a lack of sexual confidence and unexamined misogyny.  This is depressing but a fine enough story...once.  But this same archetype is repeated in more than half of the stories and not with a great deal of variety.  I don't mind the portrayal or the sadness and lack of transformation, but it feels very repetitive; and in a collection as short as this, that's definitely not a good thing.
dark reflective slow-paced

Love in a Time of Cholera is a novel that asks you to re-examine everything you thought you knew about love, or time or even cholera.  A love story, of sorts, it's more a story about love in so many aspects that move between poetic serenades, quotidian conjugal life, agonizing unrequited suits, disgusting and depraved delusions, and the loneliness of growing old.  You are invited to entertain these disturbing, contrarian suggestions of love as a manifestation of sickness, of mistaking obsession for passion, and the desolation of trying to refute what is with what was.

Less dense and more streamlined than the author's masterpiece: 100 Years of Solitude, this is nonetheless an insanely well written novel, in which it feels like the author is operating at the height of his abilities, easily leading you down one path only to swerve to another, then doing it again.  And drawing so many parallels with other characters, the setting and its history.  The structure is brilliant, the characters so deeply and diligently realized and interesting and tragic, and the subtext is infinitely refined.  The prose is wistful and full of Marquez's customary wonderful language, although I don't think it's quite as memorable as 100 Years of Solitude.  It's worth noting the English translation of this novel is done by Edith Grossman, not Gregory Rabassa (who did Chronicle of a Death Foretold and 100 Years of Solitude among others) so that might very well be the reason.

This novel can be terribly touching as well as so revolting you must always question whether you are reading a story of love, or a story of pestilence and depravity.  What is also remarkable is how perfectly the author also weaves in the threads of memory, of passing time and nostalgia, and how it aligns and works perfectly with the post-colonial setting of this unnamed city of the Viceroys on the shores of the Caribbean.  In equal measure with its discourse on love, there's a great preoccupation with time and how it works on people.  Not only the indignity of age (though this is examined more colourfully and thoroughly in this book than any I've read), but the tension of a city looking out to sea where lays an irretrievably sunken Spanish ship laden with gold pilfered from a previous age of atrocity; and a city whose river leads deep into the heartland where innumerable civil wars are fought over the future beyond independence.  Despite it's more focused plot, limited characters and lack of any magical realism, I'd say this novel is just as ambitious and well-written as 100 Years of Solitude, if not quite reaching those lofty heights. 
adventurous lighthearted

A novel that takes you deep into the life of the Royal Navy, following Captain Jack Aubrey and the crew of His Majesty's ship/sloop: the Sophie.  It's a fascinating, detailed and very pleasant look at the goings on of ship actions about the time of Napoleon, Nelson, and when England vied with French and Spanish powers for control of the Mediterranean.  There is a great deal of nautical terminology to be dealt with up front but the author supplies us with the helpful perspective of fellow nautical greenhorn: Dr. Steven Maturin, in whose neophyte eyes we are eased into the strange world of life at sea.  One should not be discouraged when these expository chapters emerge (it is far less demanding than equivalent whaling chapters in Moby Dick) and what's more, the book does not demand an expertise on these matters, and you'll find yourself learning and relearning the various aspects of naval curios during the novel.  There is no solemnity and emptiness of the Pequod's journey; in contrast, the Sophie's Mediterranean prowls are teeming with action, friendly and unfriendly vessels and furious activity.  There is little tedium to be found in the book, and whenever the action pauses a while, the novel is carried by the charming dynamic of the captain and his surgeon to keep the reader engaged.  This is a nice little historical novel, but one which doesn't really have any sense of progression or build up; a series of incidents, more like, that the reader is glad to have read but derives a bit less satisfaction from the book as a whole.  It is wholly apparent that much of the value from this book is that it kicks off a series of sequels to come.
challenging

There’s no beating around the bush: Cannonball is the most syntactically difficult book I’ve  read.  To call the writing wildly inexplicable is to somehow understate the amount of madness and purposeful incoherence and turbulence to be found in the prose.  This makes Faulkner’s and Virginia Woolf’s modernist stream-of-consciousness prose look positively quaint, linear and pedestrian in comparison.  The experience of reading this is like having a story shouted at you in a language you don’t understand while you’re underwater and something is spinning you head over heels, trying desperately to grasp any sort of meaning from the words swimming off the page in seemingly arbitrary sequences before it is untimely ripped away and you are disoriented again, summersaulting and drowning endlessly in white water.

That doesn't sound fun, and in some ways it isn't, but the nonchalant madness of the prose did not stop me from continuing all the way to the end, and that must be something to the book's credit.  The author spins a fascinating, mysterious premise: a combat photographer is at the poolside of one of the deposed Saddam Hussein's palaces under which, lies something, and under that: one part of a larger ancient Mesopotamian system of horizontal wells where a message, a hidden interview from Jesus Christ himself has been travelling across time and under land, promising a new gospel of profit, self-interest and entrepreneurship.  And there appears, absolutely inexplicably, a fat 300 pound age-ambiguous Chinese man, a childhood friend of the combat photographer, jumping off a diving board into that palatial pool.

This book is unapologetically difficult and slant, yet if careful attention is paid, I think a patient reader can suss out the majority of events that occur and even some of the rich layers of subtext.  The questions of who this fat Chinese man is, how he got there, why he's diving, who the combat photographer is and how they are connected, what the deal is with these Scrolls, and larger still: what the hell is this war all about... these mysteries gird a novel that almost has contempt for every convention of the medium (grammar and most standards of punctuation being the first casualties).  On a sentence by sentence level (whenever McElroy chooses to actually write it sentences...) , the novel is completely unpredictable; words are used and mis-used, characters have dialogues that are so broken and scattered they might as well be in insane.  It pushes the reader into an unrelenting and baffling state of paranoia; it might well exhaust you in its impenetrability.  But...and I can't even believe I'm saying this, there is something special and extraordinary at the core of the book: extracting endless parallels between its form and the act of diving, of backstroke, competition, doing-the-job, water, instantaneous rates of change, motion dissected and held in place by a befuddled cameraman, a surprisingly touching friendship and sincere but alarming intimacy.

I don't know who this book is for or if I even understand the better part of it.  And it's a shock to myself to say it but...I kinda liked it all the same.
informative reflective

This is a set of nine science fiction slanted short-stories, all but one of which is excellent.  A number of thought-provoking ideas are explored in settings that are bursting in creativity and deep compassion.  Those seeking high-minded concepts exploring free will, parallel universes, time travel, artificial consciousness, memory and entropy will find a lot to chew on.  Those searching for stories with deep empathy and exploration of human anxieties and tragedies will leave incredibly satisfied.  With perhaps one exception to a notably mediocre (and very brief) fifth story (Dacey's Patent Automatic Nanny), the author effortlessly marries lofty technological and scientific speculations with the intimacy of the humans who bear, create and explore these new settings.  These stories are very accessible and errs to the side of being a bit explicit in its themes (in contrast to, say, Borges).  The prose is relatively smooth but unambitious; two stories in particular (The Truth of Fact, the Truth of Feeling and Omphalos) felt like their terrific ideas and explorations were hamstrung by a writing ability that is serviceable but not much more than that.  Still, this is a high-watermark in terms of science-fiction short stories and this much acclaimed author has earned every bit of his reputation.
challenging

 So here’s a poem of ten thousand lines of unrhymed blank verse, retelling the oldest story in Western literature.  We're thrown right into the middle of things: Satan and the rebel Spirits awakening after a nine day-long fall from Heaven’s grace, through the confusion of Chaos and Night, all the way to this new fiery realm called Hell.  The non-rhyming verses, the complex language and the in media res start make for a bewildering and challenging beginning.  But if one can endure a demanding first dozen or so pages, and start to find grounding with either the strange but beautiful language or more familiar elements of the story of Genesis’ Garden of Eden, you find yourself with an absolutely fascinating reading experience. 
 
With sentences that go on for half a page, strung and re-strung by loose scaffolding of phrases and line-broken clauses (even by poetry standards this feels unusually stretched), and without rhyming lines, it’s more important than ever to read this giant epic aloud, not only for comprehensibility but for an appreciation of the writing.  The non-standard accented English, elisions of vowels and the sheer number of pages of poetry flow better and feel less discombobulating when spoken and/or read slowly.  It will get less challenging the further into the twelve books you get and towards the end, what was originally archaic and abstruse becomes unbelievably sublime poetry.  It’s less accessible than Shakespearean verse, and isn’t as punchy, but it’s an undeniably beautiful and unique use of language. 
 
I think a general knowledge of at least the Book of Genesis (1, 2, 3) is mandatory to appreciate Paradise Lost.  It’s a retelling of a creation myth but so clearly belonging to its own time.  Many interesting elements of the enlightened English age find their way here: a modern understanding of cosmology, predestination, heliocentric vs. geocentric models, modern warfare and strifes of succession.  One of the more fascinating inventions in Paradise Lost is the description of the original celestial war which saw Satan and his allies fall from Heaven.  It should not be understated how radical it is that Milton not only introduces Jesus as a fully-fledge character from the beginning, but that he assumes a militant role - more like Henry V than the carpenter’s son so familiar to us.  Nor should we fail to notice that Satan’s original enmity to Heaven comes only when God introduces his Son as sovereign over all angelic powers; the ensuing civil war should bring to mind many contests over the English crown, which are to the author Milton, intimate and lived history.  Beyond this, Paradise Lost is clearly and intentionally competing with the grandeur of Homer and Virgil.  Milton works tirelessly to reconcile Greek and Christian mythology and to reference those characters - seemingly trying to subsume the Aeneid and the Iliad under his own unifying tale.  I can’t imagine any without some heavy classics background will catch a majority of the references of Greek, Mesopotamian and Egyptian origin. 
 
Satan is by far the best part of the epic.  He’s the most interesting character, what depth and doubt he possesses!  His self-loathing and animus to God are surprisingly original compared to what I was expecting (having myself a long but not deep relationship with the Christian text),  His lonely journey from Hell through Chaos to Paradise reminds so heavily of Odysseus’ misadventures at sea, but even more strange and nefarious.  Adam is bland in comparison and Eve…well Eve brings us to the worst part of this epic.  I feel fairly desensitized to poor portrayals of women in literature but the sheer unapologetic misogyny dripping from every line involving Eve is so distracting I almost thought it was initially some sort of satire.  But nope!  There is no mention of Eve here without unironic unrelenting condescension of her inferior, baser nature and wherever she isn’t being actively tempted and blamed for following the temptation that has been preordained, she’s so deferential and self-disparaging to Adam and the angelic spirits, she might as well be worm.  I don’t think even the Bible was this blatantly patriarchal.  It makes an otherwise interestingly written story about the fall of man distracting with Milton’s insistence on Man’s dominance, superiority and purity over Woman. 
 
Beyond Eve, not all the books of this giant epic work for me: the six days of creation are a relatively safe and unoriginal rehashing, and some verses will be filled with nothing but dozens upon dozens of allusions to events, places and people of esoteric early antiquity.  I find the more original sections of the epic, detailing Satan’s pre-adventures before becoming the serpent in the garden to be more compelling and richly written than Adam and Eve’s temptation and fall, but the whole epic is superbly written and will surprise the reader in its deviations from biblical canon.  A challenging but highly rewarding read if one has the time to work their way through this epic poem. 
mysterious sad

This feels like a novel entirely contingent on the reader being in the proper mood when reading it.  Fortunately, I was in such a state of mind that I could appreciate this little book.  A man returns to a bleak remote village, fulfilling his mother's dying wish to seek out his father.  This is indeed the premise of the book, and yet the book has nothing to do with this.  There is no real plot here, just the digressive half-caught musings of various ghostly memories of the people that once inhabited the village of Comala - their pains and regrets and ambition.  It's almost burying the lede to call this a ghost story; the spectres here are not so much employed as spooky mysteries that are encountered over the course of the book, but rather suffuse into the narration itself: invading a straightforward premise with a multitude of perspectives from different times and different people.  It's disorientating and distracting and designed to carry the reader's attention away from the premise (indeed at one point, the reader has no choice but to do so), and the sooner the reader can get onboard with this, the better the novel can be appreciated.  There is some distinct and very striking writing here (in the English translation) that stands up to some of the novels which would later take inspiration from this book (i.e. 100 Years of Solitude).  In particular, the author has a talent for wondrously and without repetition, finding ways to describe the skyscape that takes one's breath away.  And each ghostly perspective in the book carries sincere and beautifully rendered longings and disappointments.  A short, fabulous read to be experienced more so than neurotically analyzed for hidden meaning and allusions.  If you're in the mood for eerie vibes, meandering and beautiful vignettes and a reading experience that is acute but difficult to summarize, this book is for you!