You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

chrisssl 's review for:

The Dutch House by Ann Patchett
3.0

It's a testament to the understated but strong writing that the author can manage to hold my interest in a book about a cliché premise of orphaned children, an evil stepmother and lost birthrights in the middle-class,  post-war America.  Even writing this description seems unattractive but the book manages to be quite engaging and bring surprising depth to a tired collection of archetypes.  The Dutch House, a pre-depression relic, the strange lost familial home becomes that classical device - a fixed object around which different characters have wildly varied relationships with.  Rest assured, there is far more going on with this house and story than a symbolic nostalgia for simpler, pastoral times of childhood and innocence.  People experience and are changed by memory differently, both their own memories and those of others, and its a fascinating bit of subtext that runs through the whole book.  One of the central tensions I found is being unable to exactly locate particular scenes chronologically (involving sitting in a car outside the Dutch house); this playfulness and instability with regards to perspective keeps the reader engaged throughout the main character (Danny's) journey from age 3 through to his fifties.  But it is his assertive sister Maeve who truly shines above her more passive younger brother.  I'm not sure this book has left a huge impression on me, and I think the ending is too tidy for my liking, but it's a solid piece of writing that makes for an intriguing read.