328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
slow-paced

Wow I really hated this book. It was one long slow boring ass plod to the finish line and I asked myself multiple times why I was bothering with finishing it but I guess just trying to eke out my money’s worth. Yes, I bought this book. I wish I hadn’t. 

This was my first Grady Hendrix and I would not have picked up a book about pregnant and traumatized teenage girls had I known it was written by a middle aged dude. The whole time, it just felt kinda creepy. I realized Grady is a man about 1/4 of the way through lol JUMP SCARE

It’s about pregnant teens in the 70s forced to go to a home where they surrender their babies, and while there find a book that entices them into doing witchcraft. There’s a spiraling convoluted plot that doesn’t make a lot of sense and actually doesn’t seem to matter anyway.

The characters were barely interesting, the black characters were just there to support white journeys or actually just be a cut and paste magical negro trope. There was a 14 year old girl impregnated by her middle-aged preacher. Just ick. Also this was supposed to be about witches but the witchcraft was just so lackluster. The acknowledgments say the first draft had no witches at all and I believe it because everything about it felt like an afterthought or marketing choice. Witches are big now, can we add that in?

It was also so freakin long and didn’t need to be because we feel every page of that length. So much is repeated and reiterated it’s like an editor never even touched this, or was scared to say what they really thought. Also not sure why the witches always had to be naked and riding branches clinging to trees? Wtf?

This also contained one of the most traumatic birth stories I’ve ever read—needlessly so. 

Also, if you’re looking for horror—this is neither scary nor suspenseful. It’s scary how bad it is in every way but I don’t think that was intentional.

I’m just not sure what the point of this book was, it felt like a dirty outlet for Hendrix’s weird teenage girl fixation. 

Could not possibly recommend. Worst book of the year.
adventurous dark

Hiiii long time no see—the dregs of winter blues have set in, the world is burning, I slipped on the ice and hurt myself, got the flu and couldn’t walk… so I thought it best to just ✨opt out✨ for awhile lol. 

And then bookclub happened and I had to fight tooth and nail to defend this gorgeous gorgeous book I (and one other member) loved so much that just didn’t resonate with anyone else. Cue the tears. No really. I got so emotional talking about this book I cried and then I think at least semi emotionally-manipulated others to increase their rating. When I tell you I am emotionally hanging on ✨by a thread✨ 😌. It’s fine everything is fine.

Bookclub read and really enjoyed her other book The Snow Child during our first season, I actually loved this one so much more—but that wasn’t the consensus. 

Black Woods, Blue Sky is a dark Beauty and the Beast retelling set in the Alaskan wilds. Birdie, a young mother struggling to provide for her daughter and fighting against her base nature falls for a reclusive odd ball and follows him to his cabin (kid in tow) off the grid where she hopes to build a new idyllic life pressed up against the wild.

What followed for me, was a nuanced portrayal of nature v man, a struggle to be your better self perched tight on the edge of a razor, the way empathy, forgiveness and hope play against our rationality when it comes to abuse, addiction and the people we love. A debate on what we owe our children, our community and ourselves. All told in the most striking and visceral prose. I LOVED it and gave it 5 stars.

What followed for the rest of bookclub was a weirdo cringe mess of a relationship, a host of characters that were either terrible or just not relatable, and an irritating ending. 

I like to believe they were all just wrong. 😑 

lol this is why bookclub is so much fun though and the conversation was SO GOOD and longer and deeper than any other meeting yet.

But they were still mostly wrong about this one, I’ll die on this hill 🤣
emotional reflective slow-paced

Good Dirt by Charmaine Wilkerson
✅ audiobook provided by @penguinrandomhouse through the @librofm influencer program 

I really enjoy a generational family saga. In Good Dirt we’re with the Freemans—one of the only Black families in a wealthy enclave in New England. 10-year-old Ebby witnesses her brother get murdered during a home invasion and we see how that loss shapes her as an adult. Tracing the generations back through the passing of a historic jar through their family, we’re introduced to the enslaved potters who made uncredited beautiful work, and used it as an instrument of escape; the newly free Black sailors that worked on whaling and trade ships always at risk of being captured again; the road to freedom and the legacy and trauma of the journey passed down through generations; how eventual affluence and generational wealth might insulate but ultimately can’t protect the Freemans from prejudice and violence.

This was a solid read, the history of enslaved Black potters and free sailors was fascinating, and I’d have like to stay with them even longer. I liked main character Ebby but found her story centred around losing her white fiancé then running into him at an Airbnb in France kind of out of place to the rest of the novel. It almost felt as though I were reading two very different books but, not in a necessarily bad way. Enjoyable but constantly shifting wavelengths.

I found myself really enjoying this when I turned it on, but a bit forgettable when I wasn’t actively listening. And at times I got a little lost in the timeline. But, the audiobook is narrated by January LaVoy who is phenomenal so I was able to forgive any issues I had with the novel and just be carried along for the ride.

I haven’t read Black Cake but feel like I definitely want to prioritize it now!

adventurous challenging dark lighthearted

Fairytale retellings are some of my favourite things to read—and some of Cunningham’s stories really pack a punch here, but after a while the acerbic cynical tone started to grate on me. 

I liked when the stories are reimagining what might have happened before or after the original tale—like with Little Man which interrogates Rumpelstiltskin’s desire to be a father, or the brother in A Wild Swan who isn’t fully transformed and has one swan wing instead of an arm causing a descent into alcoholism and depression. It always felt clever the adding of whys and hows. But other tales like Jacked with a more modern Jack and the Beanstalk or Her Hair retelling Rapunzel felt less creative and more filler, adding nothing much to the retelling. Often, trying to include “modern” elements to the tale didn’t work for me at all and felt gimmicky and forced.

But, certain stories like A Monkey’s Paw or Beasts where small clever changes make a big impact made the lesser  more average stories and somewhat off putting tone worth journeying through anyhow.
challenging dark emotional hopeful reflective sad medium-paced

milktooth by @jaimeburnet 
✅ARC #gifted to me by @nimbuspub for review

Oh my god I loved this book so much. From the very first page I couldn’t put this beautiful book down and I truly didn’t want it to end.

Milktooth is about queer and unlucky in love Sorcha. She’s in her early 30s and tired of the messy relationships of her past and ready to settle down, maybe become a “real” adult whatever that means. Enter Chris—Leonardo Dicaprio lesbian lookalike, who seems like the type of person she could make a life with, if only Sorcha could be a little better at pleasing her and her mercurial moods, or stop provoking her into sullen jealous fights, get her friends to accept her, or figure out how to tiptoe around the triggers buried like mines around them…… right? 

When Sorcha and Chris move to rural Cape Breton to start building that idyllic life together, alone and isolated, things reach a breaking point, a crossroads, and Sorcha must step into the only future she can live with. But what does that look like—and at what cost?

What a compelling read this was! Set in Halifax, Cape Breton and Scotland, the locales were perfect side characters to this gloomy story of the insidious and quiet abuse that can exist in relationships—and the way you rearrange reality in your mind to make it something you can accept and live with. I loved the characters, Sorcha is so relatable and the way her mind is described as having little workers in it were so endearing and quirky. All the relationships in this story were so authentic and felt real to me and the way the plot unfurls felt inevitable in the best way. 

I loved the showcase on Gaelic language and the way sexual identity and preference is explored and allowed to evolve. Just a really gorgeous story with beautiful writing. This is probably going to be my favourite cover of the year and I’m so glad the story lived up to it! I think this book might be the one to beat this year! 

Highly recommend for lovers of litfic, sad girls, queer relationships, ppl struggling at adulting, and found family. 

Waaaah I want to read more of Sorcha 😭 also yes I did cry at the end. 5 stars and my whole heart
adventurous emotional funny informative lighthearted fast-paced
lighthearted mysterious tense fast-paced

Juicy, entertaining and totally fun—The Favourites is like an exclusive tell-all memoir merged with documentary-style descriptions and interview clips about Ice Dancing’s most notorious couple, Katarina Shaw and Heath Rocha. 

Skating together since childhood each with their own traumatic backstories to contend with, we watch as they put everything they have on the line for a dream, falling in love and destroying each other emotionally in the process.

Very much in the vein of Taylor Jenkins Reid’s best sellers (so much so, she’s thanked in the acknowledgments) Layne Fargo does deliver a very similar vibe that will appeal to so many—although I think her characters on the page might be a little shallow, she could have edited it a bit shorter, and her plot sort of flails a little towards the end, when listening to this on audio almost all of that is forgiven with the amazing full cast narration. 

Another case of a good book getting a whole lot better on audio thanks to the amazing cinematic listening experience. I enjoyed every second of it! Highly recommend if you pick this up you do so on audio!