Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Good Dirt
by Charmaine Wilkerson
emotional
reflective
slow-paced
Good Dirt by Charmaine Wilkerson
✅ audiobook provided by @penguinrandomhouse through the @librofm influencer program
I really enjoy a generational family saga. In Good Dirt we’re with the Freemans—one of the only Black families in a wealthy enclave in New England. 10-year-old Ebby witnesses her brother get murdered during a home invasion and we see how that loss shapes her as an adult. Tracing the generations back through the passing of a historic jar through their family, we’re introduced to the enslaved potters who made uncredited beautiful work, and used it as an instrument of escape; the newly free Black sailors that worked on whaling and trade ships always at risk of being captured again; the road to freedom and the legacy and trauma of the journey passed down through generations; how eventual affluence and generational wealth might insulate but ultimately can’t protect the Freemans from prejudice and violence.
This was a solid read, the history of enslaved Black potters and free sailors was fascinating, and I’d have like to stay with them even longer. I liked main character Ebby but found her story centred around losing her white fiancé then running into him at an Airbnb in France kind of out of place to the rest of the novel. It almost felt as though I were reading two very different books but, not in a necessarily bad way. Enjoyable but constantly shifting wavelengths.
I found myself really enjoying this when I turned it on, but a bit forgettable when I wasn’t actively listening. And at times I got a little lost in the timeline. But, the audiobook is narrated by January LaVoy who is phenomenal so I was able to forgive any issues I had with the novel and just be carried along for the ride.
I haven’t read Black Cake but feel like I definitely want to prioritize it now!
✅ audiobook provided by @penguinrandomhouse through the @librofm influencer program
I really enjoy a generational family saga. In Good Dirt we’re with the Freemans—one of the only Black families in a wealthy enclave in New England. 10-year-old Ebby witnesses her brother get murdered during a home invasion and we see how that loss shapes her as an adult. Tracing the generations back through the passing of a historic jar through their family, we’re introduced to the enslaved potters who made uncredited beautiful work, and used it as an instrument of escape; the newly free Black sailors that worked on whaling and trade ships always at risk of being captured again; the road to freedom and the legacy and trauma of the journey passed down through generations; how eventual affluence and generational wealth might insulate but ultimately can’t protect the Freemans from prejudice and violence.
This was a solid read, the history of enslaved Black potters and free sailors was fascinating, and I’d have like to stay with them even longer. I liked main character Ebby but found her story centred around losing her white fiancé then running into him at an Airbnb in France kind of out of place to the rest of the novel. It almost felt as though I were reading two very different books but, not in a necessarily bad way. Enjoyable but constantly shifting wavelengths.
I found myself really enjoying this when I turned it on, but a bit forgettable when I wasn’t actively listening. And at times I got a little lost in the timeline. But, the audiobook is narrated by January LaVoy who is phenomenal so I was able to forgive any issues I had with the novel and just be carried along for the ride.
I haven’t read Black Cake but feel like I definitely want to prioritize it now!