328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
adventurous lighthearted slow-paced

No hate to Brandon Sanderson but Bookclub was not the biggest fan of his book… 😬 this takes the crown as our lowest rated book yet with a sad average of 2.65 stars… me, I skewed it lower too because I was not a fan! I rated it 2.

Tress of the Emerald Sea is a Princess Bride retelling, originally made to cater to Sanderson superfans, probably not the best intro to his work. Tress loses her beau and decides to do anything to save him, including becoming a pirate on a ship sailing through the dangerous aether oceans, seas made up of spores that react to water in wild and unexpected ways. There’s also a dragon, a sorcerer and a talking rat. Silly and whimsical, but unfortunately in a trying way too hard and not quite hitting the mark sort of way.

We all had pretty much the same issues with it—despite everyone agreeing there was fun imagination at play and great world building, we all found the narrator absolutely annoying as hell and his tendency to break the 4th wall and talk to the reader jarring and bad. Closing in at almost 400 pages this was just too long with too much time sailing on a boat with not a lot of action in-between to break it up which just got boring after a while. 

On the whole, the plot was overly convenient and the ending pretty anticlimactic. But, several us really liked main character Tress and we all thought the aether oceans were pretty cool. As someone who loves the Princess Bride, this missed the mark of that for tone, I was picturing the Paperbag Princess the whole time instead. It felt like middle grade fiction to me, and if it was marketed as that it would be great, but as YA or Adult Fantasy (which was where it was in my bookstore), I expected more from it.

I was deep in a reading slump when I read this so that probably didn’t help either, in fact it felt like it kicked me down deeper and threw a pile of dirt on my face to boot.

I will give his high fantasy a go though…

challenging slow-paced

Well! That was a journey. I feel like I dragged myself by my fingernails through the last of it but I’m here! It’s completed!! But at what cost?!

Long Island Compromise was a constant compromise with myself, we negotiated and I didn’t DNF but it never redeemed itself either, so joke’s on me! The ending to this book is the most maddening thing I’ve ever read. Why have such shitty unlikeable characters if you’re not going to give them any growth or redeem them in anyway?! The women in this book were all the worst caricatures of Jewish matriarchs I’ve encountered in awhile and the adult children, our main characters, are all reduced to one quality—depraved Beamer, Anxious Nathan and Self-flagellating Jenny. They were all the worst and not in a “haha look at these rich people behaving badly fun sort of way” but an “ew look at these rich people behaving badly for 464 pages but learning almost nothing sort of way.” Yikes.

These are the children of Carl—he was kidnapped in their childhood and then returned with unattended trauma and the book is about how that trauma has been passed down to each of them. They are the Fletchers, a rich Jewish family in a wealthy suburb who own a styrofoam factory and we interrogate how their wealth has or hasn’t insulated or helped them. I dunno, there’s a lot going on here that’s good—capitalism, inheritance, family history and secrets, the trappings of wealth, what the rich do to hang on to it, entitlement, yadda yadda yadda but I absolutely could not enjoy any of it because these characters were just so freaking insufferable. Beamer in particular, who unfortunately we start out with, is a sex/drug addict who we spend waaaay too much time with as he spirals out of control and hits every gross rung on the way down. Nathan was anxious and his anxiety was palpable but that was more annoying than anything and Jenny was just ugh the worst somehow because she didn’t want her wealth and struggles against it but doesn’t seem to do any good either, just kinda floats there unsure who or what to blame. Eye rolllllll. This was just such a tedious read but I read it. So yay for me? Gold star!⭐️ 🙄

Audiobook gifted through the Librofm influencer program in exchange for my honest review.
emotional reflective medium-paced

A tale of nobility lost, a woman’s fate at the mercy of men, love, female friendship, the spirit of resilience and stubborn survival.

Based on a true story—Marguerite de Rocque was a gentlewoman in the sixteenth century who when orphaned and heir to a fortune she falls at the mercy of her guardian and cousin, a tempestuous and violent man. 

As he voyages to the new world he demands she accompany him… while aboard the ship she falls into an affair he does not approve of and in bitter punishment maroons them on an island with few supplies or hope of survival.

What follows is one of the most fascinating and immersive tales of wilderness survival I’ve read. I loved these characters and every moment felt so vivid and emotional. I wholeheartedly believed the story unfolding and wanted so badly to see Marguerite make it through… even knowing what the story would be, I was on tenterhooks the entire time!

I truly can’t believe this is based on a true story! What a life! And her guardian can go F himself 😤

My thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing for the ebook in exchange for my honest review.
challenging lighthearted slow-paced

What a bunch of surreal, weirdo nonsense. At first, I was like oh ha ha I see what she's doing here, clever. But, it just dragged on and doubled down to the point where I set it down and set it down, the tedium felt never ending but the book was only 170 some pages!!

Temporary is about a woman who takes temp jobs but the jobs are like being a ghost, or a pirate, or a sea barnacle, someone's mom, or a murder's apprentice. It gets weirder, stream-of-unhinged-conscious, and more off-putting the deeper you go, and I'm not really sure what the point of it all was in the end. I feel like it went off the deep end and I was just watching, wishing she'd take less literary risks, actually.

People were saying this book was funny, but beyond being quirky--think stuck in an Alice in Wonderland fever dream you can't escape from--I didn't really find it funny at all. I guess, if you just want no plot, no character development, barely a story, just strange vibes then this might appeal to you. It was just a little too much for me, though.

Tove Ditlevsen is beloved in Denmark, but perhaps something was lost a bit in translation because her poetry felt very tedious and stagnant to me. I think the criticism that her writing style when rhymed feels very antiquated has merit, I did find towards the end of the collection when her work moved to free form, it was a lot more interesting and digestible but even so, nothing really captured my emotions or imagination. A pretty disappointing collection unfortunately.

My thanks to Netgalley and Farrar, Straus and Giroux for the review copy.

Extremely accessible, at times a bit shallow, poetry that leans heavily on the Taylor Swift fandom. These poems didn't particularly speak to me, but I think for an audience new to poetry or who are looking for something super approachable and social media friendly this might work for them.

My thanks to Netgalley and Central Avenue Publishing for the review copy.
adventurous emotional reflective fast-paced

The Light Pirate by @lilybrooksdalton 
Purchased myself ✅ 

I did not expect to love this as much as I did, but from the very first page I was completely hooked.

Told with bold and emotional writing, Lily Brooks-Dalton unfolds a story of watery endtimes that’s laced through with just the right amount of magical realism to keep things contemplative but not too fantastical.

We follow Wanda as she’s born in the hurricane that marks the beginning of a true climate catastrophe and comes of age in the care of her electrician dad and brother who are doing everything in their power to maintain a grid at its breaking point. Where we go from there, is a bounce through the coming years and revealing how we got there in flashback. 

I really loved Phyllis, the survivalist/prepper biologist that takes Wanda under her wing and the quiet queer romance drifting in the undercurrent. Although the first half of this book was exceptional in its tense atmosphere, I think the quieter second half was just as fascinating in its imagining of what our world might become as the lights go out and the water comes in.

Truly such an engaging surprise of a book to end the year with, if this has been lingering on your tbr I urge you to bring it to the top!! Thanks for the buddy read @jeatherhanereads and @jcgalligan —I wouldn’t have picked this up without you!! And now I’m looking forward to more Water World themed books. After the Flood is next on my list!
reflective medium-paced

I've been watching Sarah Kay's spoken word for years, I think there's an element of her performance that is just so excellent that you can't quite reach on the page. But, she's been a favourite poet of mine since the first time I heard her poem B.

Her new book of poetry A Little Daylight Left, feels like a slight departure for me. The poems feel longer and wordier than what I remember of her work and more observational. I really enjoyed these but did feel myself missing the way her best poems will end with such a good kicker that makes you see everything that came before in a new light. I like the way she can fold a metaphor or a line over and over, changing it every time.

There were definitely some poems in here that spoke to me, the ones about family and friends, especially. Even if this isn't my favourite of her books, I remain a huge fan!

Thanks to Netgalley and Random House for the ebook in exchange for my honest review.
dark lighthearted

We Could Be Rats by Emily Austin
💝 arc sent to me by @simonschusterca (thank you!)

Emily Austin has such a great way of getting into the minds and hearts of her characters. They’re weird, interesting, compelling, messy… I really loved the two sisters in We Could Be Rats and the friendship between Sigrid and Greta. It felt incredibly nostalgic and bittersweet reading this.

For me, though, I didn’t love the format—a constantly evolving suicide letter written in a way that kept undermining or questioning the truth of everything said… it got to be a little exhausting in the way that unreliable narrators can get sometimes. There is a clever twist half way through, that I liked but overall I found this one a little forgettable and somewhat disappointing after enjoying Interesting Facts About Space so much… I feel like it must be that the format this story was told in just wasn’t for me, because otherwise I really loved the characters. And Emily Austin’s writing is always great—approaching and accepting life’s darkness with a levity I appreciate. I’ll still read whatever she writes, but wouldn’t suggest this book as a starting place to new readers of her work