You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Witchcraft for Wayward Girls by Grady Hendrix
1.0
slow-paced

Wow I really hated this book. It was one long slow boring ass plod to the finish line and I asked myself multiple times why I was bothering with finishing it but I guess just trying to eke out my money’s worth. Yes, I bought this book. I wish I hadn’t. 

This was my first Grady Hendrix and I would not have picked up a book about pregnant and traumatized teenage girls had I known it was written by a middle aged dude. The whole time, it just felt kinda creepy. I realized Grady is a man about 1/4 of the way through lol JUMP SCARE

It’s about pregnant teens in the 70s forced to go to a home where they surrender their babies, and while there find a book that entices them into doing witchcraft. There’s a spiraling convoluted plot that doesn’t make a lot of sense and actually doesn’t seem to matter anyway.

The characters were barely interesting, the black characters were just there to support white journeys or actually just be a cut and paste magical negro trope. There was a 14 year old girl impregnated by her middle-aged preacher. Just ick. Also this was supposed to be about witches but the witchcraft was just so lackluster. The acknowledgments say the first draft had no witches at all and I believe it because everything about it felt like an afterthought or marketing choice. Witches are big now, can we add that in?

It was also so freakin long and didn’t need to be because we feel every page of that length. So much is repeated and reiterated it’s like an editor never even touched this, or was scared to say what they really thought. Also not sure why the witches always had to be naked and riding branches clinging to trees? Wtf?

This also contained one of the most traumatic birth stories I’ve ever read—needlessly so. 

Also, if you’re looking for horror—this is neither scary nor suspenseful. It’s scary how bad it is in every way but I don’t think that was intentional.

I’m just not sure what the point of this book was, it felt like a dirty outlet for Hendrix’s weird teenage girl fixation. 

Could not possibly recommend. Worst book of the year.