Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Black Woods, Blue Sky
by Eowyn Ivey
adventurous
dark
Hiiii long time no see—the dregs of winter blues have set in, the world is burning, I slipped on the ice and hurt myself, got the flu and couldn’t walk… so I thought it best to just ✨opt out✨ for awhile lol.
And then bookclub happened and I had to fight tooth and nail to defend this gorgeous gorgeous book I (and one other member) loved so much that just didn’t resonate with anyone else. Cue the tears. No really. I got so emotional talking about this book I cried and then I think at least semi emotionally-manipulated others to increase their rating. When I tell you I am emotionally hanging on ✨by a thread✨ 😌. It’s fine everything is fine.
Bookclub read and really enjoyed her other book The Snow Child during our first season, I actually loved this one so much more—but that wasn’t the consensus.
Black Woods, Blue Sky is a dark Beauty and the Beast retelling set in the Alaskan wilds. Birdie, a young mother struggling to provide for her daughter and fighting against her base nature falls for a reclusive odd ball and follows him to his cabin (kid in tow) off the grid where she hopes to build a new idyllic life pressed up against the wild.
What followed for me, was a nuanced portrayal of nature v man, a struggle to be your better self perched tight on the edge of a razor, the way empathy, forgiveness and hope play against our rationality when it comes to abuse, addiction and the people we love. A debate on what we owe our children, our community and ourselves. All told in the most striking and visceral prose. I LOVED it and gave it 5 stars.
What followed for the rest of bookclub was a weirdo cringe mess of a relationship, a host of characters that were either terrible or just not relatable, and an irritating ending.
I like to believe they were all just wrong. 😑
lol this is why bookclub is so much fun though and the conversation was SO GOOD and longer and deeper than any other meeting yet.
But they were still mostly wrong about this one, I’ll die on this hill 🤣
And then bookclub happened and I had to fight tooth and nail to defend this gorgeous gorgeous book I (and one other member) loved so much that just didn’t resonate with anyone else. Cue the tears. No really. I got so emotional talking about this book I cried and then I think at least semi emotionally-manipulated others to increase their rating. When I tell you I am emotionally hanging on ✨by a thread✨ 😌. It’s fine everything is fine.
Bookclub read and really enjoyed her other book The Snow Child during our first season, I actually loved this one so much more—but that wasn’t the consensus.
Black Woods, Blue Sky is a dark Beauty and the Beast retelling set in the Alaskan wilds. Birdie, a young mother struggling to provide for her daughter and fighting against her base nature falls for a reclusive odd ball and follows him to his cabin (kid in tow) off the grid where she hopes to build a new idyllic life pressed up against the wild.
What followed for me, was a nuanced portrayal of nature v man, a struggle to be your better self perched tight on the edge of a razor, the way empathy, forgiveness and hope play against our rationality when it comes to abuse, addiction and the people we love. A debate on what we owe our children, our community and ourselves. All told in the most striking and visceral prose. I LOVED it and gave it 5 stars.
What followed for the rest of bookclub was a weirdo cringe mess of a relationship, a host of characters that were either terrible or just not relatable, and an irritating ending.
I like to believe they were all just wrong. 😑
lol this is why bookclub is so much fun though and the conversation was SO GOOD and longer and deeper than any other meeting yet.
But they were still mostly wrong about this one, I’ll die on this hill 🤣