Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
A Wild Swan: And Other Tales
by Michael Cunningham
adventurous
challenging
dark
lighthearted
Fairytale retellings are some of my favourite things to read—and some of Cunningham’s stories really pack a punch here, but after a while the acerbic cynical tone started to grate on me.
I liked when the stories are reimagining what might have happened before or after the original tale—like with Little Man which interrogates Rumpelstiltskin’s desire to be a father, or the brother in A Wild Swan who isn’t fully transformed and has one swan wing instead of an arm causing a descent into alcoholism and depression. It always felt clever the adding of whys and hows. But other tales like Jacked with a more modern Jack and the Beanstalk or Her Hair retelling Rapunzel felt less creative and more filler, adding nothing much to the retelling. Often, trying to include “modern” elements to the tale didn’t work for me at all and felt gimmicky and forced.
But, certain stories like A Monkey’s Paw or Beasts where small clever changes make a big impact made the lesser more average stories and somewhat off putting tone worth journeying through anyhow.
I liked when the stories are reimagining what might have happened before or after the original tale—like with Little Man which interrogates Rumpelstiltskin’s desire to be a father, or the brother in A Wild Swan who isn’t fully transformed and has one swan wing instead of an arm causing a descent into alcoholism and depression. It always felt clever the adding of whys and hows. But other tales like Jacked with a more modern Jack and the Beanstalk or Her Hair retelling Rapunzel felt less creative and more filler, adding nothing much to the retelling. Often, trying to include “modern” elements to the tale didn’t work for me at all and felt gimmicky and forced.
But, certain stories like A Monkey’s Paw or Beasts where small clever changes make a big impact made the lesser more average stories and somewhat off putting tone worth journeying through anyhow.