Take a photo of a barcode or cover
46 reviews by:
orcinus_olive
adventurous
reflective
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
Context:
I have not read the original story of the Argonauts, only a brief summary of it, and I’m only vaguely familiar with a few stories of Atalanta. But every so often throughout reading this novel, I would read up on further details about what happened in the original tellings and how.
tldr/summary:
This story reeks of potential that sadly goes largely unused. All the ingredients are there to tell a truly amazing story about a woman who claimed her title as hero in a male dominated society. However it appears that the author prioritized accuracy to the myths over telling that story. This on several occasions creates a weird disconnect between what happens and how the reader is supposed to feel about those events. The story becomes a messy succession of interesting, enrapturing story events and disappointing, strange ones.
Long version:
In essence, this novel feels like an ideal foundation on which one can construct a truly brilliant story. But the author seems to lack the confidence to really commit to writing this story. It would involve changing the original myths too much or adding on them too much. It would involve giving the characters meaningful flaws to let them go through actual arcs. Sometimes it appears as though there’s some amazing subtext, but it is so subtle that it’s unclear the author intended that subtext to be there in the first place. The story’s highs are high but the lows are also really low.
The story is split into three parts; their pace, location, storyline, supporting characters etc. so vastly different every time that it hardly feels like they all belong to the same story. The only consistent through-lines are Atalanta and Artemis, the mortal and the goddess she worships and quests for. And even Artemis is barely a presence in the middle part.
Atalanta’s journey begins with her birth and being raised by the creatures of the Arcadian Forest, under Artemis’ protection. Although the vibes of this magical forest are immaculate, little actually happens in it. Most of the time, the characters here act as mouthpieces to tell or act out myths which usually don’t even connect to Atalanta or the rest of the novel’s plot. There are parts in here which are necessary for the later plot, but the whole segment should have been shortened. In its current form it is really slow and uneventful, bordering on boring.
Eventually however, Artemis gives Atalanta the quest to join the Argonauts on their journey to Colchis, where they’ll take the Golden Fleece so Jason can become king of Iolcus. This is the second and longest part of the story, where the plot truly begins and picks up both pace and action. But at the same time, it doesn’t really do that. Until the Argonauts reach Colchis, there’s only one stop on their journey that gets fleshed out more: the very first one. After the ship leaves Lemnos, the story quickly becomes very episodic: the Argonauts land in a new location, are confronted with a new problem, overcome it easily and leave again.
Since the author decided to focus on the more interpersonal dynamics of the crew, the tests of strength take a backseat. This in itself is fine – these people are Greece’s most accomplished heroes after all, they should have no problem killing a bunch of giants etc. – but it does have the side effect of turning most of the story’s actual plot into trivial challenges. Therefore the encounters don’t really rise in tension, the stakes never really get higher, and as a result it doesn’t really feel like the story is picking up pace and really getting started until the Argonauts reach Colchis a good way into the novel.
Another problem of this approach is: most Argonauts are really bland and boring. Almost all of them are more defined by what they can do – fly, sing really good, be the son of a god – rather than who they actually are. The only ones of note really are Jason, Heracles and Meleager. Jason doesn’t really do much before the events in Colchis but he’s a mostly dislikeable guy, intentionally so. He’s a bad leader who prefers to let others do the work and who can be easily manipulated by others. The story makes sure to show that on several occasions.
Heracles is the only really enjoyable character in this segment. He starts of as a jerk towards Atalanta but it quickly becomes clear that he and her have quite a lot in common. They are both rather pragmatic and fully focused on achieving their goals and sticking to their duties. Once he realizes that, he gears towards becoming appreciative of the only woman on this journey as an equal warrior and thereby being the only character in the story (besides Atalanta herself) who starts having a character arc where he overcomes his flaws and meaningfully changes. There are so many characters in this text and almost all of them remain absolutely static throughout the entirety of it.
But even Heracles doesn’t really get to change, because after he warms up a little to Atalanta, he is forced to leave on the third major stop of the journey and never returns, leaving his teased character arc unresolved. Why is he given so much attention if he’s barely in the story? There are more than enough Argonauts to give some others more depth; for example the story could have explored what Orpheus, a musician, is doing on this journey to slay monsters and fight warriors all over the Black Sea. But it doesn’t.
And then there is Meleager, Atalanta’s first ally among the Argonauts and love interest. He is such an annoying, shallow character who for the majority of the story feels like he’s just there to provide cheap, poorly executed drama to Atalanta (who had sworn to Artemis not to marry any man ever). He is such an idiot that you feel like he’s supposed to be a bad guy, only there to highlight what a great man Hippomenes is in the last part of the story. But then the story always treats him as a good man and hero and claims it’s so tragic that he dies a completely avoidable death, caused by his own idiocy. His personality is so bland and there’s no development between him and Atalanta at all: they are friends at first sight and in love only days later. And then his whole personality has been on display even though the journey barely started.
Eventually however, the crew reaches Colchis. This segment is perfectly fine, but there’s not much to point out, positively or negatively. Medea is an interesting, deeply flawed character, well deserving of her own story in which she is explored more deeply. A similar thing can be said for Atalanta’s visit to Meleager’s homeland after the Argonauts return to Greece (if you ignore that Meleager had to act like an idiot, so that he would die).
And so the story transitions towards Atalanta’s life after the journey of the Argonauts, the best segment of the novel. She has become pregnant with Meleager’s child, so Artemis tells she is never allowed to return home and has to fend on her own now. Though it is a bit jarring to come from the fast-paced action-packed ship voyage to this slow, more pensive life of a retired hero, it does have a nice side effect: Almost 300 pages in, we finally get to sit down and explore the identity and inner feelings of the titular character.
Up until now Atalanta has been rather bland; her only real traits were being good at hunting, running and being in love with in Meleager. She has no meaningful personality, positive or negative. Most of the myths played out in Arcadia and the adventures of the Argonauts aren’t her stories, so she is usually just there watching the plot happen to someone else. Now we finally get to see a story that truly feels like it’s hers: rejected by her travel companions and patron goddess, Atalanta has to figure out how to provide for herself and her newborn child.
Aiding her in this endeavor is her new sidekick Hippomenes. He’s been in the story before but only now does he become a major character. And in that role he is the platonic ideal of what Meleager seemingly was supposed to be: He’s not just shallowly obsessed with a girl who can fight and really sees who Atalanta is behind her facade. He genuinely cares for her and doesn’t appear like he would drop her because he got bored of her after a few months. He and Atalanta have such good and healthy chemistry that one can really root for the two getting married, even though it should normally feel displaced in a story about a woman claiming her place in a male dominated world.
However, likeable as he is, in the end he is another man helping Atalanta find solutions to her problems and persuading her into certain actions. This is a reoccurring problem with the novel: Atalanta is a really passive character. The story begins with Artemis telling her to join the Argonauts, there she works under the rule of Jason together with Meleager, who is quite a force of personality. When she returns to Arcadia with a new understanding of men and love (and pregnant), she doesn’t choose to reject Artemis’ restrictive rules for her worshipers and build a new life for herself; Artemis comes to Atalanta telling her she can no longer live in Arcadia and has to figure out life elsewhere.
Then she reunites with Hippomenes who tells her that her father, King Iasus, wants her back and that it might be good for her son to grow up in a palace. When her father acknowledges her as his daughter, he forces her to marry someone. She manages to defend herself against suitors for a while until Hippomenes tricks her with Aphrodite’s help (also, she likes him too much to let him be killed) and the two get married, only to get cursed by an angry Rhea and once more seeking out Artemis.
The only two meaningful decisions she makes are convincing Jason that he should continue his mission instead of settling down on Lemnos and deciding that marrying Hippomenes isn’t so bad after all. Otherwise her life – to the very end – is defined by others ordering her around and making decisions for her.
The ending in general has weird tones to it. It clearly tries to paint a very tragic event as something positive. Allegedly, Atalanta finally escapes the grasp of gods and men and is truly free. But then Aphrodite tricks her into awakening Rhea’s wrath, who turns her into an animal, before in the second to last paragraph, Atalanta runs back to Artemis and regains her favor. So she is not free from the gods controlling her life, regardless of whether she loves being a lion or not. Here, more clearly than elsewhere, the conflict is visible between painting Atalanta as a strong woman who carved out her own destiny, and being loyal to the myths, that plagues the entire novel.
I have not read the original story of the Argonauts, only a brief summary of it, and I’m only vaguely familiar with a few stories of Atalanta. But every so often throughout reading this novel, I would read up on further details about what happened in the original tellings and how.
tldr/summary:
This story reeks of potential that sadly goes largely unused. All the ingredients are there to tell a truly amazing story about a woman who claimed her title as hero in a male dominated society. However it appears that the author prioritized accuracy to the myths over telling that story. This on several occasions creates a weird disconnect between what happens and how the reader is supposed to feel about those events. The story becomes a messy succession of interesting, enrapturing story events and disappointing, strange ones.
Long version:
The story is split into three parts; their pace, location, storyline, supporting characters etc. so vastly different every time that it hardly feels like they all belong to the same story. The only consistent through-lines are Atalanta and Artemis, the mortal and the goddess she worships and quests for. And even Artemis is barely a presence in the middle part.
Atalanta’s journey begins with her birth and being raised by the creatures of the Arcadian Forest, under Artemis’ protection. Although the vibes of this magical forest are immaculate, little actually happens in it. Most of the time, the characters here act as mouthpieces to tell or act out myths which usually don’t even connect to Atalanta or the rest of the novel’s plot. There are parts in here which are necessary for the later plot, but the whole segment should have been shortened. In its current form it is really slow and uneventful, bordering on boring.
Eventually however, Artemis gives Atalanta the quest to join the Argonauts on their journey to Colchis, where they’ll take the Golden Fleece so Jason can become king of Iolcus. This is the second and longest part of the story, where the plot truly begins and picks up both pace and action. But at the same time, it doesn’t really do that. Until the Argonauts reach Colchis, there’s only one stop on their journey that gets fleshed out more: the very first one. After the ship leaves Lemnos, the story quickly becomes very episodic: the Argonauts land in a new location, are confronted with a new problem, overcome it easily and leave again.
Since the author decided to focus on the more interpersonal dynamics of the crew, the tests of strength take a backseat. This in itself is fine – these people are Greece’s most accomplished heroes after all, they should have no problem killing a bunch of giants etc. – but it does have the side effect of turning most of the story’s actual plot into trivial challenges. Therefore the encounters don’t really rise in tension, the stakes never really get higher, and as a result it doesn’t really feel like the story is picking up pace and really getting started until the Argonauts reach Colchis a good way into the novel.
Another problem of this approach is: most Argonauts are really bland and boring. Almost all of them are more defined by what they can do – fly, sing really good, be the son of a god – rather than who they actually are. The only ones of note really are Jason, Heracles and Meleager. Jason doesn’t really do much before the events in Colchis but he’s a mostly dislikeable guy, intentionally so. He’s a bad leader who prefers to let others do the work and who can be easily manipulated by others. The story makes sure to show that on several occasions.
Heracles is the only really enjoyable character in this segment. He starts of as a jerk towards Atalanta but it quickly becomes clear that he and her have quite a lot in common. They are both rather pragmatic and fully focused on achieving their goals and sticking to their duties. Once he realizes that, he gears towards becoming appreciative of the only woman on this journey as an equal warrior and thereby being the only character in the story (besides Atalanta herself) who starts having a character arc where he overcomes his flaws and meaningfully changes. There are so many characters in this text and almost all of them remain absolutely static throughout the entirety of it.
But even Heracles doesn’t really get to change, because after he warms up a little to Atalanta, he is forced to leave on the third major stop of the journey and never returns, leaving his teased character arc unresolved. Why is he given so much attention if he’s barely in the story? There are more than enough Argonauts to give some others more depth; for example the story could have explored what Orpheus, a musician, is doing on this journey to slay monsters and fight warriors all over the Black Sea. But it doesn’t.
And then there is Meleager, Atalanta’s first ally among the Argonauts and love interest. He is such an annoying, shallow character who for the majority of the story feels like he’s just there to provide cheap, poorly executed drama to Atalanta (who had sworn to Artemis not to marry any man ever). He is such an idiot that you feel like he’s supposed to be a bad guy, only there to highlight what a great man Hippomenes is in the last part of the story. But then the story always treats him as a good man and hero and claims it’s so tragic that he dies a completely avoidable death, caused by his own idiocy. His personality is so bland and there’s no development between him and Atalanta at all: they are friends at first sight and in love only days later. And then his whole personality has been on display even though the journey barely started.
Eventually however, the crew reaches Colchis. This segment is perfectly fine, but there’s not much to point out, positively or negatively. Medea is an interesting, deeply flawed character, well deserving of her own story in which she is explored more deeply. A similar thing can be said for Atalanta’s visit to Meleager’s homeland after the Argonauts return to Greece (if you ignore that Meleager had to act like an idiot, so that he would die).
And so the story transitions towards Atalanta’s life after the journey of the Argonauts, the best segment of the novel. She has become pregnant with Meleager’s child, so Artemis tells she is never allowed to return home and has to fend on her own now. Though it is a bit jarring to come from the fast-paced action-packed ship voyage to this slow, more pensive life of a retired hero, it does have a nice side effect: Almost 300 pages in, we finally get to sit down and explore the identity and inner feelings of the titular character.
Up until now Atalanta has been rather bland; her only real traits were being good at hunting, running and being in love with in Meleager. She has no meaningful personality, positive or negative. Most of the myths played out in Arcadia and the adventures of the Argonauts aren’t her stories, so she is usually just there watching the plot happen to someone else. Now we finally get to see a story that truly feels like it’s hers: rejected by her travel companions and patron goddess, Atalanta has to figure out how to provide for herself and her newborn child.
Aiding her in this endeavor is her new sidekick Hippomenes. He’s been in the story before but only now does he become a major character. And in that role he is the platonic ideal of what Meleager seemingly was supposed to be: He’s not just shallowly obsessed with a girl who can fight and really sees who Atalanta is behind her facade. He genuinely cares for her and doesn’t appear like he would drop her because he got bored of her after a few months. He and Atalanta have such good and healthy chemistry that one can really root for the two getting married, even though it should normally feel displaced in a story about a woman claiming her place in a male dominated world.
However, likeable as he is, in the end he is another man helping Atalanta find solutions to her problems and persuading her into certain actions. This is a reoccurring problem with the novel: Atalanta is a really passive character. The story begins with Artemis telling her to join the Argonauts, there she works under the rule of Jason together with Meleager, who is quite a force of personality. When she returns to Arcadia with a new understanding of men and love (and pregnant), she doesn’t choose to reject Artemis’ restrictive rules for her worshipers and build a new life for herself; Artemis comes to Atalanta telling her she can no longer live in Arcadia and has to figure out life elsewhere.
Then she reunites with Hippomenes who tells her that her father, King Iasus, wants her back and that it might be good for her son to grow up in a palace. When her father acknowledges her as his daughter, he forces her to marry someone. She manages to defend herself against suitors for a while until Hippomenes tricks her with Aphrodite’s help (also, she likes him too much to let him be killed) and the two get married, only to get cursed by an angry Rhea and once more seeking out Artemis.
The only two meaningful decisions she makes are convincing Jason that he should continue his mission instead of settling down on Lemnos and deciding that marrying Hippomenes isn’t so bad after all. Otherwise her life – to the very end – is defined by others ordering her around and making decisions for her.
The ending in general has weird tones to it. It clearly tries to paint a very tragic event as something positive. Allegedly, Atalanta finally escapes the grasp of gods and men and is truly free. But then Aphrodite tricks her into awakening Rhea’s wrath, who turns her into an animal, before in the second to last paragraph, Atalanta runs back to Artemis and regains her favor. So she is not free from the gods controlling her life, regardless of whether she loves being a lion or not. Here, more clearly than elsewhere, the conflict is visible between painting Atalanta as a strong woman who carved out her own destiny, and being loyal to the myths, that plagues the entire novel.
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
tldr/summary:
While the mystery investigation and the side characters are quite decent, the final resolution is kind of disappointing. But that hardly matters if every neat aspect of the novel is dragged down by the protagonist and first person narrator through whose perspective the whole story is filtered. Hanne Wilhelmsen is such an insufferable character that she manages to make you stop caring about solving the crime in a crime solving story.
Long version:
This story has one glaring problem: the protagonist and first person narrator. Hanne Wilhelmsen is such an insufferable person who cannot state often enough how much she hates participating in society and nearly every individual human who has ever walked this planet. It takes her until page 55 to disclose her name to another character and even the reader because of her aggressively antisocial behavior. In the very first chapter, there’s already a side character who gets so annoyed by her – quite understandably so – that he tells her that if she is so intent on making everyone leave her alone, then she should just fuck off and be miserable on her own.
Aside from Hanne, the side characters are quite decent however. The characters that are supposed to be likeable are actually easy to like and the dislikeable characters are similarly skilled at evoking their emotion. It’s hard to find a fictional character who makes you as uncomfortable as Kari Thue. The author even manages to make the reader have more complex feelings towards characters like Adrian, who cannot simply be classified as likeable or dislikeable.
On top of that, the cast is quite diverse with characters that have a middle eastern background, dwarfism or other traits that are typically underrepresented in fiction. These characters are also rarely defined only by their diversity or associated stereotypes. Especially the character with dwarfism has a very complex character that goes beyond having sophisticated meditations on his disability, although those are nice as well. The problem here however is that Hanne is so presumptuous and judgmental about literally everyone that this representation kinda doesn’t feel good anymore. Some things she says or thinks early on feel really quite offensive; and the book isn’t interested in confronting that fact at all.
On paper, investigating the central mystery of who is the murderer is neatly executed. There are not too obvious clues lying around and Hanne doesn’t make absolutely wild deduction leaps that no real person could ever replicate. But when it comes to foreshadowing or withholding information from the reader, the author is rather clumsy at that. There are several paragraphs where Hanne’s narrative voice notes that she realized or remembered something or put two pieces of information together. She states that this now changes everything but then refuses to elaborate on what she just figured out. An example of that is when she says that she figured out where she has seen someone before and which emotions that invokes in her, but then refuses to tell the reader who that person is.
Another thing that frequently happens is when a conversation is broken off by another character joining in or by some other sudden event. This always happens right before some game-changing information is revealed and it’s pretty obvious that that would have happened, were it not for the random interruption.
This technique also comes into play when the author seems to not know how to transition from one scene to the next or deal with the consequences of what was just said; even in cases where it would be very interesting to see how the current situation resolves or continues without the interruption.
But in a sense, this barely matters because Hanne’s general disinterest in everyone and everything kinda makes you stop caring about the murder case too.
This story has two mysteries to solve: Who killed the dead people and what’s in the mysterious, locked up train carriage?
The resolution to the first question was kind of underwhelming. It is realistic, logical and the reader could have deduced it on their own, sure. But that doesn’t mean it isn’t rather boring. It doesn’t help either that you can easily nail it down to two or three possible suspects simply by asking the question: “Do you have a purpose in the story other than being the murderer?“
Finding out the secret of the mystery carriage on the other hand was disappointing in the complete opposite direction. It is so far-fetched, unrealistic and frankly just ridiculously bonkers that you have to wonder why anyone thought this reveal would be a good scene to end the novel on, rather than giving us a few final moments with the likeable side characters (like the beginning of the final chapter implies would be happening). Without going into details, it is also incredibly dated. You can really tell when this story was published simply because of this reveal.
Also there’s a scene where a dog gets brutally murdered. Was that really necessary?
While the mystery investigation and the side characters are quite decent, the final resolution is kind of disappointing. But that hardly matters if every neat aspect of the novel is dragged down by the protagonist and first person narrator through whose perspective the whole story is filtered. Hanne Wilhelmsen is such an insufferable character that she manages to make you stop caring about solving the crime in a crime solving story.
Long version:
This story has one glaring problem: the protagonist and first person narrator. Hanne Wilhelmsen is such an insufferable person who cannot state often enough how much she hates participating in society and nearly every individual human who has ever walked this planet. It takes her until page 55 to disclose her name to another character and even the reader because of her aggressively antisocial behavior. In the very first chapter, there’s already a side character who gets so annoyed by her – quite understandably so – that he tells her that if she is so intent on making everyone leave her alone, then she should just fuck off and be miserable on her own.
Aside from Hanne, the side characters are quite decent however. The characters that are supposed to be likeable are actually easy to like and the dislikeable characters are similarly skilled at evoking their emotion. It’s hard to find a fictional character who makes you as uncomfortable as Kari Thue. The author even manages to make the reader have more complex feelings towards characters like Adrian, who cannot simply be classified as likeable or dislikeable.
On top of that, the cast is quite diverse with characters that have a middle eastern background, dwarfism or other traits that are typically underrepresented in fiction. These characters are also rarely defined only by their diversity or associated stereotypes. Especially the character with dwarfism has a very complex character that goes beyond having sophisticated meditations on his disability, although those are nice as well. The problem here however is that Hanne is so presumptuous and judgmental about literally everyone that this representation kinda doesn’t feel good anymore. Some things she says or thinks early on feel really quite offensive; and the book isn’t interested in confronting that fact at all.
On paper, investigating the central mystery of who is the murderer is neatly executed. There are not too obvious clues lying around and Hanne doesn’t make absolutely wild deduction leaps that no real person could ever replicate. But when it comes to foreshadowing or withholding information from the reader, the author is rather clumsy at that. There are several paragraphs where Hanne’s narrative voice notes that she realized or remembered something or put two pieces of information together. She states that this now changes everything but then refuses to elaborate on what she just figured out. An example of that is when she says that she figured out where she has seen someone before and which emotions that invokes in her, but then refuses to tell the reader who that person is.
Another thing that frequently happens is when a conversation is broken off by another character joining in or by some other sudden event. This always happens right before some game-changing information is revealed and it’s pretty obvious that that would have happened, were it not for the random interruption.
This technique also comes into play when the author seems to not know how to transition from one scene to the next or deal with the consequences of what was just said; even in cases where it would be very interesting to see how the current situation resolves or continues without the interruption.
But in a sense, this barely matters because Hanne’s general disinterest in everyone and everything kinda makes you stop caring about the murder case too.
This story has two mysteries to solve: Who killed the dead people and what’s in the mysterious, locked up train carriage?
The resolution to the first question was kind of underwhelming. It is realistic, logical and the reader could have deduced it on their own, sure. But that doesn’t mean it isn’t rather boring. It doesn’t help either that you can easily nail it down to two or three possible suspects simply by asking the question: “Do you have a purpose in the story other than being the murderer?“
Finding out the secret of the mystery carriage on the other hand was disappointing in the complete opposite direction. It is so far-fetched, unrealistic and frankly just ridiculously bonkers that you have to wonder why anyone thought this reveal would be a good scene to end the novel on, rather than giving us a few final moments with the likeable side characters (like the beginning of the final chapter implies would be happening). Without going into details, it is also incredibly dated. You can really tell when this story was published simply because of this reveal.
Also there’s a scene where a dog gets brutally murdered. Was that really necessary?
adventurous
hopeful
lighthearted
reflective
relaxing
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
tldr/summary:
The story takes a while to get rolling and be interesting. In the way of an exciting second half stands a set of beginning chapters which are quite formulaic, repetitive, even a bit bland and empty. Once Bilbo and the world he’s in however find their footing on the page, things become more intriguing. The conflict of the final chapters still feels fresh to this day and Bilbo and the characters around him have grown to become really enjoyable.
Long version:
This is a difficult story to judge, maybe more 3.5/5 than 3/5. Overall it was a pleasant experience, but it needs to be said that after the company leaves the whimsical Hobbiton, the journey starts on its weakest point. However it gets progressively better all the way to the end. A lot of that can probably be attributed to Tolkien’s writing style since it has such a strong personality, both to its fault and benefit.
Especially in the beginning, Tolkien often just says something happened with much less emphasis on these events than you’d expect. He has this tendency of telling the story and every now and then saying things like “Oh by the way, when Bilbo and the dwarves left Elrond several days ago, Elrond gave Gandalf a new horse.” even though he’s already spent a good few pages telling the reader what had occurred since the thing he just mentioned offhandedly. He jumps around in the chronology of the narrative – telling us what had happened while this other event from a while ago had happened – quite a few times, which can be really disorienting.
The writing in general can feel a bit messy at times, as if Tolkien just wrote down whatever came to his mind the moment he thought of that thing. For example, there’s a scene early on where Elrond tells the company about the elven swords they had come across earlier, their names, purpose and so on. However later on, the narrator just randomly points out “Oh by the way, they also glow blue when goblins are nearby.”, something that Elrond would have definitely known. It feels as if Tolkien only came up with that fun idea later on and didn’t put that information to a more fitting spot when he polished up the story. Something like this happens several times, like when people started referring to Lake Town as Esgaroth midway through the story.
However Tolkien seems to have gotten a grip on these two problems as he progressed in writing the story, as they become rarer to nonexistent in the later parts. And when Tolkien sets his mind to writing out a scene instead of just telling you that it happened off-page, it is a pure joy to read. He had an amazing sense of giving every place, character or event personality and charm and knew how to describe something so vividly that you can feel it come alive and stay alive even as the story moves on to something different.
This extraordinary prose is allowed to shine especially in the more whimsical, optimistic parts of the story, like everything that happens in Hobbiton at the beginning and end of the story: Bilbo’s everyday life, the visit of the dwarves and the reaction of the other hobbits upon Bilbo’s return. But Tolkien is also a master of the more epic scenes. The Battle of Five Armies is so expertly described that you really feel the scale of the place, the violence and the heroics.
What doesn’t really get better however is the thirteen dwarves. Thirteen more or less main characters are a lot, so it is understandable that many of them don’t have a very developed identity; Thorin is the leader, Fili and Kili are the youngest and Bombur is the fattest (and even those aren’t technically personality traits). The rest has basically no distinguishing features. Most of the time, the dwarves act as a collective rather than individuals.
That on its own isn’t bad. What does stand out negatively however is how annoying these guys are most of the time. Many of the problems that arise throughout the plot are caused by them. And even those that the company runs into through other means, they are unable to solve. The thirteen dwarves do not solve a single problem – regardless of whether they caused that situation, worsened it or sort of just of stumbled into it – and always have to be saved by someone else. Once the story progresses to the last third their actions become especially insufferable, not only since these guys never seem to realize this themselves.
Bilbo on the other hand is much more enjoyable. Though he starts off similarly useless, whiny and reliant on Gandalf as the dwarves, Bilbo manages to go through some major development throughout the story. Once the company has gone a good way into Mirkwood, Bilbo proves himself by solving a predicament he and the dwarves are in all by himself. This moment – though sort of overkill for only his second major trial – marks the moment where Bilbo becomes a character who is fun to watch. From there onward, he knows what he’s good and bad at and how to put these skills to use. He solves many situations by being smart rather than strong, which is very satisfying to watch. He’s also a much wiser character now who knows how to handle situations delicately, for example when to step back or give up for the greater good; something the dwarves severely lack.
For the side character of this tale, there isn’t much to say. Many of them are pleasant, but it’s hard to say more about them than “Yeah, Beorn was a cool guy”, positive or negative.
Gandalf was surprisingly mean in the beginning, but then he quickly turns into a nice, though somewhat sassy man who’s mostly just there to solve problems for the dwarves and that’s pretty much all. Even in the end he doesn’t do or say all that much. Also his power set feels widely inconsistent, making his role as a plot device even more obvious. He can defeat a group of monsters with no great struggle, but an ordinary door that is opened with an ordinary key is too powerful to be opened with his magic.
Bard is a surprisingly interesting character who manages to display a wide range of personality which plays off the other characters and the plot quite well.
And Gollum was a surprisingly touching character. Even if you know the general gist of who he is already, Tolkien wrote his parts in a way that makes you really feel what a tragic figure he is more than only hearing of him through others ever could.
The plot also has a sort of development, where it starts off rather weak but improves the more the reader (and presumably Tolkien) finds their footing in the world. Nevertheless, the opening chapters are incredibly episodic and formulaic: Bilbo and the dwarves get in trouble while Gandalf sort of disappears for a moment, only to Deus Ex Machina the situation and bring the party back on course shortly after.
At some point however, Gandalf leaves the company to walk their path on their own. From that point onward, it is Bilbo who has to save the dwarves from trouble again and again. Since he isn’t an all powerful wizard however, his rescue plans require a bit more ingenuity and entertainment factor. And once the company arrives on the foot of the Lonely Mountain, the plot changes from a simple journey to something more complex and less predictable. It is genuinely a very fun and interesting story from that point onward with more gripping questions than “How will Bilbo save the dwarves this time?” (even though he indirectly still does that).
What never changes sadly is the company’s constant lack of food. Even if they stacked up on rations just a few pages ago, Tolkien finds a way to make them loose those rations again very quickly; either the company gets attacked or there’s a time lapse. Especially Bilbo is very good at bemoaning their food situation all the time and it gets annoying and repetitive really fast.
Getting through all this however is worth it to find out what happens once Smaug is defeated. Both the build-up to the Battle of Five Armies as well as the battle itself are so much fun and still feel fresh and suspenseful to this day. Bilbo’s final journey back home was also a fun, pleasant experience, not despite its length but because of it. Tolkien really has a sense to convey that the time of conflict is over; Bilbo and his world return back to an era of peace, hope and joy. Watching Bilbo travel home to the whimsical Hobbiton is one of the more cathartic reading experience one can have. The hobbit finally gets the rest that he needs and deserves.
The story takes a while to get rolling and be interesting. In the way of an exciting second half stands a set of beginning chapters which are quite formulaic, repetitive, even a bit bland and empty. Once Bilbo and the world he’s in however find their footing on the page, things become more intriguing. The conflict of the final chapters still feels fresh to this day and Bilbo and the characters around him have grown to become really enjoyable.
Long version:
This is a difficult story to judge, maybe more 3.5/5 than 3/5. Overall it was a pleasant experience, but it needs to be said that after the company leaves the whimsical Hobbiton, the journey starts on its weakest point. However it gets progressively better all the way to the end. A lot of that can probably be attributed to Tolkien’s writing style since it has such a strong personality, both to its fault and benefit.
Especially in the beginning, Tolkien often just says something happened with much less emphasis on these events than you’d expect. He has this tendency of telling the story and every now and then saying things like “Oh by the way, when Bilbo and the dwarves left Elrond several days ago, Elrond gave Gandalf a new horse.” even though he’s already spent a good few pages telling the reader what had occurred since the thing he just mentioned offhandedly. He jumps around in the chronology of the narrative – telling us what had happened while this other event from a while ago had happened – quite a few times, which can be really disorienting.
The writing in general can feel a bit messy at times, as if Tolkien just wrote down whatever came to his mind the moment he thought of that thing. For example, there’s a scene early on where Elrond tells the company about the elven swords they had come across earlier, their names, purpose and so on. However later on, the narrator just randomly points out “Oh by the way, they also glow blue when goblins are nearby.”, something that Elrond would have definitely known. It feels as if Tolkien only came up with that fun idea later on and didn’t put that information to a more fitting spot when he polished up the story. Something like this happens several times, like when people started referring to Lake Town as Esgaroth midway through the story.
However Tolkien seems to have gotten a grip on these two problems as he progressed in writing the story, as they become rarer to nonexistent in the later parts. And when Tolkien sets his mind to writing out a scene instead of just telling you that it happened off-page, it is a pure joy to read. He had an amazing sense of giving every place, character or event personality and charm and knew how to describe something so vividly that you can feel it come alive and stay alive even as the story moves on to something different.
This extraordinary prose is allowed to shine especially in the more whimsical, optimistic parts of the story, like everything that happens in Hobbiton at the beginning and end of the story: Bilbo’s everyday life, the visit of the dwarves and the reaction of the other hobbits upon Bilbo’s return. But Tolkien is also a master of the more epic scenes. The Battle of Five Armies is so expertly described that you really feel the scale of the place, the violence and the heroics.
What doesn’t really get better however is the thirteen dwarves. Thirteen more or less main characters are a lot, so it is understandable that many of them don’t have a very developed identity; Thorin is the leader, Fili and Kili are the youngest and Bombur is the fattest (and even those aren’t technically personality traits). The rest has basically no distinguishing features. Most of the time, the dwarves act as a collective rather than individuals.
That on its own isn’t bad. What does stand out negatively however is how annoying these guys are most of the time. Many of the problems that arise throughout the plot are caused by them. And even those that the company runs into through other means, they are unable to solve. The thirteen dwarves do not solve a single problem – regardless of whether they caused that situation, worsened it or sort of just of stumbled into it – and always have to be saved by someone else. Once the story progresses to the last third their actions become especially insufferable, not only since these guys never seem to realize this themselves.
Bilbo on the other hand is much more enjoyable. Though he starts off similarly useless, whiny and reliant on Gandalf as the dwarves, Bilbo manages to go through some major development throughout the story. Once the company has gone a good way into Mirkwood, Bilbo proves himself by solving a predicament he and the dwarves are in all by himself. This moment – though sort of overkill for only his second major trial – marks the moment where Bilbo becomes a character who is fun to watch. From there onward, he knows what he’s good and bad at and how to put these skills to use. He solves many situations by being smart rather than strong, which is very satisfying to watch. He’s also a much wiser character now who knows how to handle situations delicately, for example when to step back or give up for the greater good; something the dwarves severely lack.
For the side character of this tale, there isn’t much to say. Many of them are pleasant, but it’s hard to say more about them than “Yeah, Beorn was a cool guy”, positive or negative.
Gandalf was surprisingly mean in the beginning, but then he quickly turns into a nice, though somewhat sassy man who’s mostly just there to solve problems for the dwarves and that’s pretty much all. Even in the end he doesn’t do or say all that much. Also his power set feels widely inconsistent, making his role as a plot device even more obvious. He can defeat a group of monsters with no great struggle, but an ordinary door that is opened with an ordinary key is too powerful to be opened with his magic.
Bard is a surprisingly interesting character who manages to display a wide range of personality which plays off the other characters and the plot quite well.
And Gollum was a surprisingly touching character. Even if you know the general gist of who he is already, Tolkien wrote his parts in a way that makes you really feel what a tragic figure he is more than only hearing of him through others ever could.
The plot also has a sort of development, where it starts off rather weak but improves the more the reader (and presumably Tolkien) finds their footing in the world. Nevertheless, the opening chapters are incredibly episodic and formulaic: Bilbo and the dwarves get in trouble while Gandalf sort of disappears for a moment, only to Deus Ex Machina the situation and bring the party back on course shortly after.
At some point however, Gandalf leaves the company to walk their path on their own. From that point onward, it is Bilbo who has to save the dwarves from trouble again and again. Since he isn’t an all powerful wizard however, his rescue plans require a bit more ingenuity and entertainment factor. And once the company arrives on the foot of the Lonely Mountain, the plot changes from a simple journey to something more complex and less predictable. It is genuinely a very fun and interesting story from that point onward with more gripping questions than “How will Bilbo save the dwarves this time?” (even though he indirectly still does that).
What never changes sadly is the company’s constant lack of food. Even if they stacked up on rations just a few pages ago, Tolkien finds a way to make them loose those rations again very quickly; either the company gets attacked or there’s a time lapse. Especially Bilbo is very good at bemoaning their food situation all the time and it gets annoying and repetitive really fast.
Getting through all this however is worth it to find out what happens once Smaug is defeated. Both the build-up to the Battle of Five Armies as well as the battle itself are so much fun and still feel fresh and suspenseful to this day. Bilbo’s final journey back home was also a fun, pleasant experience, not despite its length but because of it. Tolkien really has a sense to convey that the time of conflict is over; Bilbo and his world return back to an era of peace, hope and joy. Watching Bilbo travel home to the whimsical Hobbiton is one of the more cathartic reading experience one can have. The hobbit finally gets the rest that he needs and deserves.
adventurous
hopeful
lighthearted
reflective
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Complicated
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
tldr/summary:
In general, there’s a good story here that sadly suffers from having too many characters. Pretty much all of them are fun, but often they can be kind of flat. This abundance of characters also flattens the central theme of gender stereotypes and expectations a bit, because we don’t go into too much detail about the individual misogyny characters have experienced in their backstories or about their identities as men/women. Still, they are a lot of fun to read about and watch grow as people, which is the central appeal of the novel.
The war plot happening in the background is at first not too interesting, but Pratchett really has written one of the more elegantly executed finales a story can receive.
Long version:
This story is in essence deeply character driven. While there is an overarching plot of reaching a certain fortress and turning the tides of war, possibly ending it, most of the book focuses on how the characters travel from place to place and develop as people. The story features a lot of one-off encounters along the way that contribute to the final climax and resolution, but most of them feel quite episodic and don’t factor in a lot until the end.
The characters that fill these events are quite compelling and colorful. There are a few guest appearances of characters from other Discworld stories and while they are nice to be around, they barely hog the spotlight and don’t develop a lot or reveal much about themselves. Much more interesting are the characters original to this novel – especially Polly and her squad, who are the focus point for almost the entire story.
But the out-of-squad side characters are great too, be it the funny joke ones like Prince Heinrich or the more serious ones. The Duchess is surprisingly interesting, considering the precious little time she gets to show herself off. A similar thing can be said for Corporal Strappi, who uses his limited page time effectively to be as insufferable as possible (which he is supposed to be. He’s really compelling in how detestable he is.).
Polly herself is quite a compelling character. Though her starting motivation may be simple, it does gain interesting/important additional layers beyond ‘She wants to protect her brother’ and is subverted a bit. Either way, as said before, the end goal of the travels isn’t all that important for the journey while it is still being undertaken. Polly discovers quite a few perks (hehe) of her own identity that she wasn’t aware of before, and that is quite satisfying to watch. She is a character who can truly prove what a strong woman she is – to herself, the world and the readers – and it is really satisfying to watch.
Many of Polly’s fellow soldiers have interesting reasons for why they would join a loosing army, fighting for a country that doesn’t really respect the rights of women. Though some of them – Shufti, Tonker and Lofty – might have profited from there being less squad members so that the story can hone in on the interesting ones and explore them more deeply than they were. The squad has quite a few members, which has the sad side effect that not all of them are equally interesting or present. Especially the character of Carborundum/Jade feels like there is no point to her being in the story at all. Also, weirdly enough, all of the characters with more interesting motivations and struggles are humans. The vampire, troll and igor all only have the same, very nebulous motivation of “Well, misogyny exists in all races.”, which is rather disappointing and boring.
This general theme of being a woman in a misogynistic society/country is executed nicely, but if you are already interested in the topic of misogyny and emancipation, there’s nothing here that you haven’t seen or heard of before. It’s really quite barebones in that regard.
One thing that reduces the complexities of the theme is the fact that literally everyone in the squad and quite a few characters beyond turn out to be a woman. As the result of that most stakes and conflict that are said to arise from the characters being women are not actually real once the characters actually have to confront them. It also makes it harder for the less spotlighted characters to distinguish themselves from one another.
Lieutenant Blouse (a truly brilliant side character) – though he doesn’t oppose the main characters – does introduce some interesting dimensions to the theme and world. It would be quite interesting to see an actually villainous, actually misogynist character in this story and disrupt the plot, not just people pretending to be that.
Maladict especially drew a hard lot with her gender reveal. The scene in which it happened felt rather clunky, as if Pratchett had forgotten to write it in earlier, so it has to happen now, in the middle of more interesting things. Why would she wait so long to tell the others? She already knew everyone was a woman and perfectly fine with the other being women too. It just isn’t explained.
Worse, Maladict already had a rather unique and fun place in the plot, an interesting side plot and character arc of her own, wholly unrelated to her being a woman. Once she reveals she is a woman however, that stuff is mostly neglected, partly because the character herself is barely in the spotlight from that point onward. She starts off very self-confident, but once she’s openly a woman, she is almost trying to disappear in the background. So while she is one of the cooler characters in the story, she leaves the plot completely understating herself. Weirdly enough, she somehow feels like her character arc isn’t completed, even though it is.
Now while the plot of traveling towards a battlefield and fighting another country’s army isn’t too complex or at the center of attention, it is still quite compelling. All the events and encounters along the journey culminate in a final siege where everything comes back to either reward or hinder the protagonists. It is truly one of the more elegantly executed story finales.
And while the epilogue part could have been shorter in certain regards, it was still a nice epilogue that gives the last few details and resolutions to certain character arcs.
In general, there’s a good story here that sadly suffers from having too many characters. Pretty much all of them are fun, but often they can be kind of flat. This abundance of characters also flattens the central theme of gender stereotypes and expectations a bit, because we don’t go into too much detail about the individual misogyny characters have experienced in their backstories or about their identities as men/women. Still, they are a lot of fun to read about and watch grow as people, which is the central appeal of the novel.
The war plot happening in the background is at first not too interesting, but Pratchett really has written one of the more elegantly executed finales a story can receive.
Long version:
The characters that fill these events are quite compelling and colorful. There are a few guest appearances of characters from other Discworld stories and while they are nice to be around, they barely hog the spotlight and don’t develop a lot or reveal much about themselves. Much more interesting are the characters original to this novel – especially Polly and her squad, who are the focus point for almost the entire story.
But the out-of-squad side characters are great too, be it the funny joke ones like Prince Heinrich or the more serious ones. The Duchess is surprisingly interesting, considering the precious little time she gets to show herself off. A similar thing can be said for Corporal Strappi, who uses his limited page time effectively to be as insufferable as possible (which he is supposed to be. He’s really compelling in how detestable he is.).
Polly herself is quite a compelling character. Though her starting motivation may be simple, it does gain interesting/important additional layers beyond ‘She wants to protect her brother’ and is subverted a bit. Either way, as said before, the end goal of the travels isn’t all that important for the journey while it is still being undertaken. Polly discovers quite a few perks (hehe) of her own identity that she wasn’t aware of before, and that is quite satisfying to watch. She is a character who can truly prove what a strong woman she is – to herself, the world and the readers – and it is really satisfying to watch.
Many of Polly’s fellow soldiers have interesting reasons for why they would join a loosing army, fighting for a country that doesn’t really respect the rights of women. Though some of them – Shufti, Tonker and Lofty – might have profited from there being less squad members so that the story can hone in on the interesting ones and explore them more deeply than they were. The squad has quite a few members, which has the sad side effect that not all of them are equally interesting or present. Especially the character of Carborundum/Jade feels like there is no point to her being in the story at all. Also, weirdly enough, all of the characters with more interesting motivations and struggles are humans. The vampire, troll and igor all only have the same, very nebulous motivation of “Well, misogyny exists in all races.”, which is rather disappointing and boring.
This general theme of being a woman in a misogynistic society/country is executed nicely, but if you are already interested in the topic of misogyny and emancipation, there’s nothing here that you haven’t seen or heard of before. It’s really quite barebones in that regard.
One thing that reduces the complexities of the theme is the fact that literally everyone in the squad and quite a few characters beyond turn out to be a woman. As the result of that most stakes and conflict that are said to arise from the characters being women are not actually real once the characters actually have to confront them. It also makes it harder for the less spotlighted characters to distinguish themselves from one another.
Lieutenant Blouse (a truly brilliant side character) – though he doesn’t oppose the main characters – does introduce some interesting dimensions to the theme and world. It would be quite interesting to see an actually villainous, actually misogynist character in this story and disrupt the plot, not just people pretending to be that.
Maladict especially drew a hard lot with her gender reveal. The scene in which it happened felt rather clunky, as if Pratchett had forgotten to write it in earlier, so it has to happen now, in the middle of more interesting things. Why would she wait so long to tell the others? She already knew everyone was a woman and perfectly fine with the other being women too. It just isn’t explained.
Worse, Maladict already had a rather unique and fun place in the plot, an interesting side plot and character arc of her own, wholly unrelated to her being a woman. Once she reveals she is a woman however, that stuff is mostly neglected, partly because the character herself is barely in the spotlight from that point onward. She starts off very self-confident, but once she’s openly a woman, she is almost trying to disappear in the background. So while she is one of the cooler characters in the story, she leaves the plot completely understating herself. Weirdly enough, she somehow feels like her character arc isn’t completed, even though it is.
Now while the plot of traveling towards a battlefield and fighting another country’s army isn’t too complex or at the center of attention, it is still quite compelling. All the events and encounters along the journey culminate in a final siege where everything comes back to either reward or hinder the protagonists. It is truly one of the more elegantly executed story finales.
And while the epilogue part could have been shorter in certain regards, it was still a nice epilogue that gives the last few details and resolutions to certain character arcs.
adventurous
dark
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
tldr/summary:
The world of the Final Empire is quite fascinating and exploring it is really entertaining, but it can become a bit monotone and gray (literally) over all these pages. From culture and history to magic and politics, the world is filled with interesting ideas.
The plot is really gripping with its many facets, developments and twists. It is the perfect playground for an array of enjoyable characters, good and evil. The novel could have actually done more with its side characters, fun as they are. If only the main protagonist of Vin wasn’t so hard to find an emotional connection to.
Long version:
The world of the Final Empire is quite intriguing, full of mysteries and characters wishing to be explored. And this feeling of wanting to dive deeper doesn’t ebb off as one learns more about the world. This is true for small scale events and people as well as global politics – especially the global politics were quite interesting and need to be discussed in greater detail in the sequels.
However it needs to be noted that the Empire can be quite stagnant and monotone in many parts – being a one thousand year old country with an immortal ruler. The story is primarily set in one city – one that is big, oppressive and dirty. It and the entire world feel (and literally are) rather gray. Even the plants here are no longer green. While there are some really vibrant and lively events throughout the plot, the world can become a bit tiring and dead over several hundred pages and leave you desiring for some variety and change.
A central feature of this world is it’s metal-based Allomancy Magic. Even though Sanderson already has a reputation of creating really interesting magic system, it's surprising how creatively he plays with his rules and limitations, how many interesting ways of using one singular ability he can think of. Further developments and new revelations are also elegantly executed and don't feel like they come out of nowhere to resolve plot.
All these factors are true from the very beginning and remain true as the plot progresses and things begin to change. It is very satisfying to see people plan out a mission to overthrow a government and learn the intricacies of their magic and non-magic abilities. Even as complications show up and they have to make detours toward their destination, things remain interesting. Side plots don’t feel like a waste of time. They are enjoyable in and of themselves and in the way they build the world, show off the characters and progress the main plot. Sanderson understands how to make the plot progress and escalate in believable and meaningful ways.
The plot twists and worldbuilding revelations are of the same nature, though Sanderson could let people figure stuff out for themselves instead of actively explaining them. He really isn't subtle about his subtext and usually spells things out quite clearly when he doesn’t have to; e.g. when we learn the details of Mare’s betrayal. Especially in the epilogue, that's super annoying.
This novel also falls into a common trap of longer novels: The beginning feels longer than it needed to be and the finale is too short. The last 50 or so pages are a wild ride in the best way possible, but it would be nice if that part of the plot was elaborated on a bit more, instead of having a middle section this long. While reading the novel is fun for almost the entire experience, sometimes it feels like nothing happened for the first 60 or so percent of the novel. It is only after the darkest hour that things really start to get into motion.
The novel has quite a few characters. Pretty much all of them are compelling and likable in one way or another. But many of the side characters do feel rather flat, they only have one or two traits. Example: Dockson is the planning and bureaucracy guy, Ham is the strong guy who likes philosophy, Breeze is the fancy talky guy who doesn't like physical work. Still, these characters are very enjoyable, but they could use and deserve some more characterization and identity.
Now while Vin and Kelsier are (a bit) less flat than the rest, Vin, the protagonist, is a difficult to enjoy character. In the beginning, she has a strong ‘I’m not like other girls.‘ mentality which is annoying really quickly. Sanderson also felt the need to remind the reader at least twice per chapter of her issues to trust others until like page 400 (This is an exaggeration (probably)) which is clear even without the regular reminders. She’s extremely distanced toward everyone at all times, which results in her making it hard for even the reader to form a connection with her.
Spoiler:
Less people should have died. Most deaths didn’t really illicit too much emotion; the characters are taken out of the experience quite unceremoniously and without all that much impact on the plot. That makes it even worse when you feel like the characters that die would be more interesting if they stayed alive, e.g. Yeden.
The world of the Final Empire is quite fascinating and exploring it is really entertaining, but it can become a bit monotone and gray (literally) over all these pages. From culture and history to magic and politics, the world is filled with interesting ideas.
The plot is really gripping with its many facets, developments and twists. It is the perfect playground for an array of enjoyable characters, good and evil. The novel could have actually done more with its side characters, fun as they are. If only the main protagonist of Vin wasn’t so hard to find an emotional connection to.
Long version:
The world of the Final Empire is quite intriguing, full of mysteries and characters wishing to be explored. And this feeling of wanting to dive deeper doesn’t ebb off as one learns more about the world. This is true for small scale events and people as well as global politics – especially the global politics were quite interesting and need to be discussed in greater detail in the sequels.
However it needs to be noted that the Empire can be quite stagnant and monotone in many parts – being a one thousand year old country with an immortal ruler. The story is primarily set in one city – one that is big, oppressive and dirty. It and the entire world feel (and literally are) rather gray. Even the plants here are no longer green. While there are some really vibrant and lively events throughout the plot, the world can become a bit tiring and dead over several hundred pages and leave you desiring for some variety and change.
A central feature of this world is it’s metal-based Allomancy Magic. Even though Sanderson already has a reputation of creating really interesting magic system, it's surprising how creatively he plays with his rules and limitations, how many interesting ways of using one singular ability he can think of. Further developments and new revelations are also elegantly executed and don't feel like they come out of nowhere to resolve plot.
All these factors are true from the very beginning and remain true as the plot progresses and things begin to change. It is very satisfying to see people plan out a mission to overthrow a government and learn the intricacies of their magic and non-magic abilities. Even as complications show up and they have to make detours toward their destination, things remain interesting. Side plots don’t feel like a waste of time. They are enjoyable in and of themselves and in the way they build the world, show off the characters and progress the main plot. Sanderson understands how to make the plot progress and escalate in believable and meaningful ways.
The plot twists and worldbuilding revelations are of the same nature, though Sanderson could let people figure stuff out for themselves instead of actively explaining them. He really isn't subtle about his subtext and usually spells things out quite clearly when he doesn’t have to; e.g. when we learn the details of Mare’s betrayal. Especially in the epilogue, that's super annoying.
This novel also falls into a common trap of longer novels: The beginning feels longer than it needed to be and the finale is too short. The last 50 or so pages are a wild ride in the best way possible, but it would be nice if that part of the plot was elaborated on a bit more, instead of having a middle section this long. While reading the novel is fun for almost the entire experience, sometimes it feels like nothing happened for the first 60 or so percent of the novel. It is only after the darkest hour that things really start to get into motion.
The novel has quite a few characters. Pretty much all of them are compelling and likable in one way or another. But many of the side characters do feel rather flat, they only have one or two traits. Example: Dockson is the planning and bureaucracy guy, Ham is the strong guy who likes philosophy, Breeze is the fancy talky guy who doesn't like physical work. Still, these characters are very enjoyable, but they could use and deserve some more characterization and identity.
Now while Vin and Kelsier are (a bit) less flat than the rest, Vin, the protagonist, is a difficult to enjoy character. In the beginning, she has a strong ‘I’m not like other girls.‘ mentality which is annoying really quickly. Sanderson also felt the need to remind the reader at least twice per chapter of her issues to trust others until like page 400 (This is an exaggeration (probably)) which is clear even without the regular reminders. She’s extremely distanced toward everyone at all times, which results in her making it hard for even the reader to form a connection with her.
Spoiler:
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
relaxing
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
tldr:
Everything in these pages has impeccable vibes. The protagonists are really fun and the side characters are also surprisingly compelling. The world and non-romance plot too are way better than they needed to be. However the romance itself leaves something to be desired. Until the very end, the story feels more like enemies to friends than enemy to lovers. Also the protagonists are much less morally gray than you’d expect from their set-up.
Long version:
If you were to describe this novel in only one word, it would probably be: vibes. It is really good at evoking certain feelings in all aspects of itself; mostly whimsy, festivity, melancholy and somberness. Usually, these opposing feelings masterfully appear simultaneously; for example the story is set during a great time of festivals and joy in the middle of a cold, unforgiving winter.
The story takes place in a fantasy version of 19th Century Poland in the middle of a major political drama: after a lost civil war, the nation is occupied by fantasy Russia. While these politics never take center stage, the history and conflicts of the place feel as if there is a lot going on that's not written down. The novel doesn't focus too much on worldbuilding but just enough that everything feels real and is a joy too experience. What is there is quite interesting and digging deeper into it sounds enticing.
However, it is a little irritating how close to reality this world is in parts. For example, the Russia stand-in is called Rusja. And there are other details, like the mention of real world religions. It never actively harms the experience, but it does make you wonder why the author (barely) tried to obscure the very obvious real world analogies.
Like the world, the characters are also a lot of fun. Both of the protagonists have very distinct and enjoyable personalities that complement each other in interesting ways. Especially Marynka is a pure joy to experience most of the time. Zosia too has an engaging identity and backstory but is sort of drowned out by Marynka's sheer force of personality in the beginning. However as the story goes on, she does a great job at establishing herself as an equal to Marynka in terms of reader enjoyment.
On top of that, the side characters are amazing too. There are three of them who are more fleshed out, but even those that only appear for a few pages are great. A lot about them is revealed in the short time they are given attention. Similarly, the more important side characters – Beata, Jozef and Kajetan – have a quickly established identities and even character arcs that rival those of the protagonists.
Some characters that are sadly lacking however are the witches; the foster parents, teachers and to some extent antagonists to Marynka and Zosia. For all the talk about them, they appear precious little. Zosia's witch does not appear a single time but is only ever talked about or threatened to be nearby. Marynka's witch appears shortly in the prologue and at the end for the final climax. And when she's there, she is a bit underwhelming. Neither witch feels like the threat their students want us to believe they are – or like fleshed out characters in general.
It is also needed to point out that the back side of the book can be a bit misleading as to where the story goes. Firstly, the story heavily implies itself to be enemies to lovers, which is debateable. Were it not for the final chapter and the epilogue (which should have been cut anyway), there would not be a single romantic interaction, thought or scene in here. The dynamic between Maryinka and Zosia reads more like two people who realize they went through the same hardships and want to help each other heal now, rather than develop romantic feelings for the other.
Similarly, Marynka and Zosia are not morally gray/dubious characters, even though it feels like they should be. They are instead morally good people who VERY occasionally kill. Side characters who do dubious things also either spend their time redeeming themselves for that or are full-on villains.
The final potential problem is that, somehow, the protagonists never turn into public enemies. Prince Jozef takes until the very end to learn they are witches. Whenever they interact with him, there’s a convenient aspect of the scene at hand that conceals their identities from him and everybody else. Therefore their interactions with him rarely demand for caution and they can walk the city streets no problem. The tension in these spaces is never very high, even though the novel suggests it would be eventually and it would make for very interesting stories and challenges.
Finally, the ending. It’s where the novel stumbles the most – not only because it ends either roughly 20 pages later than it should have or a few pages too soon, depending on your opinion. Because of that, the story hangs in a weird limbo between open-ended and concluded. The character are so close to getting what they want, but don’t have the two additional pages to actually get it.
The other option – where the novel stopped earlier at a point with the conflicts resolved but it’s not quite clear where the character would/should go now – would have made for a more interesting ending.
(Spoilers for the rest if the review)
The build-up to the final climax is nice, narratively and emotionally. Where it fails however is how unapologetically good it is, despite some clear signposting it shouldn’t be. The author seems to have run out of pages or ideas to explain what happened, therefore the characters suggested to die here simply don’t. And there’s no explanation given as to why and how they survived – unless you count ‘They wanted to/sheer willpower’ as a sufficient explanation.
Everything in these pages has impeccable vibes. The protagonists are really fun and the side characters are also surprisingly compelling. The world and non-romance plot too are way better than they needed to be. However the romance itself leaves something to be desired. Until the very end, the story feels more like enemies to friends than enemy to lovers. Also the protagonists are much less morally gray than you’d expect from their set-up.
Long version:
If you were to describe this novel in only one word, it would probably be: vibes. It is really good at evoking certain feelings in all aspects of itself; mostly whimsy, festivity, melancholy and somberness. Usually, these opposing feelings masterfully appear simultaneously; for example the story is set during a great time of festivals and joy in the middle of a cold, unforgiving winter.
The story takes place in a fantasy version of 19th Century Poland in the middle of a major political drama: after a lost civil war, the nation is occupied by fantasy Russia. While these politics never take center stage, the history and conflicts of the place feel as if there is a lot going on that's not written down. The novel doesn't focus too much on worldbuilding but just enough that everything feels real and is a joy too experience. What is there is quite interesting and digging deeper into it sounds enticing.
However, it is a little irritating how close to reality this world is in parts. For example, the Russia stand-in is called Rusja. And there are other details, like the mention of real world religions. It never actively harms the experience, but it does make you wonder why the author (barely) tried to obscure the very obvious real world analogies.
Like the world, the characters are also a lot of fun. Both of the protagonists have very distinct and enjoyable personalities that complement each other in interesting ways. Especially Marynka is a pure joy to experience most of the time. Zosia too has an engaging identity and backstory but is sort of drowned out by Marynka's sheer force of personality in the beginning. However as the story goes on, she does a great job at establishing herself as an equal to Marynka in terms of reader enjoyment.
On top of that, the side characters are amazing too. There are three of them who are more fleshed out, but even those that only appear for a few pages are great. A lot about them is revealed in the short time they are given attention. Similarly, the more important side characters – Beata, Jozef and Kajetan – have a quickly established identities and even character arcs that rival those of the protagonists.
Some characters that are sadly lacking however are the witches; the foster parents, teachers and to some extent antagonists to Marynka and Zosia. For all the talk about them, they appear precious little. Zosia's witch does not appear a single time but is only ever talked about or threatened to be nearby. Marynka's witch appears shortly in the prologue and at the end for the final climax. And when she's there, she is a bit underwhelming. Neither witch feels like the threat their students want us to believe they are – or like fleshed out characters in general.
It is also needed to point out that the back side of the book can be a bit misleading as to where the story goes. Firstly, the story heavily implies itself to be enemies to lovers, which is debateable. Were it not for the final chapter and the epilogue (which should have been cut anyway), there would not be a single romantic interaction, thought or scene in here. The dynamic between Maryinka and Zosia reads more like two people who realize they went through the same hardships and want to help each other heal now, rather than develop romantic feelings for the other.
Similarly, Marynka and Zosia are not morally gray/dubious characters, even though it feels like they should be. They are instead morally good people who VERY occasionally kill. Side characters who do dubious things also either spend their time redeeming themselves for that or are full-on villains.
The final potential problem is that, somehow, the protagonists never turn into public enemies. Prince Jozef takes until the very end to learn they are witches. Whenever they interact with him, there’s a convenient aspect of the scene at hand that conceals their identities from him and everybody else. Therefore their interactions with him rarely demand for caution and they can walk the city streets no problem. The tension in these spaces is never very high, even though the novel suggests it would be eventually and it would make for very interesting stories and challenges.
Finally, the ending. It’s where the novel stumbles the most – not only because it ends either roughly 20 pages later than it should have or a few pages too soon, depending on your opinion. Because of that, the story hangs in a weird limbo between open-ended and concluded. The character are so close to getting what they want, but don’t have the two additional pages to actually get it.
The other option – where the novel stopped earlier at a point with the conflicts resolved but it’s not quite clear where the character would/should go now – would have made for a more interesting ending.
(Spoilers for the rest if the review)
The build-up to the final climax is nice, narratively and emotionally. Where it fails however is how unapologetically good it is, despite some clear signposting it shouldn’t be. The author seems to have run out of pages or ideas to explain what happened, therefore the characters suggested to die here simply don’t. And there’s no explanation given as to why and how they survived – unless you count ‘They wanted to/sheer willpower’ as a sufficient explanation.
adventurous
challenging
emotional
funny
lighthearted
reflective
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Context: This is my first Terry Pratchett/Discworld novel.
tldr:
It is hard to find something to criticize about this novel. Truly all of the characters are amazing - funny and emotionally complex - and so is the world. Everything in these pages makes you laugh and then think about surprisingly deep and difficult to answer questions. The concept of religions is explored in a critical and respectful way that both atheists and religious people can learn from.
Long version:
The first thing that jumps at the reader is Pratchett's incredible prose. It is so full of personality and charm that it's really hard to put the book away again. Throughout the entire work is weaved a thread of whimsical amusement that somehow doesn't undercut the more serious and/or emotional scenes. Rather it enables the entire world to pull you in and help you connect more with it and the characters, which in turn makes said emotional beats hit even harder.
Said world is brilliantly realized. The characters visit several locations that always feel vivid and real, despite some of them being profoundly absurd. The world is a breathing organism and not just a stage to explore the themes of the plot, though it does that exceptionally well too.
Terry Pratchett uses these places to explore and discuss how gods and their followers live together from several angles. He asks what it means to be a god or a believer and does a great job at displaying the problems that can arise from religion, especially the institutions that represent it, without ever ridiculing the concept of faith in general. This exploration is nuanced and complex but executed in a way that's easily understandable. As the characters – religious or not – come into contact with other faiths and opinions, they begin to uncover more about their own believes, and so does the reader.
However the highlights of the story are to no surprise the two protagonists: Brutha the Mortal and Om the Great God.
Even to someone who never had a strong belief in religion, the story of a man who gets disillusioned with his church and later his god - even though he can talk to him - is truly touching. Brutha's development throughout the novel is inspiring and gratifying when in the end he becomes who he was always meant to be – radically changed by his experiences but also more himself than ever before.
One weird aspect however is his inability to read. It is there for a reason, but it does clash with his ability to memorize everything with uncanny speed and accuracy, which is also an essential part of the story.
But just as great a character as Brutha is, so is the second protagonist: the Great God Om, turned into a half-blind tortoise. Like Brutha, he starts off deeply flawed, but instead of naive, inexperienced and so good-hearted that he hurts himself, Om is angry, arrogant but also weak and helpless. Unlike Brutha, he is smart from the beginning and quickly puzzles together why he lost his powers and has to rely on Brutha - much to his initial dismay. For the reader however this is great because the two synergize so well with each other – both in the comedic and the serious parts.
What however starts as a relationship in which Om is only interested in his own survival develops into a truly heart-touching friendship in which both of them help each other overcome their struggles within the world and within themselves. Through his interaction with the world and Brutha, Om is forced to confront the question of what it means to be a good god. Though he is likable from the beginning, his development from there onward only makes him more and more sympathetic. His final character resolution is one of the best out there. It is clever from a writing standpoint, emotional and gratifying. It makes you cheer out loud for him and the rest of the world and characters.
tldr:
It is hard to find something to criticize about this novel. Truly all of the characters are amazing - funny and emotionally complex - and so is the world. Everything in these pages makes you laugh and then think about surprisingly deep and difficult to answer questions. The concept of religions is explored in a critical and respectful way that both atheists and religious people can learn from.
Long version:
The first thing that jumps at the reader is Pratchett's incredible prose. It is so full of personality and charm that it's really hard to put the book away again. Throughout the entire work is weaved a thread of whimsical amusement that somehow doesn't undercut the more serious and/or emotional scenes. Rather it enables the entire world to pull you in and help you connect more with it and the characters, which in turn makes said emotional beats hit even harder.
Said world is brilliantly realized. The characters visit several locations that always feel vivid and real, despite some of them being profoundly absurd. The world is a breathing organism and not just a stage to explore the themes of the plot, though it does that exceptionally well too.
Terry Pratchett uses these places to explore and discuss how gods and their followers live together from several angles. He asks what it means to be a god or a believer and does a great job at displaying the problems that can arise from religion, especially the institutions that represent it, without ever ridiculing the concept of faith in general. This exploration is nuanced and complex but executed in a way that's easily understandable. As the characters – religious or not – come into contact with other faiths and opinions, they begin to uncover more about their own believes, and so does the reader.
However the highlights of the story are to no surprise the two protagonists: Brutha the Mortal and Om the Great God.
Even to someone who never had a strong belief in religion, the story of a man who gets disillusioned with his church and later his god - even though he can talk to him - is truly touching. Brutha's development throughout the novel is inspiring and gratifying when in the end he becomes who he was always meant to be – radically changed by his experiences but also more himself than ever before.
One weird aspect however is his inability to read. It is there for a reason, but it does clash with his ability to memorize everything with uncanny speed and accuracy, which is also an essential part of the story.
But just as great a character as Brutha is, so is the second protagonist: the Great God Om, turned into a half-blind tortoise. Like Brutha, he starts off deeply flawed, but instead of naive, inexperienced and so good-hearted that he hurts himself, Om is angry, arrogant but also weak and helpless. Unlike Brutha, he is smart from the beginning and quickly puzzles together why he lost his powers and has to rely on Brutha - much to his initial dismay. For the reader however this is great because the two synergize so well with each other – both in the comedic and the serious parts.
What however starts as a relationship in which Om is only interested in his own survival develops into a truly heart-touching friendship in which both of them help each other overcome their struggles within the world and within themselves. Through his interaction with the world and Brutha, Om is forced to confront the question of what it means to be a good god. Though he is likable from the beginning, his development from there onward only makes him more and more sympathetic. His final character resolution is one of the best out there. It is clever from a writing standpoint, emotional and gratifying. It makes you cheer out loud for him and the rest of the world and characters.
challenging
dark
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
I liked the part of the story that was actually about the picture of Dorian Gray.
The parts about Sybil Vane were nice too I guess. However it feels like 70% of the novel are dedicated to Henry Wotton preaching his life philosophies and random side characters that never return telling him how horrible his philosophies are. Also the longest chapter in the book is just a completely unneccesary list of all the cool rocks and paintings and stuff that Dorian has collected.
The parts about Sybil Vane were nice too I guess. However it feels like 70% of the novel are dedicated to Henry Wotton preaching his life philosophies and random side characters that never return telling him how horrible his philosophies are. Also the longest chapter in the book is just a completely unneccesary list of all the cool rocks and paintings and stuff that Dorian has collected.
adventurous
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
No
challenging
informative
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
The novel is mostly separated into an autobiographical story of Kate Charlesworth's life and informative collage pages explaining historical events and people.
I don't have much to say about the biographical part of it. It is nice and there are some interesting beats to it. But it mostly serves to ground the informative pages into a world, so that you can understand their significance more easily.
A problem that arises in these pages is that we often jump several years or even decades into the future or past, seemingly at random. Even text boxes like "Three years later" or "1986" become increasingly more rare. This paired with the fact that we often get dialogue only in fragments or with heavy dialects can make it hard to understand what is actually going on.
The info pages are nice but often give only small insight into each individual topic. This novel is a good introduction to gay history but it expects you to do further research on your own if something interests you.
It is also important to mention some flaws of them - which the author however is very aware of and warns you about in the very beginning. The novel mainly focuses on British LGBT+ history and celebrities from the 1950s to around 2019. This means that the information in it is scewed heavily towards white people, most of them lesbian or or gay. People of color, bisexual people and trans people are rather rare. Anything else is not or barely mentioned at all.
These pages can also get a bit disorienting in their layout, but it is less of a problem here because most text boxes stand for themselves and don't tell a larger story.
Another problem that arises in autobiography, plain information and from the interplay of the two is that the novel throws a lot of names at you and it's hard to tell which ones are necessary to remember.
Sometimes people are mentioned again 50+ pages after they've been introduced for a few panels. Or we are told of people who only much later get an info page to tell us who they actually were. By that time you may have forgotten they came up before in the first place.
Especially since there are three different Jackies, two of them moderately important.
As an introductory text to queer history it fulfills its job but you have to pay close attention, even when you read it only for entertainment.
I don't have much to say about the biographical part of it. It is nice and there are some interesting beats to it. But it mostly serves to ground the informative pages into a world, so that you can understand their significance more easily.
A problem that arises in these pages is that we often jump several years or even decades into the future or past, seemingly at random. Even text boxes like "Three years later" or "1986" become increasingly more rare. This paired with the fact that we often get dialogue only in fragments or with heavy dialects can make it hard to understand what is actually going on.
The info pages are nice but often give only small insight into each individual topic. This novel is a good introduction to gay history but it expects you to do further research on your own if something interests you.
It is also important to mention some flaws of them - which the author however is very aware of and warns you about in the very beginning. The novel mainly focuses on British LGBT+ history and celebrities from the 1950s to around 2019. This means that the information in it is scewed heavily towards white people, most of them lesbian or or gay. People of color, bisexual people and trans people are rather rare. Anything else is not or barely mentioned at all.
These pages can also get a bit disorienting in their layout, but it is less of a problem here because most text boxes stand for themselves and don't tell a larger story.
Another problem that arises in autobiography, plain information and from the interplay of the two is that the novel throws a lot of names at you and it's hard to tell which ones are necessary to remember.
Sometimes people are mentioned again 50+ pages after they've been introduced for a few panels. Or we are told of people who only much later get an info page to tell us who they actually were. By that time you may have forgotten they came up before in the first place.
Especially since there are three different Jackies, two of them moderately important.
As an introductory text to queer history it fulfills its job but you have to pay close attention, even when you read it only for entertainment.