orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

Atalanta by Jennifer Saint
3.0
adventurous reflective tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Complicated

Context:
I have not read the original story of the Argonauts, only a brief summary of it, and I’m only vaguely familiar with a few stories of Atalanta. But every so often throughout reading this novel, I would read up on further details about what happened in the original tellings and how.

tldr/summary:
This story reeks of potential that sadly goes largely unused. All the ingredients are there to tell a truly amazing story about a woman who claimed her title as hero in a male dominated society. However it appears that the author prioritized accuracy to the myths over telling that story. This on several occasions creates a weird disconnect between what happens and how the reader is supposed to feel about those events. The story becomes a messy succession of interesting, enrapturing story events and disappointing, strange ones.

Long version:
In essence, this novel feels like an ideal foundation on which one can construct a truly brilliant story. But the author seems to lack the confidence to really commit to writing this story. It would involve changing the original myths too much or adding on them too much. It would involve giving the characters meaningful flaws to let them go through actual arcs. Sometimes it appears as though there’s some amazing subtext, but it is so subtle that it’s unclear the author intended that subtext to be there in the first place. The story’s highs are high but the lows are also really low.
The story is split into three parts; their pace, location, storyline, supporting characters etc. so vastly different every time that it hardly feels like they all belong to the same story. The only consistent through-lines are Atalanta and Artemis, the mortal and the goddess she worships and quests for. And even Artemis is barely a presence in the middle part.

Atalanta’s journey begins with her birth and being raised by the creatures of the Arcadian Forest, under Artemis’ protection. Although the vibes of this magical forest are immaculate, little actually happens in it. Most of the time, the characters here act as mouthpieces to tell or act out myths which usually don’t even connect to Atalanta or the rest of the novel’s plot. There are parts in here which are necessary for the later plot, but the whole segment should have been shortened. In its current form it is really slow and uneventful, bordering on boring.

Eventually however, Artemis gives Atalanta the quest to join the Argonauts on their journey to Colchis, where they’ll take the Golden Fleece so Jason can become king of Iolcus. This is the second and longest part of the story, where the plot truly begins and picks up both pace and action. But at the same time, it doesn’t really do that. Until the Argonauts reach Colchis, there’s only one stop on their journey that gets fleshed out more: the very first one. After the ship leaves Lemnos, the story quickly becomes very episodic: the Argonauts land in a new location, are confronted with a new problem, overcome it easily and leave again. 
Since the author decided to focus on the more interpersonal dynamics of the crew, the tests of strength take a backseat. This in itself is fine – these people are Greece’s most accomplished heroes after all, they should have no problem killing a bunch of giants etc. – but it does have the side effect of turning most of the story’s actual plot into trivial challenges. Therefore the encounters don’t really rise in tension, the stakes never really get higher, and as a result it doesn’t really feel like the story is picking up pace and really getting started until the Argonauts reach Colchis a good way into the novel.
Another problem of this approach is: most Argonauts are really bland and boring. Almost all of them are more defined by what they can do – fly, sing really good, be the son of a god – rather than who they actually are. The only ones of note really are Jason, Heracles and Meleager. Jason doesn’t really do much before the events in Colchis but he’s a mostly dislikeable guy, intentionally so. He’s a bad leader who prefers to let others do the work and who can be easily manipulated by others. The story makes sure to show that on several occasions.
Heracles is the only really enjoyable character in this segment. He starts of as a jerk towards Atalanta but it quickly becomes clear that he and her have quite a lot in common. They are both rather pragmatic and fully focused on achieving their goals and sticking to their duties. Once he realizes that, he gears towards becoming appreciative of the only woman on this journey as an equal warrior and thereby being the only character in the story (besides Atalanta herself) who starts having a character arc where he overcomes his flaws and meaningfully changes. There are so many characters in this text and almost all of them remain absolutely static throughout the entirety of it. 
But even Heracles doesn’t really get to change, because after he warms up a little to Atalanta, he is forced to leave on the third major stop of the journey and never returns, leaving his teased character arc unresolved. Why is he given so much attention if he’s barely in the story? There are more than enough Argonauts to give some others more depth; for example the story could have explored what Orpheus, a musician, is doing on this journey to slay monsters and fight warriors all over the Black Sea. But it doesn’t.
And then there is Meleager, Atalanta’s first ally among the Argonauts and love interest. He is such an annoying, shallow character who for the majority of the story feels like he’s just there to provide cheap, poorly executed drama to Atalanta (who had sworn to Artemis not to marry any man ever). He is such an idiot that you feel like he’s supposed to be a bad guy, only there to highlight what a great man Hippomenes is in the last part of the story. But then the story always treats him as a good man and hero and claims it’s so tragic that he dies a completely avoidable death, caused by his own idiocy. His personality is so bland and there’s no development between him and Atalanta at all: they are friends at first sight and in love only days later. And then his whole personality has been on display even though the journey barely started.
Eventually however, the crew reaches Colchis. This segment is perfectly fine, but there’s not much to point out, positively or negatively. Medea is an interesting, deeply flawed character, well deserving of her own story in which she is explored more deeply. A similar thing can be said for Atalanta’s visit to Meleager’s homeland after the Argonauts return to Greece (if you ignore that Meleager had to act like an idiot, so that he would die).

And so the story transitions towards Atalanta’s life after the journey of the Argonauts, the best segment of the novel. She has become pregnant with Meleager’s child, so Artemis tells she is never allowed to return home and has to fend on her own now. Though it is a bit jarring to come from the fast-paced action-packed ship voyage to this slow, more pensive life of a retired hero, it does have a nice side effect: Almost 300 pages in, we finally get to sit down and explore the identity and inner feelings of the titular character. 
Up until now Atalanta has been rather bland; her only real traits were being good at hunting, running and being in love with in Meleager. She has no meaningful personality, positive or negative. Most of the myths played out in Arcadia and the adventures of the Argonauts aren’t her stories, so she is usually just there watching the plot happen to someone else. Now we finally get to see a story that truly feels like it’s hers: rejected by her travel companions and patron goddess, Atalanta has to figure out how to provide for herself and her newborn child.
Aiding her in this endeavor is her new sidekick Hippomenes. He’s been in the story before but only now does he become a major character. And in that role he is the platonic ideal of what Meleager seemingly was supposed to be: He’s not just shallowly obsessed with a girl who can fight and really sees who Atalanta is behind her facade. He genuinely cares for her and doesn’t appear like he would drop her because he got bored of her after a few months. He and Atalanta have such good and healthy chemistry that one can really root for the two getting married, even though it should normally feel displaced in a story about a woman claiming her place in a male dominated world.
However, likeable as he is, in the end he is another man helping Atalanta find solutions to her problems and persuading her into certain actions. This is a reoccurring problem with the novel: Atalanta is a really passive character. The story begins with Artemis telling her to join the Argonauts, there she works under the rule of Jason together with Meleager, who is quite a force of personality. When she returns to Arcadia with a new understanding of men and love (and pregnant), she doesn’t choose to reject Artemis’ restrictive rules for her worshipers and build a new life for herself; Artemis comes to Atalanta telling her she can no longer live in Arcadia and has to figure out life elsewhere.
Then she reunites with Hippomenes who tells her that her father, King Iasus, wants her back and that it might be good for her son to grow up in a palace. When her father acknowledges her as his daughter, he forces her to marry someone. She manages to defend herself against suitors for a while until Hippomenes tricks her with Aphrodite’s help (also, she likes him too much to let him be killed) and the two get married, only to get cursed by an angry Rhea and once more seeking out Artemis. 
The only two meaningful decisions she makes are convincing Jason that he should continue his mission instead of settling down on Lemnos and deciding that marrying Hippomenes isn’t so bad after all. Otherwise her life – to the very end – is defined by others ordering her around and making decisions for her.
The ending in general has weird tones to it. It clearly tries to paint a very tragic event as something positive. Allegedly, Atalanta finally escapes the grasp of gods and men and is truly free. But then Aphrodite tricks her into awakening Rhea’s wrath, who turns her into an animal, before in the second to last paragraph, Atalanta runs back to Artemis and regains her favor. So she is not free from the gods controlling her life, regardless of whether she loves being a lion or not. Here, more clearly than elsewhere, the conflict is visible between painting Atalanta as a strong woman who carved out her own destiny, and being loyal to the myths, that plagues the entire novel.