Take a photo of a barcode or cover
orcinus_olive 's review for:
The Final Empire
by Brandon Sanderson
adventurous
dark
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
tldr/summary:
The world of the Final Empire is quite fascinating and exploring it is really entertaining, but it can become a bit monotone and gray (literally) over all these pages. From culture and history to magic and politics, the world is filled with interesting ideas.
The plot is really gripping with its many facets, developments and twists. It is the perfect playground for an array of enjoyable characters, good and evil. The novel could have actually done more with its side characters, fun as they are. If only the main protagonist of Vin wasn’t so hard to find an emotional connection to.
Long version:
The world of the Final Empire is quite intriguing, full of mysteries and characters wishing to be explored. And this feeling of wanting to dive deeper doesn’t ebb off as one learns more about the world. This is true for small scale events and people as well as global politics – especially the global politics were quite interesting and need to be discussed in greater detail in the sequels.
However it needs to be noted that the Empire can be quite stagnant and monotone in many parts – being a one thousand year old country with an immortal ruler. The story is primarily set in one city – one that is big, oppressive and dirty. It and the entire world feel (and literally are) rather gray. Even the plants here are no longer green. While there are some really vibrant and lively events throughout the plot, the world can become a bit tiring and dead over several hundred pages and leave you desiring for some variety and change.
A central feature of this world is it’s metal-based Allomancy Magic. Even though Sanderson already has a reputation of creating really interesting magic system, it's surprising how creatively he plays with his rules and limitations, how many interesting ways of using one singular ability he can think of. Further developments and new revelations are also elegantly executed and don't feel like they come out of nowhere to resolve plot.
All these factors are true from the very beginning and remain true as the plot progresses and things begin to change. It is very satisfying to see people plan out a mission to overthrow a government and learn the intricacies of their magic and non-magic abilities. Even as complications show up and they have to make detours toward their destination, things remain interesting. Side plots don’t feel like a waste of time. They are enjoyable in and of themselves and in the way they build the world, show off the characters and progress the main plot. Sanderson understands how to make the plot progress and escalate in believable and meaningful ways.
The plot twists and worldbuilding revelations are of the same nature, though Sanderson could let people figure stuff out for themselves instead of actively explaining them. He really isn't subtle about his subtext and usually spells things out quite clearly when he doesn’t have to; e.g. when we learn the details of Mare’s betrayal. Especially in the epilogue, that's super annoying.
This novel also falls into a common trap of longer novels: The beginning feels longer than it needed to be and the finale is too short. The last 50 or so pages are a wild ride in the best way possible, but it would be nice if that part of the plot was elaborated on a bit more, instead of having a middle section this long. While reading the novel is fun for almost the entire experience, sometimes it feels like nothing happened for the first 60 or so percent of the novel. It is only after the darkest hour that things really start to get into motion.
The novel has quite a few characters. Pretty much all of them are compelling and likable in one way or another. But many of the side characters do feel rather flat, they only have one or two traits. Example: Dockson is the planning and bureaucracy guy, Ham is the strong guy who likes philosophy, Breeze is the fancy talky guy who doesn't like physical work. Still, these characters are very enjoyable, but they could use and deserve some more characterization and identity.
Now while Vin and Kelsier are (a bit) less flat than the rest, Vin, the protagonist, is a difficult to enjoy character. In the beginning, she has a strong ‘I’m not like other girls.‘ mentality which is annoying really quickly. Sanderson also felt the need to remind the reader at least twice per chapter of her issues to trust others until like page 400 (This is an exaggeration (probably)) which is clear even without the regular reminders. She’s extremely distanced toward everyone at all times, which results in her making it hard for even the reader to form a connection with her.
Spoiler:
Less people should have died. Most deaths didn’t really illicit too much emotion; the characters are taken out of the experience quite unceremoniously and without all that much impact on the plot. That makes it even worse when you feel like the characters that die would be more interesting if they stayed alive, e.g. Yeden.
The world of the Final Empire is quite fascinating and exploring it is really entertaining, but it can become a bit monotone and gray (literally) over all these pages. From culture and history to magic and politics, the world is filled with interesting ideas.
The plot is really gripping with its many facets, developments and twists. It is the perfect playground for an array of enjoyable characters, good and evil. The novel could have actually done more with its side characters, fun as they are. If only the main protagonist of Vin wasn’t so hard to find an emotional connection to.
Long version:
The world of the Final Empire is quite intriguing, full of mysteries and characters wishing to be explored. And this feeling of wanting to dive deeper doesn’t ebb off as one learns more about the world. This is true for small scale events and people as well as global politics – especially the global politics were quite interesting and need to be discussed in greater detail in the sequels.
However it needs to be noted that the Empire can be quite stagnant and monotone in many parts – being a one thousand year old country with an immortal ruler. The story is primarily set in one city – one that is big, oppressive and dirty. It and the entire world feel (and literally are) rather gray. Even the plants here are no longer green. While there are some really vibrant and lively events throughout the plot, the world can become a bit tiring and dead over several hundred pages and leave you desiring for some variety and change.
A central feature of this world is it’s metal-based Allomancy Magic. Even though Sanderson already has a reputation of creating really interesting magic system, it's surprising how creatively he plays with his rules and limitations, how many interesting ways of using one singular ability he can think of. Further developments and new revelations are also elegantly executed and don't feel like they come out of nowhere to resolve plot.
All these factors are true from the very beginning and remain true as the plot progresses and things begin to change. It is very satisfying to see people plan out a mission to overthrow a government and learn the intricacies of their magic and non-magic abilities. Even as complications show up and they have to make detours toward their destination, things remain interesting. Side plots don’t feel like a waste of time. They are enjoyable in and of themselves and in the way they build the world, show off the characters and progress the main plot. Sanderson understands how to make the plot progress and escalate in believable and meaningful ways.
The plot twists and worldbuilding revelations are of the same nature, though Sanderson could let people figure stuff out for themselves instead of actively explaining them. He really isn't subtle about his subtext and usually spells things out quite clearly when he doesn’t have to; e.g. when we learn the details of Mare’s betrayal. Especially in the epilogue, that's super annoying.
This novel also falls into a common trap of longer novels: The beginning feels longer than it needed to be and the finale is too short. The last 50 or so pages are a wild ride in the best way possible, but it would be nice if that part of the plot was elaborated on a bit more, instead of having a middle section this long. While reading the novel is fun for almost the entire experience, sometimes it feels like nothing happened for the first 60 or so percent of the novel. It is only after the darkest hour that things really start to get into motion.
The novel has quite a few characters. Pretty much all of them are compelling and likable in one way or another. But many of the side characters do feel rather flat, they only have one or two traits. Example: Dockson is the planning and bureaucracy guy, Ham is the strong guy who likes philosophy, Breeze is the fancy talky guy who doesn't like physical work. Still, these characters are very enjoyable, but they could use and deserve some more characterization and identity.
Now while Vin and Kelsier are (a bit) less flat than the rest, Vin, the protagonist, is a difficult to enjoy character. In the beginning, she has a strong ‘I’m not like other girls.‘ mentality which is annoying really quickly. Sanderson also felt the need to remind the reader at least twice per chapter of her issues to trust others until like page 400 (This is an exaggeration (probably)) which is clear even without the regular reminders. She’s extremely distanced toward everyone at all times, which results in her making it hard for even the reader to form a connection with her.
Spoiler: