You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

1222 by Anne Holt
2.0
dark mysterious tense medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Plot
Strong character development: No
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus: No

tldr/summary:
While the mystery investigation and the side characters are quite decent, the final resolution is kind of disappointing. But that hardly matters if every neat aspect of the novel is dragged down by the protagonist and first person narrator through whose perspective the whole story is filtered. Hanne Wilhelmsen is such an insufferable character that she manages to make you stop caring about solving the crime in a crime solving story.

Long version:
This story has one glaring problem: the protagonist and first person narrator. Hanne Wilhelmsen is such an insufferable person who cannot state often enough how much she hates participating in society and nearly every individual human who has ever walked this planet. It takes her until page 55 to disclose her name to another character and even the reader because of her aggressively antisocial behavior. In the very first chapter, there’s already a side character who gets so annoyed by her – quite understandably so – that he tells her that if she is so intent on making everyone leave her alone, then she should just fuck off and be miserable on her own.
Aside from Hanne, the side characters are quite decent however. The characters that are supposed to be likeable are actually easy to like and the dislikeable characters are similarly skilled at evoking their emotion. It’s hard to find a fictional character who makes you as uncomfortable as Kari Thue. The author even manages to make the reader have more complex feelings towards characters like Adrian, who cannot simply be classified as likeable or dislikeable.
On top of that, the cast is quite diverse with characters that have a middle eastern background, dwarfism or other traits that are typically underrepresented in fiction. These characters are also rarely defined only by their diversity or associated stereotypes. Especially the character with dwarfism has a very complex character that goes beyond having sophisticated meditations on his disability, although those are nice as well. The problem here however is that Hanne is so presumptuous and judgmental about literally everyone that this representation kinda doesn’t feel good anymore. Some things she says or thinks early on feel really quite offensive; and the book isn’t interested in confronting that fact at all.

On paper, investigating the central mystery of who is the murderer is neatly executed. There are not too obvious clues lying around and Hanne doesn’t make absolutely wild deduction leaps that no real person could ever replicate. But when it comes to foreshadowing or withholding information from the reader, the author is rather clumsy at that. There are several paragraphs where Hanne’s narrative voice notes that she realized or remembered something or put two pieces of information together. She states that this now changes everything but then refuses to elaborate on what she just figured out. An example of that is when she says that she figured out where she has seen someone before and which emotions that invokes in her, but then refuses to tell the reader who that person is.
Another thing that frequently happens is when a conversation is broken off by another character joining in or by some other sudden event. This always happens right before some game-changing information is revealed and it’s pretty obvious that that would have happened, were it not for the random interruption.
This technique also comes into play when the author seems to not know how to transition from one scene to the next or deal with the consequences of what was just said; even in cases where it would be very interesting to see how the current situation resolves or continues without the interruption.
But in a sense, this barely matters because Hanne’s general disinterest in everyone and everything kinda makes you stop caring about the murder case too.

This story has two mysteries to solve: Who killed the dead people and what’s in the mysterious, locked up train carriage?
The resolution to the first question was kind of underwhelming. It is realistic, logical and the reader could have deduced it on their own, sure. But that doesn’t mean it isn’t rather boring. It doesn’t help either that you can easily nail it down to two or three possible suspects simply by asking the question: “Do you have a purpose in the story other than being the murderer?“
Finding out the secret of the mystery carriage on the other hand was disappointing in the complete opposite direction. It is so far-fetched, unrealistic and frankly just ridiculously bonkers that you have to wonder why anyone thought this reveal would be a good scene to end the novel on, rather than giving us a few final moments with the likeable side characters (like the beginning of the final chapter implies would be happening). Without going into details, it is also incredibly dated. You can really tell when this story was published simply because of this reveal.

Also there’s a scene where a dog gets brutally murdered. Was that really necessary?