Take a photo of a barcode or cover
orcinus_olive 's review for:
The Hobbit: or There and Back Again
by J.R.R. Tolkien
adventurous
hopeful
lighthearted
reflective
relaxing
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
tldr/summary:
The story takes a while to get rolling and be interesting. In the way of an exciting second half stands a set of beginning chapters which are quite formulaic, repetitive, even a bit bland and empty. Once Bilbo and the world he’s in however find their footing on the page, things become more intriguing. The conflict of the final chapters still feels fresh to this day and Bilbo and the characters around him have grown to become really enjoyable.
Long version:
This is a difficult story to judge, maybe more 3.5/5 than 3/5. Overall it was a pleasant experience, but it needs to be said that after the company leaves the whimsical Hobbiton, the journey starts on its weakest point. However it gets progressively better all the way to the end. A lot of that can probably be attributed to Tolkien’s writing style since it has such a strong personality, both to its fault and benefit.
Especially in the beginning, Tolkien often just says something happened with much less emphasis on these events than you’d expect. He has this tendency of telling the story and every now and then saying things like “Oh by the way, when Bilbo and the dwarves left Elrond several days ago, Elrond gave Gandalf a new horse.” even though he’s already spent a good few pages telling the reader what had occurred since the thing he just mentioned offhandedly. He jumps around in the chronology of the narrative – telling us what had happened while this other event from a while ago had happened – quite a few times, which can be really disorienting.
The writing in general can feel a bit messy at times, as if Tolkien just wrote down whatever came to his mind the moment he thought of that thing. For example, there’s a scene early on where Elrond tells the company about the elven swords they had come across earlier, their names, purpose and so on. However later on, the narrator just randomly points out “Oh by the way, they also glow blue when goblins are nearby.”, something that Elrond would have definitely known. It feels as if Tolkien only came up with that fun idea later on and didn’t put that information to a more fitting spot when he polished up the story. Something like this happens several times, like when people started referring to Lake Town as Esgaroth midway through the story.
However Tolkien seems to have gotten a grip on these two problems as he progressed in writing the story, as they become rarer to nonexistent in the later parts. And when Tolkien sets his mind to writing out a scene instead of just telling you that it happened off-page, it is a pure joy to read. He had an amazing sense of giving every place, character or event personality and charm and knew how to describe something so vividly that you can feel it come alive and stay alive even as the story moves on to something different.
This extraordinary prose is allowed to shine especially in the more whimsical, optimistic parts of the story, like everything that happens in Hobbiton at the beginning and end of the story: Bilbo’s everyday life, the visit of the dwarves and the reaction of the other hobbits upon Bilbo’s return. But Tolkien is also a master of the more epic scenes. The Battle of Five Armies is so expertly described that you really feel the scale of the place, the violence and the heroics.
What doesn’t really get better however is the thirteen dwarves. Thirteen more or less main characters are a lot, so it is understandable that many of them don’t have a very developed identity; Thorin is the leader, Fili and Kili are the youngest and Bombur is the fattest (and even those aren’t technically personality traits). The rest has basically no distinguishing features. Most of the time, the dwarves act as a collective rather than individuals.
That on its own isn’t bad. What does stand out negatively however is how annoying these guys are most of the time. Many of the problems that arise throughout the plot are caused by them. And even those that the company runs into through other means, they are unable to solve. The thirteen dwarves do not solve a single problem – regardless of whether they caused that situation, worsened it or sort of just of stumbled into it – and always have to be saved by someone else. Once the story progresses to the last third their actions become especially insufferable, not only since these guys never seem to realize this themselves.
Bilbo on the other hand is much more enjoyable. Though he starts off similarly useless, whiny and reliant on Gandalf as the dwarves, Bilbo manages to go through some major development throughout the story. Once the company has gone a good way into Mirkwood, Bilbo proves himself by solving a predicament he and the dwarves are in all by himself. This moment – though sort of overkill for only his second major trial – marks the moment where Bilbo becomes a character who is fun to watch. From there onward, he knows what he’s good and bad at and how to put these skills to use. He solves many situations by being smart rather than strong, which is very satisfying to watch. He’s also a much wiser character now who knows how to handle situations delicately, for example when to step back or give up for the greater good; something the dwarves severely lack.
For the side character of this tale, there isn’t much to say. Many of them are pleasant, but it’s hard to say more about them than “Yeah, Beorn was a cool guy”, positive or negative.
Gandalf was surprisingly mean in the beginning, but then he quickly turns into a nice, though somewhat sassy man who’s mostly just there to solve problems for the dwarves and that’s pretty much all. Even in the end he doesn’t do or say all that much. Also his power set feels widely inconsistent, making his role as a plot device even more obvious. He can defeat a group of monsters with no great struggle, but an ordinary door that is opened with an ordinary key is too powerful to be opened with his magic.
Bard is a surprisingly interesting character who manages to display a wide range of personality which plays off the other characters and the plot quite well.
And Gollum was a surprisingly touching character. Even if you know the general gist of who he is already, Tolkien wrote his parts in a way that makes you really feel what a tragic figure he is more than only hearing of him through others ever could.
The plot also has a sort of development, where it starts off rather weak but improves the more the reader (and presumably Tolkien) finds their footing in the world. Nevertheless, the opening chapters are incredibly episodic and formulaic: Bilbo and the dwarves get in trouble while Gandalf sort of disappears for a moment, only to Deus Ex Machina the situation and bring the party back on course shortly after.
At some point however, Gandalf leaves the company to walk their path on their own. From that point onward, it is Bilbo who has to save the dwarves from trouble again and again. Since he isn’t an all powerful wizard however, his rescue plans require a bit more ingenuity and entertainment factor. And once the company arrives on the foot of the Lonely Mountain, the plot changes from a simple journey to something more complex and less predictable. It is genuinely a very fun and interesting story from that point onward with more gripping questions than “How will Bilbo save the dwarves this time?” (even though he indirectly still does that).
What never changes sadly is the company’s constant lack of food. Even if they stacked up on rations just a few pages ago, Tolkien finds a way to make them loose those rations again very quickly; either the company gets attacked or there’s a time lapse. Especially Bilbo is very good at bemoaning their food situation all the time and it gets annoying and repetitive really fast.
Getting through all this however is worth it to find out what happens once Smaug is defeated. Both the build-up to the Battle of Five Armies as well as the battle itself are so much fun and still feel fresh and suspenseful to this day. Bilbo’s final journey back home was also a fun, pleasant experience, not despite its length but because of it. Tolkien really has a sense to convey that the time of conflict is over; Bilbo and his world return back to an era of peace, hope and joy. Watching Bilbo travel home to the whimsical Hobbiton is one of the more cathartic reading experience one can have. The hobbit finally gets the rest that he needs and deserves.
The story takes a while to get rolling and be interesting. In the way of an exciting second half stands a set of beginning chapters which are quite formulaic, repetitive, even a bit bland and empty. Once Bilbo and the world he’s in however find their footing on the page, things become more intriguing. The conflict of the final chapters still feels fresh to this day and Bilbo and the characters around him have grown to become really enjoyable.
Long version:
This is a difficult story to judge, maybe more 3.5/5 than 3/5. Overall it was a pleasant experience, but it needs to be said that after the company leaves the whimsical Hobbiton, the journey starts on its weakest point. However it gets progressively better all the way to the end. A lot of that can probably be attributed to Tolkien’s writing style since it has such a strong personality, both to its fault and benefit.
Especially in the beginning, Tolkien often just says something happened with much less emphasis on these events than you’d expect. He has this tendency of telling the story and every now and then saying things like “Oh by the way, when Bilbo and the dwarves left Elrond several days ago, Elrond gave Gandalf a new horse.” even though he’s already spent a good few pages telling the reader what had occurred since the thing he just mentioned offhandedly. He jumps around in the chronology of the narrative – telling us what had happened while this other event from a while ago had happened – quite a few times, which can be really disorienting.
The writing in general can feel a bit messy at times, as if Tolkien just wrote down whatever came to his mind the moment he thought of that thing. For example, there’s a scene early on where Elrond tells the company about the elven swords they had come across earlier, their names, purpose and so on. However later on, the narrator just randomly points out “Oh by the way, they also glow blue when goblins are nearby.”, something that Elrond would have definitely known. It feels as if Tolkien only came up with that fun idea later on and didn’t put that information to a more fitting spot when he polished up the story. Something like this happens several times, like when people started referring to Lake Town as Esgaroth midway through the story.
However Tolkien seems to have gotten a grip on these two problems as he progressed in writing the story, as they become rarer to nonexistent in the later parts. And when Tolkien sets his mind to writing out a scene instead of just telling you that it happened off-page, it is a pure joy to read. He had an amazing sense of giving every place, character or event personality and charm and knew how to describe something so vividly that you can feel it come alive and stay alive even as the story moves on to something different.
This extraordinary prose is allowed to shine especially in the more whimsical, optimistic parts of the story, like everything that happens in Hobbiton at the beginning and end of the story: Bilbo’s everyday life, the visit of the dwarves and the reaction of the other hobbits upon Bilbo’s return. But Tolkien is also a master of the more epic scenes. The Battle of Five Armies is so expertly described that you really feel the scale of the place, the violence and the heroics.
What doesn’t really get better however is the thirteen dwarves. Thirteen more or less main characters are a lot, so it is understandable that many of them don’t have a very developed identity; Thorin is the leader, Fili and Kili are the youngest and Bombur is the fattest (and even those aren’t technically personality traits). The rest has basically no distinguishing features. Most of the time, the dwarves act as a collective rather than individuals.
That on its own isn’t bad. What does stand out negatively however is how annoying these guys are most of the time. Many of the problems that arise throughout the plot are caused by them. And even those that the company runs into through other means, they are unable to solve. The thirteen dwarves do not solve a single problem – regardless of whether they caused that situation, worsened it or sort of just of stumbled into it – and always have to be saved by someone else. Once the story progresses to the last third their actions become especially insufferable, not only since these guys never seem to realize this themselves.
Bilbo on the other hand is much more enjoyable. Though he starts off similarly useless, whiny and reliant on Gandalf as the dwarves, Bilbo manages to go through some major development throughout the story. Once the company has gone a good way into Mirkwood, Bilbo proves himself by solving a predicament he and the dwarves are in all by himself. This moment – though sort of overkill for only his second major trial – marks the moment where Bilbo becomes a character who is fun to watch. From there onward, he knows what he’s good and bad at and how to put these skills to use. He solves many situations by being smart rather than strong, which is very satisfying to watch. He’s also a much wiser character now who knows how to handle situations delicately, for example when to step back or give up for the greater good; something the dwarves severely lack.
For the side character of this tale, there isn’t much to say. Many of them are pleasant, but it’s hard to say more about them than “Yeah, Beorn was a cool guy”, positive or negative.
Gandalf was surprisingly mean in the beginning, but then he quickly turns into a nice, though somewhat sassy man who’s mostly just there to solve problems for the dwarves and that’s pretty much all. Even in the end he doesn’t do or say all that much. Also his power set feels widely inconsistent, making his role as a plot device even more obvious. He can defeat a group of monsters with no great struggle, but an ordinary door that is opened with an ordinary key is too powerful to be opened with his magic.
Bard is a surprisingly interesting character who manages to display a wide range of personality which plays off the other characters and the plot quite well.
And Gollum was a surprisingly touching character. Even if you know the general gist of who he is already, Tolkien wrote his parts in a way that makes you really feel what a tragic figure he is more than only hearing of him through others ever could.
The plot also has a sort of development, where it starts off rather weak but improves the more the reader (and presumably Tolkien) finds their footing in the world. Nevertheless, the opening chapters are incredibly episodic and formulaic: Bilbo and the dwarves get in trouble while Gandalf sort of disappears for a moment, only to Deus Ex Machina the situation and bring the party back on course shortly after.
At some point however, Gandalf leaves the company to walk their path on their own. From that point onward, it is Bilbo who has to save the dwarves from trouble again and again. Since he isn’t an all powerful wizard however, his rescue plans require a bit more ingenuity and entertainment factor. And once the company arrives on the foot of the Lonely Mountain, the plot changes from a simple journey to something more complex and less predictable. It is genuinely a very fun and interesting story from that point onward with more gripping questions than “How will Bilbo save the dwarves this time?” (even though he indirectly still does that).
What never changes sadly is the company’s constant lack of food. Even if they stacked up on rations just a few pages ago, Tolkien finds a way to make them loose those rations again very quickly; either the company gets attacked or there’s a time lapse. Especially Bilbo is very good at bemoaning their food situation all the time and it gets annoying and repetitive really fast.
Getting through all this however is worth it to find out what happens once Smaug is defeated. Both the build-up to the Battle of Five Armies as well as the battle itself are so much fun and still feel fresh and suspenseful to this day. Bilbo’s final journey back home was also a fun, pleasant experience, not despite its length but because of it. Tolkien really has a sense to convey that the time of conflict is over; Bilbo and his world return back to an era of peace, hope and joy. Watching Bilbo travel home to the whimsical Hobbiton is one of the more cathartic reading experience one can have. The hobbit finally gets the rest that he needs and deserves.