Take a photo of a barcode or cover
funny
sad
dark
This book is deeply uncomfortable to read despite containing no subject matter that is outright transgressive. A man stumbles upon a poor strange hamlet in the middle of impossible windswept sand dunes and is imprisoned with one of the resident women at the bottom of a hole. He's told his job is to keep the shifting sand from overwhelming the house (and thus the larger hamlet). What follows is a Kafka-esque nightmarish short book in which our protagonist rages against his forced captivity, the servile, diffident nature of his female companion, musing about his freedom, his escape plans and his past life - though barely lived - while the ground is literally shifting beneath his feet.
There are some unnamed captors involved but the chief antagonist as well as the setting is the sand itself, and here the author is able to invest such incredible detail and metaphor into the nature of this tiny inorganic composite rock - that nonetheless, seen as a wider system is teeming with movement, strange behaviour, indifference or maleficence to the plight of humans, and a lot of surprising complexity in which the reader and protagonist can't help but allegorize to their own affairs. Besides entertaining a bubbling, somewhat deviant, barely repressed sexual desire, which complements and heightens the protagonist's own utter lack of consent of being held in this dune, there is nothing in the book that might traditionally invoke horror - and yet the stomach undeniably tightens as you read further on; correctly guessing how it might end does nothing to alleviate the emotion of reading it happen. Predictably, though, the actually woman in this book is treated without much depth at all, subjected to an exclusively male view making her meek, sexualized, stupid and without a hint of the psychological depth that is invested in the main character. This book is lean, and yet there are tons of symbolism to unearth and more to uncover upon successive rereads if one can stomach and appreciate the unsettling atmosphere.
There are some unnamed captors involved but the chief antagonist as well as the setting is the sand itself, and here the author is able to invest such incredible detail and metaphor into the nature of this tiny inorganic composite rock - that nonetheless, seen as a wider system is teeming with movement, strange behaviour, indifference or maleficence to the plight of humans, and a lot of surprising complexity in which the reader and protagonist can't help but allegorize to their own affairs. Besides entertaining a bubbling, somewhat deviant, barely repressed sexual desire, which complements and heightens the protagonist's own utter lack of consent of being held in this dune, there is nothing in the book that might traditionally invoke horror - and yet the stomach undeniably tightens as you read further on; correctly guessing how it might end does nothing to alleviate the emotion of reading it happen. Predictably, though, the actually woman in this book is treated without much depth at all, subjected to an exclusively male view making her meek, sexualized, stupid and without a hint of the psychological depth that is invested in the main character. This book is lean, and yet there are tons of symbolism to unearth and more to uncover upon successive rereads if one can stomach and appreciate the unsettling atmosphere.
funny
sad
Pnin traipses along in a short 200-odd page book with many of the same glimpses of sublime prose, over-detailed quotidian observations, incredible descriptions of trees and weird, semi-erotic fascinations around the mouth that enchanted readers in Lolita. Pnin is neither as dark or masterful as that book, adopting instead a wry, absurd tone that is equally as intelligent but far less arrogant and psycho-sexually charged than Humbert Humbert. That the book is more comical than the author's reputation might suggest (however much I think the book's reputation somewhat overstates its hilarity) is not to say it's a pleasant but shallow romp without subtext. Indeed, the titular character of Pnin, bumbling, often mocked, the butt of many jokes and constantly bewildered carries within him, the deep pain of the Russian emigre. His nostalgia for a pre-Bolshevik Russia entwines his transient nature, forever skipping from one rented lodging to the next, the instability of having lost the country of your memories, his impractical and useless pedagogy as an academic for the study of his mother tongue - for which he supplies plethora of past emotions, personal linguistic inventions and cultural artifacts instead of actual clear and constructive instruction.
Despite its short length, Pnin is sometimes a dry read, lacking a clear sense of focus, plot or tension that held readers of Lolita so captive. There are some very striking moments such as the description of a panic attack, an Oedipal-like episode and the wrestling of the past, half-remembered, fading all the time. There are also exasperating instances in which Nabokov ratchets up the sheer absurdity for how long he can keep a sentence going - how many innocuous, inconsequential clauses and non-sequiturs he can add in the middle - before finally, mercifully bringing the reader to a rare full-stop. The book was for the most part enjoyable and even interesting to think about but a far cry from Nabokov's peak writing.
Despite its short length, Pnin is sometimes a dry read, lacking a clear sense of focus, plot or tension that held readers of Lolita so captive. There are some very striking moments such as the description of a panic attack, an Oedipal-like episode and the wrestling of the past, half-remembered, fading all the time. There are also exasperating instances in which Nabokov ratchets up the sheer absurdity for how long he can keep a sentence going - how many innocuous, inconsequential clauses and non-sequiturs he can add in the middle - before finally, mercifully bringing the reader to a rare full-stop. The book was for the most part enjoyable and even interesting to think about but a far cry from Nabokov's peak writing.
challenging
informative
I think it's a tricky thing to make a book, whose central characters are geniuses, and that is greatly concerned with the very idea, development and overall purpose of genius and prodigious intellect. On one hand, it is all too clear if the characters are smarter than the author, leading to the spurious and shallow illusion of hyper-intelligence. On the other hand, a genuine commitment to investigating prodigious intellect can often be irritating and condescending - as if the author were constantly showing off her own knowledge of languages, classic literature, aerodynamics and mathematics. This book manages to navigate both pitfalls successfully. Sybella, an outrageous talent in her own right, lives with her young son Ludo in a tiny cold flat in London, making ends meet by digitizing inane forgotten magazine articles for a pittance and filling the empty hours of their impoverished days by riding the metro to nowhere, reading books to learn seventeen languages and obsessively watching Akira Kurosawa's Seven Samurai. This book does not shy away from the difficult material which Ludo is ingesting at an insane rate - a surprisingly interesting pedagogic tone is felt throughout the first quarter of the novel (as we are told the story through the mother's perspective). We get to see a young curious and impatient mind nurtured with what today's standards seem excessively advanced and inappropriate material. At the age where other's are watching Sesame Street, Ludo is reading Homer in Linear B Ancient Greek, studying Arabic and making his first steps to understanding Japanese Kanji, all while fostering the desire to meet his anonymous father.
In this pursuit, the novel veers off into many diverse, seemingly digressing, subtopics where one struggles to find some plot or thematic relevancy to the main story. These early digressions must be read with a bit of patience which pays off towards the middle of the book. It will become clear what these asides represent and can be appreciated as more than random commentaries on different contemporary geniuses and their outrageous improbable adventures. Despite being a book written about (and likely written by) geniuses, it is never arrogant and it will constantly make you ask what is this knowledge leading to exactly. The relief from boredom? Happiness? Financial stability? It interrogates the measures and means by which a "normal" person can become a prodigy, what do they gain, what do they lose, and what are they truly seeking through all this?
The novel's true objective comes into focus in the second half and I would definitely suggest any potential reader of this book to have watched the aforementioned Seven Samurai film by Kurosawa. I'd say only the first third of the film is strictly necessary to best enjoy this book. It looms large in the subtext of this novel and in the minds of the characters and there is a lot of humour and pleasure in trying to figure out which of the samurai characters Ludo is trying to inhabit and juggle over the course of his "quest". This is a book about genius, and while it may not be a work of genius itself, it is playful, endlessly curious and funny, and proves in the end to be an exceedingly clever story.
In this pursuit, the novel veers off into many diverse, seemingly digressing, subtopics where one struggles to find some plot or thematic relevancy to the main story. These early digressions must be read with a bit of patience which pays off towards the middle of the book. It will become clear what these asides represent and can be appreciated as more than random commentaries on different contemporary geniuses and their outrageous improbable adventures. Despite being a book written about (and likely written by) geniuses, it is never arrogant and it will constantly make you ask what is this knowledge leading to exactly. The relief from boredom? Happiness? Financial stability? It interrogates the measures and means by which a "normal" person can become a prodigy, what do they gain, what do they lose, and what are they truly seeking through all this?
The novel's true objective comes into focus in the second half and I would definitely suggest any potential reader of this book to have watched the aforementioned Seven Samurai film by Kurosawa. I'd say only the first third of the film is strictly necessary to best enjoy this book. It looms large in the subtext of this novel and in the minds of the characters and there is a lot of humour and pleasure in trying to figure out which of the samurai characters Ludo is trying to inhabit and juggle over the course of his "quest". This is a book about genius, and while it may not be a work of genius itself, it is playful, endlessly curious and funny, and proves in the end to be an exceedingly clever story.
adventurous
fast-paced
Lonesome Dove is a gigantic book full of memorable, relatable characters in a breathtaking setting of the fading frontier. With my copy coming to nearly 900 pages, this story is anything but brief and takes its time in many dozen episodes exploring the bleak people in a bleak border town; forming bizarre characteristics in a harsh environment. 900 pages will take you from the borders of Mexico to as far north as Canada as we follow a pair of retired Texas Rangers: Augustus McCrae and Woodrow Call seek to drive cattle to the unclaimed frontier of Montana - for reasons which generally escape either man.
It's easy to see why Lonesome Dove is something of a staple in the Western genre. It is big, epic and very accessible. It's harsh, dangerous setting offset by moments of cool heroism and determination, the monotony of endless barren plains are routinely interrupted with scenes of incredible and disastrous weather. Woodrow Call, the laconic leader of this cattle-drive outfit, is a deeply recognizable figure - so much has the "Western" retained some small share of cultural significance in the modern western world that even those, like me, who aren't particularly well read in the genre feel like he's a man we've all come to associate with the frontier. And yet, he's treated far more deeply than an archetype and has hidden and subtle depths - even if his general countenance evokes any number of Clint Eastwood and John Wayne inspired performances. Augustus McCrae is a more surprising figure: a pseudo-philosopher, prideful in his literacy and eloquence - his chief lamentation being the lack of an equally vigorous conversation partner so far from civilization. Through these characters, and many more, we get strong interpersonal dynamics and that ever-present Western dread, in which the race for the frontier is likewise an pyrrhic escape from the encroaching civilization at their heels.
The prose is unremarkable; it is a very easy read, anyone who can read at a highschool level should have no problems at all with this book. You will not find the jaw-dropping phrases and passages whose words sear into the mind as you would with Blood Meridian. And while there is humour in the novel and the occasional witty observation of prose, do not expect to find the raucous, incisive and charming style of something like True Grit. Indeed, what poignancy Lonesome Dove has to offer can only manifest over a series of several dozen pages, no doubt why it led to such a large page-count. It's story over style, and luckily, it's a pretty great story such that it somehow justified its absurd length and only occasionally did I lament the pedestrian sentences and word-craft (in particular, the word "sad" is insanely abused and overused in this book). That being said, there is some interesting symbolism spread throughout the tale and to be sure, Lonesome Dove seems to touch upon practically every thematic preoccupation of the genre, making it a fine candidate for being a "definitive" Western novel. Even such traditional weaknesses and expected inconsiderations with regards to native Americans and women are afforded more focus and attention (though not entirely redemptive). As a whole, Lonesome Dove is a very good novel in which the reader should not feel intimidated by its extraordinary length; the pages will fly by and hopefully the reader be taken on a wondrous journey with remarkable and tragic characters.
It's easy to see why Lonesome Dove is something of a staple in the Western genre. It is big, epic and very accessible. It's harsh, dangerous setting offset by moments of cool heroism and determination, the monotony of endless barren plains are routinely interrupted with scenes of incredible and disastrous weather. Woodrow Call, the laconic leader of this cattle-drive outfit, is a deeply recognizable figure - so much has the "Western" retained some small share of cultural significance in the modern western world that even those, like me, who aren't particularly well read in the genre feel like he's a man we've all come to associate with the frontier. And yet, he's treated far more deeply than an archetype and has hidden and subtle depths - even if his general countenance evokes any number of Clint Eastwood and John Wayne inspired performances. Augustus McCrae is a more surprising figure: a pseudo-philosopher, prideful in his literacy and eloquence - his chief lamentation being the lack of an equally vigorous conversation partner so far from civilization. Through these characters, and many more, we get strong interpersonal dynamics and that ever-present Western dread, in which the race for the frontier is likewise an pyrrhic escape from the encroaching civilization at their heels.
The prose is unremarkable; it is a very easy read, anyone who can read at a highschool level should have no problems at all with this book. You will not find the jaw-dropping phrases and passages whose words sear into the mind as you would with Blood Meridian. And while there is humour in the novel and the occasional witty observation of prose, do not expect to find the raucous, incisive and charming style of something like True Grit. Indeed, what poignancy Lonesome Dove has to offer can only manifest over a series of several dozen pages, no doubt why it led to such a large page-count. It's story over style, and luckily, it's a pretty great story such that it somehow justified its absurd length and only occasionally did I lament the pedestrian sentences and word-craft (in particular, the word "sad" is insanely abused and overused in this book). That being said, there is some interesting symbolism spread throughout the tale and to be sure, Lonesome Dove seems to touch upon practically every thematic preoccupation of the genre, making it a fine candidate for being a "definitive" Western novel. Even such traditional weaknesses and expected inconsiderations with regards to native Americans and women are afforded more focus and attention (though not entirely redemptive). As a whole, Lonesome Dove is a very good novel in which the reader should not feel intimidated by its extraordinary length; the pages will fly by and hopefully the reader be taken on a wondrous journey with remarkable and tragic characters.
mysterious
reflective
This is one of the more fascinating "ghost" stories that I've read. A blend of the creativity and inventiveness of Jorge Louis Borges' short stories and Juan Ruflo's quiet, expansive and nebulous Pedro Paramo, this short book isn't nearly as sublime as either but presents a fascinatingly explored and original idea in the shape of a recluse fugitive who flees to a mysterious deserted island. The prose is as sharp and self-conscious as the perspective of the main character we inhabit and many times, a fairly predictable sequence of events would later have me discarding observations of plot and ruminating instead on the topics of facsimile, voyeurism and posterity. A short book with the mystery and ambience of a ghost story, coupled with the well-conceived mechanics of more speculative fiction. It probably might have been better as an even shorter story than the novella it ended up being, but it's still a worthwhile read that shouldn't take more than a few days of light reading to enjoy.
I don't usually review nonfiction but I feel this book demands an exception be made. This detailed account of the city of Mosul under ISIS reign seems painstakingly researched, bringing to light firsthand accounts from on the ground that have never before been widely disseminated or seriously considered. The author examines the efficacy and legitimacy of ISIS rule and experiment in state-building through the perspectives of the Mosul locals. Focusing on the police, education and medical services an interesting and well investigated new dimension is revealed on how and why ISIS went about trying to govern such a large city as Mosul over the course of a three years. That being said, this book is written in a style that can only be described as sophomoric and amateurish. I try not to be a stickler for prose or writing style in nonfiction but this book is so astoundingly poorly written: pedantic, uninspiring and hiding its keen journalism and hard-won insights behind sentence after sentence of redundancy and recapitulation. It feels at time as if this was not meant to be a book for public audiences at all, and more like a term paper written by an undergraduate student or else some pedantic internal report for a national security think-tank. Good journalism but atrocious writing.
It's tough to know how to evaluate a book that seems geared towards the 'Young Adult' crowd when I fall outside that demographic. This book takes you into the crowded space of World War II novels to tell the story of a young German girl, Liesel Meminger, as told from the personified character of Death. But the idea of a narrative perspective that might have a drastically different frame of reference with which to contrast the senseless slaughter and violence of an industrialized war, ends up feeling rather undercooked. The Book Thief's Death is somewhat distinguished as a weary overworked labourer collecting souls, but he has far less personality than say, Death as imagined by Terry Pratchett. His one notable hobby as an enthusiast of colours ends up resulting in the same three or four metaphors being used over and over again to describe the skies of Molching, Germany. In the end the narrative voice isn't super strong and ends up diluting more or less into an omniscient third-person.
The main character Liesel is a great character that I'm sure many will become helplessly attached to and invested in; an illiterate girl for whom words are the enemy, which helps frames her entire childhood beset by the Nazi war effort, as that same mobilization of words writ large. Words are tangible, they expel from the mouth, collect on the ground and in arms and dangle and persist. It's a great subtext with which to take a exhaustively examined setting. It culminates in an incredible fictional children's story within the novel called: The Word Shaker. It's a sad, emotional tale that takes a new stab at a well-worn premise.
The main character Liesel is a great character that I'm sure many will become helplessly attached to and invested in; an illiterate girl for whom words are the enemy, which helps frames her entire childhood beset by the Nazi war effort, as that same mobilization of words writ large. Words are tangible, they expel from the mouth, collect on the ground and in arms and dangle and persist. It's a great subtext with which to take a exhaustively examined setting. It culminates in an incredible fictional children's story within the novel called: The Word Shaker. It's a sad, emotional tale that takes a new stab at a well-worn premise.
This book is an incredible feat of imagination, a tribute to fiction and stories and creativity and brevity. The tone you get reading these stories is one of meditative antiquity, even stories whose settings approach identifiably recent time periods sort of "float" in this soup of mysticism and otherworldliness. The range of ideas explored in these stories are super diverse speculations of every variety - historic, metafictional, theological, ontological, there seems to be no limit to what Borges can write about in such an arresting and haunting ambiance. Beneath all this, I think I can identify this theme of "plenary", of grasping or reckoning with every possibility in every exhaustive dimension and order of life, a feeling of great connectivity and isolation and thought-provoking questions on infinity and morality. Another common motif (much more easily recognizable) is the solidity of fiction and imagination; in many of these stories, the protagonist is a writer in whose imagination and those of his colleagues, whole worlds of mystery are born which cannot be contained in their authors' isolated minds. They escape and sculpt reality and perception of the writer and the reader and the power of the word, made as authoritative as god.
I'm sure some of the more influential and popular stories in this collection are known to many: Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius; The Babylon Library; Library of Babel. But I'd also like to mention a few favourites that I think have received less fame: The Circular Ruins; Theme of the Traitor and the Hero; The Secret Miracle; Three Versions of Judas; The South. There were also some stories I didn't love - most of them pseudo-academic analyses on fiction pieces of experimental literature. I'm not sure I entirely understand what Borges was up to in these stories and I would rather have read Borges' own proper version of them, instead of his commentary on their imaginary complements. In any case, there are more than enough gems in this collection to appreciate the breadth of the author's imagination and the dozens of ways he can leave thought-provoking questions lingering in your mind.
I'm sure some of the more influential and popular stories in this collection are known to many: Tlön, Uqbar, Orbis Tertius; The Babylon Library; Library of Babel. But I'd also like to mention a few favourites that I think have received less fame: The Circular Ruins; Theme of the Traitor and the Hero; The Secret Miracle; Three Versions of Judas; The South. There were also some stories I didn't love - most of them pseudo-academic analyses on fiction pieces of experimental literature. I'm not sure I entirely understand what Borges was up to in these stories and I would rather have read Borges' own proper version of them, instead of his commentary on their imaginary complements. In any case, there are more than enough gems in this collection to appreciate the breadth of the author's imagination and the dozens of ways he can leave thought-provoking questions lingering in your mind.
funny
lighthearted
There were many moments while reading this book that I wondered why exactly I was reading it. This is not a memoir in the vein of those world shakers which demand biography or the few fascinating people with incredible personal stories to tell, or even the celebrity who sloppily turns their narcissism towards the written page. This is a memoir about someone you probably don't know, who has accomplished little worth putting in the papers. The book is the memoir of a writer - a writer I am now convinced is one of the finest wordsmiths working today - with all the incredible richness of language, throwing out refined and utterly novel metaphors and turns of phrase with an almost effortless elegance. When it comes to the memoir of someone I don't really know anything about (beyond reading and being deeply impressed with her first fiction novel: No One Is Talking About This), I found that I did not really read this as nonfiction: I did not scrutinize the text for some level of accuracy or truth nor did I really care. Nor did I read it as a piece of fiction. The primary weakness of a book like this is that, especially in the middle portions, it is not super compelling: there is no narrative thrust and I had to force myself somedays to finish a chapter (in other moods I suspect I would never have finished it at all). No, instead I read this book as poetry; and that probably is the mode it must be read in to appreciate it most. There's this sort of breathless beauty and a fantabulous contemporary humour in how Lockwood writes that is just delightful - these take so many forms, not merely some contemplative philosophy or social observation, or political polemic...we see such linguistic brilliance in the weather, in the trees, on the shoreline, sequestered at home, between the stained glass and the cathedral stones, and in underpants and 80s action movies (preferably with submarines).
The book will lead you from one outrageous character or circumstance to the next, each so strange the alarm bells go off that this is a work of imagination where such literary contrivances can only be forgiven in fiction. There is no better example of this than the titular Priestdaddy: the Catholic priest, who by a legitimate process I've never heard of, becomes privileged to speak from the pulpit as an ordained priest while also having a wife and a whole host of weirdo kids - one of which is the author: Patricia Lockwood. What begins as an unbelievable and hilarious caricature of every cliche of that overweight white Republican dad, disdaining all food that doesn't bleed, all news that isn't FOX, becomes somehow a person you truly believe exists. I think the strength of this "autobiography" is that it resists the temptation to arrange one's life's events into some treatise or coherent diorama - it is scattered and varied, episodic and sometimes contradictory, a portrait of a person who exists in a thousand different varieties; like all of us. Certainly her unique insight into the church and its iconography and routines, rituals, lifestyles and priests are a recurring and powerful motif but there is far more going on here (perhaps Priestdaddy was not the best title here).
Those who enjoyed No One Is Talking About This should find just as much to laugh at in this book, both the humour and the narrative tone are incredibly interchangeable. And while the book is definitely a bit longer than it needs to be, it is a book composed of some incredibly crafted sentences and espouses a joy of writing and the power and pleasure of the word, and revels in the presence and present-ness of a strange life and riffs on outrageous injustices and stupidities.
The book will lead you from one outrageous character or circumstance to the next, each so strange the alarm bells go off that this is a work of imagination where such literary contrivances can only be forgiven in fiction. There is no better example of this than the titular Priestdaddy: the Catholic priest, who by a legitimate process I've never heard of, becomes privileged to speak from the pulpit as an ordained priest while also having a wife and a whole host of weirdo kids - one of which is the author: Patricia Lockwood. What begins as an unbelievable and hilarious caricature of every cliche of that overweight white Republican dad, disdaining all food that doesn't bleed, all news that isn't FOX, becomes somehow a person you truly believe exists. I think the strength of this "autobiography" is that it resists the temptation to arrange one's life's events into some treatise or coherent diorama - it is scattered and varied, episodic and sometimes contradictory, a portrait of a person who exists in a thousand different varieties; like all of us. Certainly her unique insight into the church and its iconography and routines, rituals, lifestyles and priests are a recurring and powerful motif but there is far more going on here (perhaps Priestdaddy was not the best title here).
Those who enjoyed No One Is Talking About This should find just as much to laugh at in this book, both the humour and the narrative tone are incredibly interchangeable. And while the book is definitely a bit longer than it needs to be, it is a book composed of some incredibly crafted sentences and espouses a joy of writing and the power and pleasure of the word, and revels in the presence and present-ness of a strange life and riffs on outrageous injustices and stupidities.