chrisssl 's review for:

Priestdaddy by Patricia Lockwood
4.0
funny lighthearted

There were many moments while reading this book that I wondered why exactly I was reading it.  This is not a memoir in the vein of those world shakers which demand biography or the few fascinating people with incredible personal stories to tell, or even the celebrity who sloppily turns their narcissism towards the written page.  This is a memoir about someone you probably don't know, who has accomplished little worth putting in the papers.  The book  is the memoir of a writer - a writer I am now convinced is one of the finest wordsmiths working today - with all the incredible richness of language, throwing out refined and utterly novel metaphors and turns of phrase with an almost effortless elegance.  When it comes to the memoir of someone I don't really know anything about (beyond reading and being deeply impressed with her first fiction novel: No One Is Talking About This), I found that I did not really read this as nonfiction: I did not scrutinize the text for some level of accuracy or truth nor did I really care.  Nor did I read it as a piece of fiction.  The primary weakness of a book like this is that, especially in the middle portions, it is not super compelling: there is no narrative thrust and I had to force myself somedays to finish a chapter (in other moods I suspect I would never have finished it at all).  No, instead I read this book as poetry; and that probably is the mode it must be read in to appreciate it most.  There's this sort of breathless beauty and a fantabulous contemporary humour  in how Lockwood writes that is just delightful - these take so many forms, not merely some contemplative philosophy or social observation, or political polemic...we see such linguistic brilliance in the weather, in the trees, on the shoreline, sequestered at home, between the stained glass and the cathedral stones, and in underpants and 80s action movies (preferably with submarines).

The book will lead you from one outrageous character or circumstance to the next, each so strange the alarm bells go off that this is a work of imagination where such literary contrivances can only be forgiven in fiction.  There is no better example of this than the titular Priestdaddy: the Catholic priest, who by a legitimate process I've never heard of, becomes privileged to speak from the pulpit as an ordained priest while also having a wife and a whole host of weirdo kids - one of which is the author: Patricia Lockwood.  What begins as an unbelievable and hilarious caricature of every cliche of that overweight white Republican dad, disdaining all food that doesn't bleed, all news that isn't FOX, becomes somehow a person you truly believe exists.  I think the strength of this "autobiography" is that it resists the temptation to arrange one's life's events into some treatise or coherent diorama - it is scattered and varied, episodic and sometimes contradictory, a portrait of a person who exists in a thousand different varieties; like all of us.  Certainly her unique insight into the church and its iconography and routines, rituals, lifestyles and priests are a recurring and powerful motif but there is far more going on here (perhaps Priestdaddy was not the best title here).

Those who enjoyed No One Is Talking About This should find just as much to laugh at in this book, both the humour and the narrative tone are incredibly interchangeable.  And while the book is definitely a bit longer than it needs to be, it is a book composed of some incredibly crafted sentences and espouses a joy of writing and the power and pleasure of the word, and revels in the presence and present-ness of a strange life and riffs on outrageous injustices and stupidities.