chrisssl 's review for:

Lonesome Dove by Larry McMurtry
3.5
adventurous fast-paced

Lonesome Dove is a gigantic book full of memorable, relatable characters in a breathtaking setting of the fading frontier.  With my copy coming to nearly 900 pages, this story is anything but brief and takes its time in many dozen episodes exploring the bleak people in a bleak border town; forming bizarre characteristics in a harsh environment.  900 pages will take you from the borders of Mexico to as far north as Canada as we follow a pair of retired Texas Rangers: Augustus McCrae and Woodrow Call seek to drive cattle to the unclaimed frontier of Montana - for reasons which generally escape either man.

It's easy to see why Lonesome Dove is something of a staple in the Western genre.  It is big, epic and very accessible.  It's harsh, dangerous setting offset by moments of cool heroism and determination, the monotony of endless barren plains are routinely interrupted with scenes of incredible and disastrous weather.  Woodrow Call, the laconic leader of this cattle-drive outfit, is a deeply recognizable figure - so much has the "Western" retained some small share of cultural significance in the modern western world that even those, like me, who aren't particularly well read in the genre feel like he's a man we've all come to associate with the frontier.  And yet, he's treated far more deeply than an archetype and has hidden and subtle depths - even if his general countenance evokes any number of Clint Eastwood and John Wayne inspired performances.  Augustus McCrae is a more surprising figure: a pseudo-philosopher, prideful in his literacy and eloquence - his chief lamentation being the lack of an equally vigorous conversation partner so far from civilization.  Through these characters, and many more, we get strong interpersonal dynamics and that ever-present Western dread, in which the race for the frontier is likewise an pyrrhic escape from the encroaching civilization at their heels.

The prose is unremarkable; it is a very easy read, anyone who can read at a highschool level should have no problems at all with this book.  You will not find the jaw-dropping phrases and passages whose words sear into the mind as you would with Blood Meridian.  And while there is humour in the novel and the occasional witty observation of prose, do not expect to find the raucous, incisive and charming style of something like True Grit.   Indeed, what poignancy Lonesome Dove has to offer can only manifest over a series of several dozen pages, no doubt why it led to such a large page-count.  It's story over style, and luckily, it's a pretty great story such that it somehow justified its absurd length and only occasionally did I lament the pedestrian sentences and word-craft (in particular, the word "sad" is insanely abused and overused in this book).  That being said, there is some interesting symbolism spread throughout the tale and to be sure, Lonesome Dove seems to touch upon practically every thematic preoccupation of the genre, making it a fine candidate for being a "definitive" Western novel.  Even such traditional weaknesses and expected inconsiderations with regards to native Americans and women are afforded more focus and attention (though not entirely redemptive).  As a whole, Lonesome Dove is a very good novel in which the reader should not feel intimidated by its extraordinary length; the pages will fly by and hopefully the reader be taken on a wondrous journey with remarkable and tragic characters.