1.5

I don't usually review nonfiction but I feel this book demands an exception be made.  This detailed account of the city of Mosul under ISIS reign seems painstakingly researched, bringing to light firsthand accounts from on the ground that have never before been widely disseminated or seriously considered.  The author examines the efficacy and legitimacy of ISIS rule and experiment in state-building through the perspectives of the Mosul locals.  Focusing on the police, education and medical services an interesting and well investigated new dimension is revealed on how and why ISIS went about trying to govern such a large city as Mosul over the course of a three years.  That being said, this book is written in a style that can only be described as sophomoric and amateurish.  I try not to be a stickler for prose or writing style in nonfiction but this book is so astoundingly poorly written: pedantic, uninspiring and hiding its keen journalism and hard-won insights behind sentence after sentence of redundancy and recapitulation.  It feels at time as if this was not meant to be a book for public audiences at all, and more like a term paper written by an undergraduate student or else some pedantic internal report for a national security think-tank.  Good journalism but atrocious writing.