Take a photo of a barcode or cover
328 reviews by:
birdykinsreads
emotional
mysterious
The first time I started this book I couldn’t get into it, and found myself setting it down, distracted. But, I always intended to come back for it, and I’m so glad I felt like giving it another go right before the end of the year. This time, I was invested from the get.
This is a story about Bodie Kane, a pretty big name in podcasting, who has never quite gotten over the traumas of boarding school—a former roommate Thalia who was murdered, among the other regular teenage humiliations, bullying and assaults. When she agrees to a two-week seminar at her alma mater teaching a group of current students about producing a podcast of their own, she can almost convince herself it’s not her influence that has one of them looking into the questions surrounding Thalia’s death and the man who went away for the crime. But, before she can help it, she’s deep down the rabbit hole—her mental health plummeting as she fixates on the crime, and who she believes is responsible for it.
Rebecca Makkai takes her time gathering the evidence and crafting these characters—I know some might have found this slow and (gasp) boring—but I was so invested in everyone, both present and past. She seamlessly winds several stories of abuse of authority, believing women, and the creative ways we deal with trauma while slowly unspooling this central mystery in such a deft, engaging and realistic way. I love how calculated Bodie was, how she acted in exactly the ways that I would have done. I loved how her narration really walked the tightrope of unreliable and unhinged as she becomes more and more obsessive and willing to do anything to expose what she believes to be the truth.
I also found the many side characters endearing, in the background this is also a story of finding yourself, becoming the person you’re meant to be and the important friendships you make along the way. Makkai is such a talented writer, one thing I particularly liked was how she would refer to new stories people discuss in the scenes as “the one where...” and then list so many possibilities of what might have happened to so many different women and I found it really emotional, the way these details blur into each other and often, desensitize us to the real people beneath the headlines. It was a powerful way to make her point.
If like me, you haven’t picked this up yet... or you abandoned it... take this is as your sign to give it another chance. You should go into this knowing it’s more of a literary fiction mystery than a thriller. Under the right circumstances, this book absolutely shines.
This is a story about Bodie Kane, a pretty big name in podcasting, who has never quite gotten over the traumas of boarding school—a former roommate Thalia who was murdered, among the other regular teenage humiliations, bullying and assaults. When she agrees to a two-week seminar at her alma mater teaching a group of current students about producing a podcast of their own, she can almost convince herself it’s not her influence that has one of them looking into the questions surrounding Thalia’s death and the man who went away for the crime. But, before she can help it, she’s deep down the rabbit hole—her mental health plummeting as she fixates on the crime, and who she believes is responsible for it.
Rebecca Makkai takes her time gathering the evidence and crafting these characters—I know some might have found this slow and (gasp) boring—but I was so invested in everyone, both present and past. She seamlessly winds several stories of abuse of authority, believing women, and the creative ways we deal with trauma while slowly unspooling this central mystery in such a deft, engaging and realistic way. I love how calculated Bodie was, how she acted in exactly the ways that I would have done. I loved how her narration really walked the tightrope of unreliable and unhinged as she becomes more and more obsessive and willing to do anything to expose what she believes to be the truth.
I also found the many side characters endearing, in the background this is also a story of finding yourself, becoming the person you’re meant to be and the important friendships you make along the way. Makkai is such a talented writer, one thing I particularly liked was how she would refer to new stories people discuss in the scenes as “the one where...” and then list so many possibilities of what might have happened to so many different women and I found it really emotional, the way these details blur into each other and often, desensitize us to the real people beneath the headlines. It was a powerful way to make her point.
If like me, you haven’t picked this up yet... or you abandoned it... take this is as your sign to give it another chance. You should go into this knowing it’s more of a literary fiction mystery than a thriller. Under the right circumstances, this book absolutely shines.
challenging
dark
mysterious
tense
Tender by Beth Hetland is an incredibly creepy and stomach-churning graphic novel about a woman whose desperate need to have the “perfect life” turns truly horrifying as things don’t go to plan. Hetland crafts a masterful sense of unease as she slowly reveals the extent of the psychological terror simmering under the surface of Carolanne—who, like so many of us, just wants to keep up with the life milestones of her closest friends.
When she suffers a terrible loss she resorts to exerting control over the only thing she can—herself, her own body. As Carolanne’s mental health unravels, so too does Hetland’s art style. And the effect is perfectly rendered. It’s gruesome, it’s sad, and it’s not for a reader averse to body-horror, that’s for sure. What an accomplishment, though. I was freaked out and when I finished it—I was totally stunned.
For fans of horror, psychological thrillers, and that special feeling of ending a book wondering WTF did I just read? This would be one you might want to check the trigger warnings for before you dive in.
Thanks so much to @netgalley and @fantagraphics for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
Tender by Beth Hetland is out March 12, 2024.
When she suffers a terrible loss she resorts to exerting control over the only thing she can—herself, her own body. As Carolanne’s mental health unravels, so too does Hetland’s art style. And the effect is perfectly rendered. It’s gruesome, it’s sad, and it’s not for a reader averse to body-horror, that’s for sure. What an accomplishment, though. I was freaked out and when I finished it—I was totally stunned.
For fans of horror, psychological thrillers, and that special feeling of ending a book wondering WTF did I just read? This would be one you might want to check the trigger warnings for before you dive in.
Thanks so much to @netgalley and @fantagraphics for the eARC in exchange for my honest review.
Tender by Beth Hetland is out March 12, 2024.
“What I have never had the courage to say is / in our culture / a boy is a blessing from god / while a girl is considered a tragedy / you are congratulated for having a son / and consoled for / a daughter” (10)
I think these poems are raw and feeling, but also a bit clunky, juvenile and heavy-handed. I liked the idea of pairing different parts of the book with certain teas... While this is clearly a compelling life story worth telling, the poetry itself was not for me. I only truly liked one poem in the whole collection—I’m just not sure this poetry collection is saying anything new or speaking to me in any particular way. Hopefully it finds its audience, as I am definitely not it.
I think these poems are raw and feeling, but also a bit clunky, juvenile and heavy-handed. I liked the idea of pairing different parts of the book with certain teas... While this is clearly a compelling life story worth telling, the poetry itself was not for me. I only truly liked one poem in the whole collection—I’m just not sure this poetry collection is saying anything new or speaking to me in any particular way. Hopefully it finds its audience, as I am definitely not it.
I’ve always loved Roxane Gay’s writing—she has such an eloquent and passionate way of presenting her opinion pieces. Usually, if I’m looking for a take on current events or pop culture, hers is the one I’m most interested to read.
In Opinions Gay collects a selection of political, literary and pop culture criticism and celebrity interviews. I enjoyed listening to this audiobook narrated by the author—I did find a lot of the political articles repetitive, but I think that’s for good reason—to illustrate not only how often the lives of Black people have been disregarded, murdered, used for performative activism/allyship—but also, for Gay, how often she’s been asked to speak on and be a voice at the nexus of media and a movement. Even as nothing changes. Again and again. How absolutely exhausting and traumatizing that has been for her. And how she keeps on.
Her literary, movie, and pop culture criticism has always been some of my favourite to read. She has a brilliant mind and persuasive opinions. Honestly, I find everything she writes interesting, even when I have no idea who the person she’s talking about is. I think this is a great collection to familiarize yourself with her writing. For me, I recognized a lot of what was in here already. I left this book feeling the heaviness of it, and completely understanding why she’s far more selective now about the things she’s willing to write about and spend her time on now. I still haven’t read any of the books of her new imprint at Grove Atlantic that came out this year, but I definitely plan to.
In Opinions Gay collects a selection of political, literary and pop culture criticism and celebrity interviews. I enjoyed listening to this audiobook narrated by the author—I did find a lot of the political articles repetitive, but I think that’s for good reason—to illustrate not only how often the lives of Black people have been disregarded, murdered, used for performative activism/allyship—but also, for Gay, how often she’s been asked to speak on and be a voice at the nexus of media and a movement. Even as nothing changes. Again and again. How absolutely exhausting and traumatizing that has been for her. And how she keeps on.
Her literary, movie, and pop culture criticism has always been some of my favourite to read. She has a brilliant mind and persuasive opinions. Honestly, I find everything she writes interesting, even when I have no idea who the person she’s talking about is. I think this is a great collection to familiarize yourself with her writing. For me, I recognized a lot of what was in here already. I left this book feeling the heaviness of it, and completely understanding why she’s far more selective now about the things she’s willing to write about and spend her time on now. I still haven’t read any of the books of her new imprint at Grove Atlantic that came out this year, but I definitely plan to.
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Complicated
An environmental-horror, Green Fuse Burning is a novella that plays with the ideas of art, creativity and our connection to the natural world through an indigenous perspective. Set in a near future, climate change has warmed the earth to the point Mi’kmaq elders are considering changing the names they have for seasons as they’re connected to physical changes in weather and occurrences in the natural world that just don’t happen predictably anymore.
Our main character Rita is struggling with the death of her father, and her connection to her culture without him—a painter, she’s stuck in a creative lull when her sort of toxic on-again off-again girlfriend forges her name on a grant and signs her up for a remote residency to shake her out of her grief. Girl, dump her.
Sequestered in a rural cottage next to a strange pond, Rita is visited by fevered dreams and strange impulses but it unlocks something in her. Combing through her own memories and experiences, and incorporating mixed-media from the changed land, she begins a collection that might be her best yet—if it doesn’t kill her first.
An unnerving, visceral, dream-like story—it’s hard to know what’s real and what’s not—but, one thing is clear, the earth is changing… the animals are evolving… and something odd and preternatural is stirring in the depths of the murk.
Tiffany Morris really unnerved me with this novella, it was weird and inventive, which I always enjoy. I love reading new indigenous writers, she’s local to me which is awesome, and I’m excited to read whatever she writes next. Indigenous weirdness and horror is my forever favourite.
Our main character Rita is struggling with the death of her father, and her connection to her culture without him—a painter, she’s stuck in a creative lull when her sort of toxic on-again off-again girlfriend forges her name on a grant and signs her up for a remote residency to shake her out of her grief. Girl, dump her.
Sequestered in a rural cottage next to a strange pond, Rita is visited by fevered dreams and strange impulses but it unlocks something in her. Combing through her own memories and experiences, and incorporating mixed-media from the changed land, she begins a collection that might be her best yet—if it doesn’t kill her first.
An unnerving, visceral, dream-like story—it’s hard to know what’s real and what’s not—but, one thing is clear, the earth is changing… the animals are evolving… and something odd and preternatural is stirring in the depths of the murk.
Tiffany Morris really unnerved me with this novella, it was weird and inventive, which I always enjoy. I love reading new indigenous writers, she’s local to me which is awesome, and I’m excited to read whatever she writes next. Indigenous weirdness and horror is my forever favourite.
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
How did I almost forget to summarize bookclub?! She’s slipping!
The Unmaking of June Farrow by Adrienne Young was my bookclub pick. We’d read a few heavy ones in a row and I wanted something a bit lighter, a bit more magical. The time travel was bonus.
It’s about June Farrow, a woman who has just lost her grandmother to a mysterious dementia-like illness that all the women in her family get. She’s afraid it might be happening to her too when she starts to experience things that aren’t there, and then a door appears. Suddenly, a whole lot of family secrets start to come to light. There’s romance, a murder mystery and a fun little twist on time travel.
I think (let’s pull this memory from my goldfish brain now), that the majority of us liked this one—but, we had some real issues with the mechanics of the time travel, motivation and timeline once we started discussing it. This is definitely one of those books that you have to just accept things as they are and not ask too many questions. I really enjoyed the characters of June and the women in her family, but I don’t think they were as fleshed out as they could have been. I also don’t necessarily think the romance had me believing it was worth abandoning your entire ass timeline for. It was a fun idea—time travel causing madness, minds bridging history, a door that just appears—to where? To when! I loved the setting of the flower farm, I wish we got more of it. Shout out to my friend Martina who wrote out the whole timeline so we could understand what actually happened lol get you a type A for your bookclub discussions, they bring a little extra *spice*.
Once again, my pick—the one I wait ALL YEAR to choose—probably won’t be my fave. That’s just how she goes, I guess.
The Unmaking of June Farrow by Adrienne Young was my bookclub pick. We’d read a few heavy ones in a row and I wanted something a bit lighter, a bit more magical. The time travel was bonus.
It’s about June Farrow, a woman who has just lost her grandmother to a mysterious dementia-like illness that all the women in her family get. She’s afraid it might be happening to her too when she starts to experience things that aren’t there, and then a door appears. Suddenly, a whole lot of family secrets start to come to light. There’s romance, a murder mystery and a fun little twist on time travel.
I think (let’s pull this memory from my goldfish brain now), that the majority of us liked this one—but, we had some real issues with the mechanics of the time travel, motivation and timeline once we started discussing it. This is definitely one of those books that you have to just accept things as they are and not ask too many questions. I really enjoyed the characters of June and the women in her family, but I don’t think they were as fleshed out as they could have been. I also don’t necessarily think the romance had me believing it was worth abandoning your entire ass timeline for. It was a fun idea—time travel causing madness, minds bridging history, a door that just appears—to where? To when! I loved the setting of the flower farm, I wish we got more of it. Shout out to my friend Martina who wrote out the whole timeline so we could understand what actually happened lol get you a type A for your bookclub discussions, they bring a little extra *spice*.
Once again, my pick—the one I wait ALL YEAR to choose—probably won’t be my fave. That’s just how she goes, I guess.
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
I’m pretty vocal about my dislike for Bunny—I thought the premise was solid but the narrative voice annoyed me to no end. So, I surprised myself by buying the hardcover of her new book immediately but dark fairytales are my siren’s call, I simply can’t resist.
Rouge is that dark horse.
I’m so drawn to and curious about Mona Awad’s mind—her imagination is beautiful, she has such fascinating ideas that she executes in such fun and unnerving ways. The woman takes risks, and I support it.
Awad sets her Snow White-inspired tale in the world of wellness, or rather it’s deep deep underbelly. I love all of the unexpected twists and flourishes she uses here—the man in the mirror, the skincare and YouTube fixations, the mother-daughter relationship that is part protection, part envy, and all toxic. The spa is depicted with just the right amount of creepiness, it definitely kept me guessing. I’m still guessing a bit, to be honest! I thought bouncing back and forth between the present and past was a lovely way to unlock the mystery of what happened to her mother, and what happened to their relationship. There was also a little side-story romance that I really really loved. Unexpectedly endearing.
But, what I loved most about this book was the way Awad plays with language, slips of the tongue, and coherence to illustrate the effects Belle’s “treatments” are having on her. I can’t really describe it, but when you read it you’ll see what I mean, and it was just so cleverly done.
I really enjoyed this one—I suppose my only issues were it felt a bit repetitive at times and as a whole I was left with too many unanswered questions for this to be a five star read for me.
Weird, unnerving, and devoted to the theme. It took me awhile to get into, but when I did I was hooked. I’m glad I gave it a chance.
Rouge is that dark horse.
I’m so drawn to and curious about Mona Awad’s mind—her imagination is beautiful, she has such fascinating ideas that she executes in such fun and unnerving ways. The woman takes risks, and I support it.
Awad sets her Snow White-inspired tale in the world of wellness, or rather it’s deep deep underbelly. I love all of the unexpected twists and flourishes she uses here—the man in the mirror, the skincare and YouTube fixations, the mother-daughter relationship that is part protection, part envy, and all toxic. The spa is depicted with just the right amount of creepiness, it definitely kept me guessing. I’m still guessing a bit, to be honest! I thought bouncing back and forth between the present and past was a lovely way to unlock the mystery of what happened to her mother, and what happened to their relationship. There was also a little side-story romance that I really really loved. Unexpectedly endearing.
But, what I loved most about this book was the way Awad plays with language, slips of the tongue, and coherence to illustrate the effects Belle’s “treatments” are having on her. I can’t really describe it, but when you read it you’ll see what I mean, and it was just so cleverly done.
I really enjoyed this one—I suppose my only issues were it felt a bit repetitive at times and as a whole I was left with too many unanswered questions for this to be a five star read for me.
Weird, unnerving, and devoted to the theme. It took me awhile to get into, but when I did I was hooked. I’m glad I gave it a chance.
challenging
Maybe something was lost in translation. Maybe the words madcap, bizarre and absurd aren’t actually buzzwords that I vibe with, though I thought they were. Maybe the problem is me. Those are all possibilities. But, there’s also the possibility that this was the most nonsensical, irritating, experiment of form and structure that I’ve ever forced myself to get through. I listened to it on audiobook and that was probably my first mistake. Finishing it at all was my next one.
I got actively angry listening to this. Because, what? Why? Huh? And now I feel like I was bamboozled when this showed up in my “you might like this” because you read Fruiting Bodies section on Everand/Scribd. The audacity! How dare they put this in the same category! Please fire whoever populated that. If it’s an algorithm fire the algorithm.
These are 25 short (sometimes very short) stories that honestly, I don’t even know how to describe. I didn’t know what the heck she was talking about half the time. There were unreliable narrators but to the max, there were criticisms of the stories themselves interspersed between them. It felt like stream of consciousness but if you were sitting next to someone tripping balls on the bus, insisting on telling you about their current fever dream. It felt like someone asked AI to write a book of short stories and have fun with it. Could I follow it? No. Did I listen to the whole thing periodically asking myself WTF am I reading? Yes. Could I recommend this to anyone? Absolutely not.
I’m sure there’s an audience for this book out there. I just don’t know who it is. And to be perfectly honest, I don’t want to know them. We are not friends. You can’t sit with me. Just kidding, if you DO ever read this PLEASE get in touch and explain to me what in the heck this even is. Because I couldn’t, can’t, won’t. This is probably going to be the worst book I read this year, maybe all decade. And I’m not sorry. (I’m a little sorry). ’twas just not for me.
I got actively angry listening to this. Because, what? Why? Huh? And now I feel like I was bamboozled when this showed up in my “you might like this” because you read Fruiting Bodies section on Everand/Scribd. The audacity! How dare they put this in the same category! Please fire whoever populated that. If it’s an algorithm fire the algorithm.
These are 25 short (sometimes very short) stories that honestly, I don’t even know how to describe. I didn’t know what the heck she was talking about half the time. There were unreliable narrators but to the max, there were criticisms of the stories themselves interspersed between them. It felt like stream of consciousness but if you were sitting next to someone tripping balls on the bus, insisting on telling you about their current fever dream. It felt like someone asked AI to write a book of short stories and have fun with it. Could I follow it? No. Did I listen to the whole thing periodically asking myself WTF am I reading? Yes. Could I recommend this to anyone? Absolutely not.
I’m sure there’s an audience for this book out there. I just don’t know who it is. And to be perfectly honest, I don’t want to know them. We are not friends. You can’t sit with me. Just kidding, if you DO ever read this PLEASE get in touch and explain to me what in the heck this even is. Because I couldn’t, can’t, won’t. This is probably going to be the worst book I read this year, maybe all decade. And I’m not sorry. (I’m a little sorry). ’twas just not for me.
This was an impulse buy, the premise hooked me—a feminist journalist finds her fiance’s name on an anonymously-populated list of abusers in the industry weeks before their wedding.
What should she do next? How do you possibly handle something like this when the accusations you would normally be supporting and believing are now about the person you love most, the person you think you know…
Doesn’t that sound so good? Unfortunately the execution let me down a little bit. I still really enjoyed this read, I liked and felt for the characters. I think it’s a really interesting situation to unpack—how to balance believing women with the way accusations/rumours online can completely lose control even when they might be unfounded. If cancel culture and maybe taking down the wrongly-accused are simply necessary risks in the eyes of online/social justice? To what extent should you stand by your partner?
I feel like Yomi Adegoke used some overly convenient plot devices to allow her characters to avoid really answering these questions, and in doing so sort of bobs and weaves her away around the very premise she sets up. The end-book twist was truly meh for me, I think leaving it more ambiguous here would have worked better. I found that a little disappointing but, in the end, that’s really how life is sometimes, huh?
Still worth reading for sure. And I liked her writing style, I’ll be curious to see what she writes next.
What should she do next? How do you possibly handle something like this when the accusations you would normally be supporting and believing are now about the person you love most, the person you think you know…
Doesn’t that sound so good? Unfortunately the execution let me down a little bit. I still really enjoyed this read, I liked and felt for the characters. I think it’s a really interesting situation to unpack—how to balance believing women with the way accusations/rumours online can completely lose control even when they might be unfounded. If cancel culture and maybe taking down the wrongly-accused are simply necessary risks in the eyes of online/social justice? To what extent should you stand by your partner?
I feel like Yomi Adegoke used some overly convenient plot devices to allow her characters to avoid really answering these questions, and in doing so sort of bobs and weaves her away around the very premise she sets up. The end-book twist was truly meh for me, I think leaving it more ambiguous here would have worked better. I found that a little disappointing but, in the end, that’s really how life is sometimes, huh?
Still worth reading for sure. And I liked her writing style, I’ll be curious to see what she writes next.
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
Every story in this collection felt so fully-formed and immersive, as I was reading I wished they were each novels in and of themselves.
There was something uncanny, disturbing, and beautifully off-putting in each of them. The writing was sparkling with gems I wanted to underline and save but I was listening on audiobook, so I couldn’t. The narration, was so calming and wonderfully done. I’m planning to get the physical copy of this one and reread it because I loved it that much.
My favourite stories were the titular Fruiting Bodies—about a woman and her wife who develops a condition where mushrooms grow all over her body. They live in the woods mostly isolated when an ominous injured male hiker stumbles upon them and makes himself at home. This story, like lots of the others, had a dark fairytale quality to it, which I absolutely loved.
There was a story about two ex-girlfriends road tripping and reminiscing on their situationship amongst the climate crisis that felt so bittersweet and prescient.
There was one about a scholar’s obsession with her favourite author that scratched my literary theory and criticism itch and somehow my celebrity conspiracy theory loving one too.
There was an incredibly creepy one I listened to on a late night drive home about two cousins who become convinced a new baby to their family is a changeling. That one made me think I was seeing things on the side of the road 😳.
There was an AMAZING one about an anthropologist who finds an entrance under a hill to a gambling house for the fae. She somehow learns to play a card game in which the bets get steadily more dangerous and unnerving but she can’t resist. Then she gets entangled in the lives of other human players clearly in over their heads. This story was so original and perfect! I was so sad when it ended.
I’m really in my short story era, I’ve been enjoying them more than ever, and this one really hit me in all my favourite places. Beautiful, weird, creepy, inventive. I’ll read anything Kathryn Harlan wants to write next.
There was something uncanny, disturbing, and beautifully off-putting in each of them. The writing was sparkling with gems I wanted to underline and save but I was listening on audiobook, so I couldn’t. The narration, was so calming and wonderfully done. I’m planning to get the physical copy of this one and reread it because I loved it that much.
My favourite stories were the titular Fruiting Bodies—about a woman and her wife who develops a condition where mushrooms grow all over her body. They live in the woods mostly isolated when an ominous injured male hiker stumbles upon them and makes himself at home. This story, like lots of the others, had a dark fairytale quality to it, which I absolutely loved.
There was a story about two ex-girlfriends road tripping and reminiscing on their situationship amongst the climate crisis that felt so bittersweet and prescient.
There was one about a scholar’s obsession with her favourite author that scratched my literary theory and criticism itch and somehow my celebrity conspiracy theory loving one too.
There was an incredibly creepy one I listened to on a late night drive home about two cousins who become convinced a new baby to their family is a changeling. That one made me think I was seeing things on the side of the road 😳.
There was an AMAZING one about an anthropologist who finds an entrance under a hill to a gambling house for the fae. She somehow learns to play a card game in which the bets get steadily more dangerous and unnerving but she can’t resist. Then she gets entangled in the lives of other human players clearly in over their heads. This story was so original and perfect! I was so sad when it ended.
I’m really in my short story era, I’ve been enjoying them more than ever, and this one really hit me in all my favourite places. Beautiful, weird, creepy, inventive. I’ll read anything Kathryn Harlan wants to write next.