birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

What Will People Say: Poems by Taniya Gupta
2.0

“What I have never had the courage to say is / in our culture / a boy is a blessing from god / while a girl is considered a tragedy / you are congratulated for having a son / and consoled for / a daughter” (10)

I think these poems are raw and feeling, but also a bit clunky, juvenile and heavy-handed. I liked the idea of pairing different parts of the book with certain teas... While this is clearly a compelling life story worth telling, the poetry itself was not for me. I only truly liked one poem in the whole collection—I’m just not sure this poetry collection is saying anything new or speaking to me in any particular way. Hopefully it finds its audience, as I am definitely not it.