328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
slow-paced

This book left me with a bad taste in my mouth. I want to just make gagging noises but I’ll try to be more diplomatic and eloquent than that. 

For a book that purports to be about reclaiming victims’ narratives and undercutting the power and admiration feeding “The Defendant” through media and true crime fascination it’s still, above all, marketing itself on the fame of Ted Bundy and profiting from it. It’s feeding into that same frenzy, purposefully, and is probably going to make a lot of money from it too. Not naming him, but making it clear who it’s meant to be, and making fun of him/revealing him for the incel he is, isn’t enough to cancel that out. So, it was kinda gross to have the main POV go on and on about the ethics of this, knowing the author is doing the same damn thing. 

Bright Young Women is about Pamela, a sorority sister that witnesses the man responsible for horrific assaults and murders leave her house—a key witness in the case, she attempts to find justice despite a bumbling police force. It’s also told through the POV of Ruth, a woman who becomes a victim of his as well—and her wife Tina who tirelessly searches for answers. 

It should have been easy, in a story like this, to make me feel, and keep me turning pages. But I found this just incredibly boring. I thought I would love this book but I hated it. I found the characters so hollow, so tedious, and I kept plodding along thinking something might make it worth it for over 370 pages?! It was painful, to pick this book up, I so badly wanted to DNF but I knew I had to review this—I’ve only seen good reviews so far—and I can’t write a negative review unless I suffer through the whole thing.

The writing was good, that’s the crazy thing. But everything else was not. I don’t know what Jessica Knoll was trying to do with this novel and honestly it feels like her publishing team didn’t care either, they knew it would sell. 

This might end up being my least favourite read of the year, which is wild.

If you loved this book I’m sorry, don’t hate me. 😂
challenging

I decided to read this when I was in the mood to be ✨devastated✨ and it worked. A heartbreaking account of Alisson Wood’s abusive relationship with her high school teacher. It’s exactly what you probably imagine it to be—My Dark Vanessa but painfully real.

What surprised me about this book was how much time was spent interrogating her experience actually reading the book Lolita over the years and how her view of it changed over time, now as a literature professor she teaches it herself. I really loved that part of it—how a book comes into your life at a certain time and how you grow and change with it, sometimes seeing it in a whole new light. I love that she ended up realizing how her teacher mishandled that book from the jump, seeing in it only what he wanted to. Not only was he a gross predator but also, in the end a shitty teacher too, completely misreading the text for his own means.

Anyway, a difficult and engaging memoir that I read in one day. Made me want to reread Lolita for myself and see how my perceptions of it have changed.
adventurous funny lighthearted fast-paced

This one was just so FUN. Completely propulsive couldn’t put it down for a second, read every chance I could until I was done—fun, fun, fun. 

My bestie @ashleythimot_art had been on me for over a year to give this one a chance, and I’m so glad she wouldn’t let it go because she was so right. I listened to half on audio—A+++ narration—and then finished it on physical because my ears hurt from listening on my earbuds non-stop. 

I’d seen the movie and thought I’d liked it but after reading this and then trying to rewatch it I realized it was a TRAVESTY and completely offensive swamptrash I mean how DARE they butcher such awesome source material in such a manner??? Why just why???

Ready Player One is about a kid that attempts to solve a mystery in order to inherit a game publishing mega fortune and control the world’s first online immersive universe where anything is possible. It’s full of 80s pop culture references and old school gaming lore, the plot is simple but addictive and the world building is just top notch. I loved the quest-like action and the comedic-relief friendships. Yes, if you look too closely there are some overly convenient plot bits and there’s definitely something to be interrogated about gamer culture and male gatekeeping and the romantic side story was shall we say a bit stalkery it’s true, but honestly I’m willing to overlook all that because it was a ride and I was fully strapped in dying to get to the end. 

Highly recommend for all the millennial gamers who love nostalgia porn.
emotional hopeful reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: Yes

I really loved this quiet slice-of-life rumination on one woman’s relationship with her mother and how it’s evolving as they age, the comfort we find in each other’s bodies, and how much we might relive or fixate on the past when what we really need is to move forward. 

Kathleen Cheng has just been dumped by the man she thought she would marry and abandoned her phD program when she moves home to live with her mom who’s about to remarry. Lost and grieving the life she thought she’d lead she’s thrown back into an unfulfilling dynamic with her distant and critical mother just as she too is beginning a new chapter. Scrambling she takes a job at a company called Midas Touch as a professional cuddler and weirdly finds herself finding new meaning in her life and her interactions with an older client. 

Not a lot happens in this book, but I found the writing so lovely and crisp. Jenny Xie’s observations on love, life and how we interact felt spot on and meaningful. I love reading about women feeling lost in their life (WOMEN VS THE VOID) and struggling to give it new meaning or find their path forward and I think this one was done beautifully and elegantly. The way Kathleen has to get to know a new version of her mother, happier now, while revisiting her memories of the messy alcoholic she used to be and how helpless that made her feel was really thoughtful and engaging. 

I thought more would happen in this book but it turns out I didn’t need it to, I was happy to live alongside these characters for awhile and watch their relationship evolve and hopefully reach a turning point. 

Everything about this book was working for me. I definitely recommend for lovers of quiet literary fiction who love a good mother-daughter dynamic.

Also, I just adore this cover. Maybe one of my faves of the year. So calming.
adventurous funny lighthearted medium-paced

This one just really took me by surprise! I’d read Legends & Lattes last month and was not the biggest fan. I thought it was cute, but lacking, kinda boring and didn’t really believe in the love story. I requested this audio ARC before I finished that first book and realized I wasn’t a fan and I’m glad I did because I might have passed on it and missed this magic! Travis Baldree really spun it out for this prequel and won me over.

Bookshops & Bonedust has our main girl Viv stuck in the town Murk while recovering from an injury in a hunt gone wrong for a powerful necromancer. There she finds and befriends a foul-mouthed ratty Fern (HILARIOUSLY bad mouthed, loved her) and becomes invested in fixing up her struggling bookshop with her while also reading her adventurous and spicy 🌶️ 😂 novel recommendations. While there a romance with a neighbouring baker and retired mercenary blooms which has her thinking about what she wants from her own life. FORESHADOWING. But, when a creepy stranger appears she’s pulled back into a dark and dangerous mystery that threatens everything around her, and her own abilities and desire to protect her friends. 

So everything that was charming about Legends & Lattes was here but mixed with a better setting (in my opinion—bookstore over cafe any day), funnier more endearing characters with better inner lives, and a not SUPER high stakes plot but high ENOUGH that it was interesting and mysterious, never boring. Add to that a more believable romance, though it still had some issues for me, and a great narration, this prequel just did for me what everyone was hyping L&L for but didn’t deliver. I really loved it. So much fun.

And I’m still saying someone better make a video game based on these books because I want to PLAAAAAAAY!!!

Thanks so much to @macmillan.audio and @netgalley for the audio arc in exchange for my honest review.
dark mysterious medium-paced

Of strange houses and the haunted people who can’t escape them—Starling House is a meld of folklore, mythology, and the dark children’s stories that have come before. There’s always a nugget of truth at the bottom, and some magic too.

Opal is our plucky rebellious heroine, and she’s been having weird dreams about the gothic mansion in the centre of her town Eden, Kentucky. Always struggling to provide for herself and her little brother after losing her mom in a car accident (was it an accident?) she lies, cons and steals when she has to. Living at a local motel she can’t help but be drawn to Starling House, despite its dark rumours and legends. The heirs that come and go, never interacting with the town. It’s the house built by E. Starling the author of a deeply strange children’s book The Underland with a cult following. When she’s offered an unexpected job at Starling House, of course she has to take it, and see where this path that’s been tugging at her for years leads. But, can she untangle the secrets of the house and her own life before something truly evil is unleashed?

This book started out a bit juvenile feeling to me, but as I sunk into it, I was completely drawn in. I loved the mix of storytelling Alix E Harrow uses to uncover the secrets of the house—told from different sources—and I love how it all came together in the end. I thought this was going to be a book about a haunted house but the reality of it is so much better than that—nicely crafted and pulling from so many different wells of inspiration but converging just right. 

There’s a bit of a funny love story at its heart, found family and stories told and retold and the power in the reclaiming of it. The elements of magical fantasy in this are just the right amount of unnerving grounded in something possible, adhering to mythological stories and possibilities. 

And this house. I loved the house. 

I think this is a great story that can pull you in if you let it. With something terrible and rotting waiting to claw it’s way to the light. Well-narrated, dark, kinda funny, creepy, an adventure that goes deeper and deeper in the best way—down down down into the dark.
mysterious

The Fake is a darkly comedic train wreck you can’t look away from as charismatic and love-bombing Cammie makes her way into the lives of post-divorce Gibson and grieving widow Shelby. Struggling with a cancer diagnosis and the deaths of two people close to her and leaving an abusive relationship—Cammie is just so deliciously saveable. Soon she’s living in their houses, eating their food, making herself at home. But when Shelby and Gibson finally meet, things with Cammie start to unravel. Is she who she seems? But no one would lie about something so serious, right?!

The book is told through Gibson and Shelby’s POV and only the first and last chapters are given to Cammie. What a character! She’s so fascinating! And as it seems to be in a lot of books like this I can’t seem to help rooting for her 😂 yes, I do want the con artists to thrive and live to con another day. 

This was so interesting to me, because there’s talk about who is actually using who and the significance of lies if you begin to believe them yourself. I just love Zoe Whittall’s writing style, this is a short book and it just flies by. 

I got to see Whittall talk about the book at @afterwordsliterary and she revealed this is actually based on her own experiences 17 years ago of being lied to in a relationship about a cancer diagnosis. Knowing that definitely also added to my reading experience. 

SPOILER: She also talked about the ending—in a way purposefully disappointing for some readers—for me, I liked it. She wanted it to let her readers down, their sense of justice, because that’s how it goes in the real world. People like Cammie don’t have to own up or pay for their transgressions, they just move on to the next one.

I’m curious to pick up some of her backlist as well. I know The Spectacular is supposed to be great.

Highly recommend this one for fans of unreliable narrators, con artists and lying liars. 👌🏽
challenging emotional slow-paced

Bookclub tackled A Council of Dolls by Mona Susan Power, and I think most of us really liked it, even if some of us felt abiding to the structure surrounding the dolls and their role in the story sometimes did it a narrative disservice. 

A Council of Dolls is a beautiful generational story of the Dakota girls in one family lineage and the dolls they had as children that helped them make sense of the trauma in their world and weather its storms. We begin with Sissy in the 1960s who with the help of her doll Ethel is coping with the unpredictable and abusive nature of her charismatic mother, we then meet her mother Lily as a girl in the 1930s and begin to understand her, from there we go to Cora in the 1890s during the “Indian Wars,” the murder of Sitting Bull and her subsequent education. 

The idea of telling this story through the experiences of the girls and their dolls is so clever, and I love how ambiguous it is—are the dolls magical or are they the product of imaginative and necessary comfort? Mona Susan Power is a beautiful writer, the first story was based on a short story she wrote and it is profound, immersive and compelling. For me, each girl’s story was emotional, touching and interesting but the end kind of summing it all up through the eyes of the dolls themselves I didn’t particularly enjoy. Though that end was the favourite part of at least one other bookclub member.

All in all, a great start to our new bookclub season and I’ll definitely be picking up some of Power’s backlist. 
slow-paced

This book felt like it was marketed as a thriller but I was not thrilled. 

Prom Mom is about Amber Glass, a girl who gives birth in a hotel room at a prom and the baby dies. She can’t remember what happened, her date—popular guy Joe she had been secretly sleeping with and convinced to take her—never checked on her. It of course, ruins and derails her entire life, not his. We hear the story flipping in between her teenage experience and where she is now—a gallery owner specializing in art made by inmates—and Joe’s life cheating on his perfect wife. 

When Amber moves home and rekindles a connection with Joe amidst the pandemic everything starts to unravel. 

I enjoyed reading this book but I felt like I was waiting for a mystery and twist that would make sense to the story but it never came. Instead there was a twist at the end that felt completely out of left field and frankly, kinda dumb. The ending was NOT IT. 

I would not call this a thriller. It was a drama and an interesting one, I often heard these prom mom/dumpster baby stories when I was a teen and I think it was clever to follow a woman’s story from there. I liked Amber, I liked her story. I think this book focused too much on Joe and his wife and then the ending really just was not in keeping with the rest of the book. 

Also, I think for the subject matter, if you’re going to invoke dead babies you should probably do it really well and with a certain amount of care or else… wtf are you even doing?! This book felt like ultimately it used it as a plot device and that kinda grossed me out.

This is my second Laura Lippman book, I also read The Lady in the Lake, and they both started out well and then fumbled the ball leaving me disappointed. Not sure I’ll seek out any more. 
slow-paced

I’m honestly just not sure what the point of this was? It was fine but also low-key not worth the time?

The Three of Us is told in three parts, each the POV from a wife, her husband, and her best friend. They all remain unnamed (which always kind of irks me) and a story of toxicity and co-dependency play out over one evening as if on a stage. I’m not a fan of reading plays and weirdly that’s what this felt like to me despite the dialogue being without much punctuation and hard to follow. 

The back cover sells this as an explosive night that reveals deep secrets but really, there was nothing too juicy or unexpected. It felt anticlimactic to get to the end and be like oh ok that’s it? And unfortunately I didn’t feel anything for any of these characters, I found them all pretty dull and unpleasant. I didn’t have anyone to care about and so it felt more like watching a messy drama from the table over at a restaurant only not as entertaining.

I was looking forward to reading this one but I wish I’d skipped it. But, it’s short, so it has that going for it.