birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

I Have Some Questions for You by Rebecca Makkai
5.0
emotional mysterious

The first time I started this book I couldn’t get into it, and found myself setting it down, distracted. But, I always intended to come back for it, and I’m so glad I felt like giving it another go right before the end of the year. This time, I was invested from the get.
This is a story about Bodie Kane, a pretty big name in podcasting, who has never quite gotten over the traumas of boarding school—a former roommate Thalia who was murdered, among the other regular teenage humiliations, bullying and assaults. When she agrees to a two-week seminar at her alma mater teaching a group of current students about producing a podcast of their own, she can almost convince herself it’s not her influence that has one of them looking into the questions surrounding Thalia’s death and the man who went away for the crime. But, before she can help it, she’s deep down the rabbit hole—her mental health plummeting as she fixates on the crime, and who she believes is responsible for it.
Rebecca Makkai takes her time gathering the evidence and crafting these characters—I know some might have found this slow and (gasp) boring—but I was so invested in everyone, both present and past. She seamlessly winds several stories of abuse of authority, believing women, and the creative ways we deal with trauma while slowly unspooling this central mystery in such a deft, engaging and realistic way. I love how calculated Bodie was, how she acted in exactly the ways that I would have done. I loved how her narration really walked the tightrope of unreliable and unhinged as she becomes more and more obsessive and willing to do anything to expose what she believes to be the truth.
I also found the many side characters endearing, in the background this is also a story of finding yourself, becoming the person you’re meant to be and the important friendships you make along the way. Makkai is such a talented writer, one thing I particularly liked was how she would refer to new stories people discuss in the scenes as “the one where...” and then list so many possibilities of what might have happened to so many different women and I found it really emotional, the way these details blur into each other and often, desensitize us to the real people beneath the headlines. It was a powerful way to make her point.
If like me, you haven’t picked this up yet... or you abandoned it... take this is as your sign to give it another chance. You should go into this knowing it’s more of a literary fiction mystery than a thriller. Under the right circumstances, this book absolutely shines.