birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

The List by Yomi Adegoke
3.0

This was an impulse buy, the premise hooked me—a feminist journalist finds her fiance’s name on an anonymously-populated list of abusers in the industry weeks before their wedding.

What should she do next? How do you possibly handle something like this when the accusations you would normally be supporting and believing are now about the person you love most, the person you think you know…

Doesn’t that sound so good? Unfortunately the execution let me down a little bit. I still really enjoyed this read, I liked and felt for the characters. I think it’s a really interesting situation to unpack—how to balance believing women with the way accusations/rumours online can completely lose control even when they might be unfounded. If cancel culture and maybe taking down the wrongly-accused are simply necessary risks in the eyes of online/social justice? To what extent should you stand by your partner?

I feel like Yomi Adegoke used some overly convenient plot devices to allow her characters to avoid really answering these questions, and in doing so sort of bobs and weaves her away around the very premise she sets up. The end-book twist was truly meh for me, I think leaving it more ambiguous here would have worked better. I found that a little disappointing but, in the end, that’s really how life is sometimes, huh?

Still worth reading for sure. And I liked her writing style, I’ll be curious to see what she writes next.