328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
slow-paced

So many people I know (and usually have similar taste to) really enjoyed this book… or at least rated it highly. I hated it. I found this short book so incredibly hard to get through. For me, it was painfully boring. And in the face of that slog, sometimes beautiful writing can save a book, but there was none of that here. The writing was blunt and unadorned. 

The narrator was a bland blank slate of a person only named Child. Child grows up in a bunker prison and due to a completely lucky set of circumstances she and the other female prisoners manage to escape. She had the horribly infuriating habit of answering any type of narrative mystery immediately and bluntly. Ie: we found many bunkers, no one was ever alive. Ok great, so glad that’s cleared up and then we spend the rest of the book going from bunker to bunker regardless. BORING. She’s with 39 other women, surely there could be some interest there, right? No she mentions in blandly BLAND passing that they took up with each other and sometimes had dramas. Wow. Somehow the complete mediocrity of this life is perfectly represented in the narrative because I too just wanted her to kill me in the end so it could be over. End my suffering, please.

This is the worst kind of dystopian novel because it focuses only on the tedious absurdity of a situation and leaves out anything curious or interesting. Are we on another planet? Probably but who cares it’s just endless fields of nothing much like this book’s plot. Why are the people being kept prisoner? Who knows it’s only considered in passing and then abandoned and we never find out which is fine because who cares. Nothing is at stake here. But then they have to survive, survival tales can be interesting right? No not really when anything they need is provided by endless bunkers and the land and seasons are giving *nothing*. My kingdom for interaction with an element of any kind.

Every few pages (there are almost no breaks in the text) I sighed audibly and complained about how much I hated this book to the empty house. I am so glad it’s over. 
challenging informative mysterious tense medium-paced

An absolutely riveting story inspired by the life of 18th-century midwife Martha Ballard and the heinous sexual assaults committed on a friend of hers, whom she was the only witness to, by virtue of recording the details in her diary, something completely unheard of for a woman of the time. 

Ariel Lawhon takes some liberties in order to craft a spellbinding narrative over six months, and in doing so, creates a possible and completely plausible version of Martha who I came to absolutely adore. She’s steadfast, strong, intelligent and just can’t help but search for justice in a time when so little of it seemed in a woman’s reach. The men she loves are the type of men we hope to surround ourselves with, and her particularly grating feud with a new idiot-doctor is just so well done, you have to laugh to stop from crying. For being an almost forgotten historical figure, she was so damn relatable.

This is a beautifully written and heartbreaking mystery that I could not put down. My only problem with the novel was the (likely completely historically accurate) disgusting racism towards the Wabanaki depicted by some of the terrible people in the book—it feels like a crutch to me to make your villains (and only your villains) racist, I don’t ever want to read it. And I thought it was strange that considering how vital to the plot it seemed to be (and possibly a complete fabrication to the details of the case) that Lawhon didn’t address her choices to include that in her afterword in the same way she discusses and defends her use of a Black character with no name and Ballard’s likely relationships with her Black neighbours. It felt like a strange oversight. And it’s tiring how so often racism against indigenous people just doesn’t seem to rate an explanation. I’m not saying she was wrong for writing her story this way, I’m just wondering if it was necessary, and I’d have liked to hear her discuss it in the afterward as well. 

This is what I want to know when a white writer sprinkles some racism into their book: why and for what reason? What is it adding? Could you achieve the same result plot and story-wise without it? Explain yourself.

Despite that very personal reaction, and reason why I didn’t give it 5 stars, I still was completely entranced by this book. And would recommend it. Especially the audiobook which was narrated so excellently by Jane Oppenheimer in a very Meryl-esque way. She was completely captivating. 


I’m such a Britney fan, her debut album was one of the first CDs I ever bought. I definitely was just as rabid as anyone else in the early aughts for information about her and her life, she’s always just been so compelling as a person. 

Her memoir is definitely well worth the read—it does sound like her voice, and I’m glad I didn’t do the audiobook for that reason. She’s been through so much  and at times it feels like she’s very careful about what she’s saying and the times she’s willing to talk about. Which is fair, but by the end of the book (read it in one day!) I’m not sure I know her any better. She’s still really such an enigma. I do think maybe I understand her a bit better and why she might be retiring from the industry—but I’m also not entirely convinced she’s free of her family’s influence in her life. I do worry we’re not seeing her because she’s still under their thumb, not because she has total control over her life, but I hope I’m wrong about that. I hope she can find good people who want the best for her to surround herself with, but something tells me that will never be the case. 

I wasn’t going to review this one, because so many people already have, but I think it’s really funny that right now as Justin Timberlake attempts a comeback with his new single Selfish that Britney fans are all like NOT ON OUR WATCH—and are buying and streaming HER song Selfish that came out like 2017. She’s now topped him on the charts and I think that’s just beautiful chef’s kiss.

This was a fine memoir, but it definitely left me wanting more, and I think maybe if she had given it some time it could have been a better book. Feels a bit rushed. 

Anyway go stream Britney Spears- Selfish!
challenging slow-paced

Some of these poems were excellent and cut to the heart of me, but so many more made my eyes glaze over. Not exactly what I’m looking for in a poetry collection, but objectively a very impressive use of language.
challenging mysterious

When I tell you I am flabbergasted by how much I ended up enjoying this book…because if it weren’t for Bookclub I would have DNFed this SO QUICK. The first 30-40 pages for me were giving 1 star nonsense. I had to reread so much and it still felt like eVeRyThInG wAs WrItTeN lIkE ThIs and it was not computing. I made my husband read the first page and he looked at me like 🤔 this is supposed to be fun?! 🧐🤨 

Piranesi is about a man trapped in a strange labyrinth-like never-ending stone mansion. It’s told through journal entries by a calendar system invented by him. He’s clearly not totally sure what’s going on himself, but he has a routine. He also has his own name for everything thus the intense amount of Proper Nouns per page. It is confusing as hell to get into. I had to just channel Elsa and let it go, LET IT GOOOO, stop trying to understand, and most vitally, stop reading the journal entry titles and dates, just skim right past them for my mental health. Then things started to work for me.

Once you get into it—paddling past that big wave of confusion—you get plunged into a big mystery. Piranesi has one friend (friend?) a man called The Other who he sees at set days and times and encourages his continued research into the depths of the house. Meanwhile Piranesi is just trying to survive in this half flooded house full of birds, sea life and endless strange statues. Making everything he can think of out of seaweed. He’s been keeping these journals for as long as he can remember and suddenly things get weird. Weirder. There’s things he doesn’t remember writing with context he simply can’t comprehend. Ie anything indicating a world outside the house. Then new people begin to show up and things get wilder and wilder.

I thought this was such an ambitious and interesting novel and if you have the patience to let it grow on you it really does deliver such a fascinating mystery about innocence and knowledge, mental health, what makes a life, free will and what’s worth sacrificing for science and truth. 

I would have enjoyed this so much more if it had not been written as a journal. Bookclub was torn, just as many 1-2 stars as 4s. So she’s polarizing!
emotional funny

An excellent book of weird, funny and sometimes deeply touching poetry that features a selection of the anti-heroes, wizards and crones, nemeses and beautiful leading people that pepper our everyday palaces, dungeons and other settings in the theatre of our lives. These poems are easy to read and accessible, super vivid and relatable. They have punchy observations that stick with you and might cause you to reevaluate the people you see everywhere in the run of a day but otherwise might overlook.

Hana Shafi also features some of her artwork which is of the odd melty-face variety, lending the whole package a sense of bright vivacity and charm. 

I thoroughly enjoyed this collection, it’s exactly the type of poetry I gravitate to and love. I likely will reread this one over the years and would recommend to anyone looking for some evocative poetry or attempting to get into reading poetry for the first time. These ones are attention grabbing and fun, a good place to start your journey to poetry lover.

Thanks to @zgreads and @bookhugpress for the review copy in exchange for my honest review.
dark mysterious tense fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix

What an unexpected thrill ride! Rabbit Hole by Kate Brody is a well-written, completely addictive read. Maybe it’s because I am also prone to falling into internet rabbit holes, but this book hooked me immediately and wouldn’t let me go.

Teddy Angstrom has just lost her father to suicide and is living at home to help her mother cope when she discovers that her dad had been working on solving her long lost sister’s missing persons case. She gets sucked into the Reddit shaped-hole he’s left behind and in the process befriends Mickey, a younger female amateur sleuth. 

From there her life falls into disarray as she takes a scary-believable hard right into the morally-grey fog and totally loses her grip. Her friendship with Mickey turns obsessively toxic and the things she’s willing to do to unravel the mystery surrounding her family veers into something dark and dangerous.

This is such a great debut, full of darkness, lots of twists and turns, and a relatably messy train-wreck of a main character I couldn’t help but find insatiably entertaining.

Looking forward to reading whatever else she comes up with!

Thanks to @soho_press for the gifted copy.