birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

I Who Have Never Known Men by Jacqueline Harpman
2.0
slow-paced

So many people I know (and usually have similar taste to) really enjoyed this book… or at least rated it highly. I hated it. I found this short book so incredibly hard to get through. For me, it was painfully boring. And in the face of that slog, sometimes beautiful writing can save a book, but there was none of that here. The writing was blunt and unadorned. 

The narrator was a bland blank slate of a person only named Child. Child grows up in a bunker prison and due to a completely lucky set of circumstances she and the other female prisoners manage to escape. She had the horribly infuriating habit of answering any type of narrative mystery immediately and bluntly. Ie: we found many bunkers, no one was ever alive. Ok great, so glad that’s cleared up and then we spend the rest of the book going from bunker to bunker regardless. BORING. She’s with 39 other women, surely there could be some interest there, right? No she mentions in blandly BLAND passing that they took up with each other and sometimes had dramas. Wow. Somehow the complete mediocrity of this life is perfectly represented in the narrative because I too just wanted her to kill me in the end so it could be over. End my suffering, please.

This is the worst kind of dystopian novel because it focuses only on the tedious absurdity of a situation and leaves out anything curious or interesting. Are we on another planet? Probably but who cares it’s just endless fields of nothing much like this book’s plot. Why are the people being kept prisoner? Who knows it’s only considered in passing and then abandoned and we never find out which is fine because who cares. Nothing is at stake here. But then they have to survive, survival tales can be interesting right? No not really when anything they need is provided by endless bunkers and the land and seasons are giving *nothing*. My kingdom for interaction with an element of any kind.

Every few pages (there are almost no breaks in the text) I sighed audibly and complained about how much I hated this book to the empty house. I am so glad it’s over.