328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
challenging dark emotional

I’d heard nothing but good things about this one all last year, but I was not prepared for how much I would love it. This is a perfect book. There is absolutely nothing I could change or improve about it—the lessons in empathy, compassion, mercy and guilt? Flawless. The way every character in this novel was fully-formed and real, grappling with life and self? Beautiful. This book was so artfully done. Masterful. 

We meet Ansel Packer as he’s awaiting execution on death row. Interspersed with his limited conditions in prison, his desire to be known and remembered, and his plans to escape, are chapters we spend with the women in his life—his mother, his sister in law, the detective who has him in her sights—and we come to know his story more intimately than I thought possible. The way the lives of these women and Ansel’s life and fate weave and intersect is so phenomenally, inevitably done and the end of this book is maybe the most powerful, evocative and heartrending ending I’ve ever read in a book. When I tell you I was WEEPING.

This is officially on my favourite books of all time list, and for another year in a row—the last book I read, finished on New Year’s Eve, was one of the best of the year. (In 2022 it was Our Wives Under the Sea finished right before midnight.)

I think this book will haunt me for a long time, as it should. I’m so glad I finally took the time to read it
adventurous dark mysterious medium-paced

What a great fantasy debut from French-Canadian author Pascale Lacelle—Curious Tides has such an inventive and interesting magic system tied to the moon cycle and the tides. In this world, you can only use the type of magic you’re born into during the right part of the lunar cycle, unless you happen to be Eclipse-born in which case you have to live in fear of being consumed by your immense power available at any time and in that case—locked away at a government facility and stripped of your magic for safety. 

At Aldryn College, school for magic, Emory has always lived in the shadow of her best friend until she goes missing in a horrible drowning accident deep in the caves by the school. When lost students begin to wash up on the shore Emory is pulled into a strange mystery, a secret society, and will stop at nothing to try and uncover what happened to her friend, and understand the weird stuff that’s now happening to her, and her magic, too.

Part dark academia, part mystery, part political conspiracy and intrigue, and a whole lot of fun magic—Curious Tides is one of the best fantasy debuts I’ve read in ages. I loved the characters, the book is told through dual POVs: Emory is tenacious and curious, coming into her own. Her friend’s brother Baz is one of the rare Eclipse-born who can alter time but lives in constant rigid fear of losing control. There’s a whole host of other supporting characters that I grew attached to and the mystery at the heart of the book is familiar and still new enough to keep me guessing. My only criticism was that it did drag a bit at times, but I kept going and it was fully worth it.

I’ll definitely be reading the next in the series and sincerely hope this finds its audience and gets the hype it deserves.

informative sad

A really informative and emotional graphic novel about Métis history in Canada. A young girl, Echo, realizes she can travel back in time to experience first-hand the struggles of her ancestors as she learns the currently-taught history at her new school. 

Sad and important knowledge that I didn’t have previously, I don’t remember being taught much about it when I was in school. This was a quick and powerful read, that maybe leaned too heavily into teaching history at times, sacrificing the storytelling aspects for it a bit. But, still very emotional and engaging. Mentions of Cree-led resistance and Montana particularly resonated with me as that’s where my family is from. 

This would be a great read for middle-grade and high school students learning about indigenous history from an indigenous source in school and anyone else who wants to know more about the many horrors and skeletons lurking in Canada’s historical closet. I’m glad I read it, and I’m interested now to learn even more.

Thank you so much @prtgandmain @highwaterpress for sending me this review copy in exchange for my honest opinion.I’m 
slow-paced

The writing style for this one was a bit too brusque for me, I didn’t like the dialogue in it, it felt unnatural. The premise—a woman searching for the daughter that was adopted out without her knowledge and becoming the nanny for her family—felt just too convenient and predictable? The way the timeline was set up in the book felt like the worst way it could have been organized. I kept thinking it would get better and have a satisfying twist, but that never came. Instead there was a ridiculous ending. The idea that this beautiful woman with a banging body who twilights as a waitress at a strip club could be unrecognized as such because she wears frumpy sweaters and lets the hair fall over her face felt very She’s All That let me take your glasses off so you can be hot vibes. Just silly. All around I was not a fan of this one or any of the characters. Just a bit of a let down since I was looking forward to reading it.

Because I don't know what you mean and what you don't

Josie Long

DID NOT FINISH: 16%

Not keeping my interest, boring stories. Not funny considering it’s written by a comedian.
challenging emotional reflective

A woman inherits her grandmother’s house and in it, haunted by her grandmother and the way they left their relationship before she died, she uncovers her family’s sad history. A quick sad read. Very engaging style, one of my fave graphic novels of the year.
adventurous lighthearted medium-paced

What if when Hansel & Gretel escaped the witch’s gingerbread grasp, they took something with them? What if, adults now, the only thing between them and abject poverty is the treats they make with the help of a little… magic… but this isn’t a fairytale, people who use magic can get burned at the stake and sometimes, pushing an old lady into a fire doesn’t make you a hero, it makes you a murderer.

Gosh, I just loved this dark retelling of that classic fairytale. Greta is a great character, I loved how Kell Woods saw her life splayed out, and how the business with the witch was only the beginning of her story. And how childhood trauma like that can effect people so differently. Learning about the different types of magic in her world and unraveling the mystery of who these children really were, why they ended up in those woods, was an adventure. 

This was just excellent fantasy—the characters were so endearing and jumped off the page, and listening to it on audio was such a treat, the narration really brought everything to life and highlighted the quiet humour in the conversations and Greta’s witty thoughts. I feel like I would enjoy rereading this one, and I don’t do that super often.

One of my favourite fantasy books of 2023, I hope she continues retelling these somewhat overlooked fairytales and keeps them in the same overarching world. This would make such a fun movie, too. Thinking about this book, it just brings a smile to my face, I think of it so fondly.

Thanks so much to @netgalley and @macmillan.audio for the audiobook in exchange for my honest review

I used to love Jennifer Weiner’s books back in my 20s, they were some of my favourite romcoms. As a reader, I’ve definitely evolved since then, and expect a bit more out of my romcoms these days. I think I was just surprised that it didn’t feel like Weiner has evolved as a writer the same way I have as a reader. 

The Breakaway is about a self-hating plus-size girlie dealing with a toxic history with her weight-obsessed mother (fat camp) and her now super fit formerly also overweight boyfriend. She feels like he’s the one for her until she meets a charismatic stud, has a one night stand that sticks with her. Years later she’s leading a bike tour that he so happens to be on. Sparks fly. Lives are reevaluated.

What bothered me most about this book was how our MC’s worth felt so tied up with her weight. It was a very early 2000s kind of POV to have. She’s constantly wondering why anyone would be attracted to her or find her worthy which was just depressing and sad. I’d like her weight to be one part of her but it felt like her whole personality. Very Good in Bed and Jemima J of her. And then we have the men. Bland and blander? And we’re just over here leaning all the way into adultery and rooting for it? I mean ok I guess. I’d just have wanted more of a reason for it. There’s a time and place when a cheating plot line makes sense (The Paper Palace for instance…) but here I just didn’t get it. 

As a whole this just wasn’t connecting with me. It was fine. The side character stories of the other people on the tour were also fine but felt like she had a quota of plot points she was trying to hit through them—teenage pregnancy scare, senior swingers, mom daughter reconnection… none of it was really adding all that much to the story and as a whole I cared very little for these characters and will probably promptly forget it. I read this quickly and can see why other people like it. I didn’t HATE it. For me, I think maybe I’ve just outgrown Weiner’s books and that’s ok too.

Read any disappointingly fine books lately?

#bookreview #bookreviewer #thebreakawa