birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

The Frozen River by Ariel Lawhon
4.0
challenging informative mysterious tense medium-paced

An absolutely riveting story inspired by the life of 18th-century midwife Martha Ballard and the heinous sexual assaults committed on a friend of hers, whom she was the only witness to, by virtue of recording the details in her diary, something completely unheard of for a woman of the time. 

Ariel Lawhon takes some liberties in order to craft a spellbinding narrative over six months, and in doing so, creates a possible and completely plausible version of Martha who I came to absolutely adore. She’s steadfast, strong, intelligent and just can’t help but search for justice in a time when so little of it seemed in a woman’s reach. The men she loves are the type of men we hope to surround ourselves with, and her particularly grating feud with a new idiot-doctor is just so well done, you have to laugh to stop from crying. For being an almost forgotten historical figure, she was so damn relatable.

This is a beautifully written and heartbreaking mystery that I could not put down. My only problem with the novel was the (likely completely historically accurate) disgusting racism towards the Wabanaki depicted by some of the terrible people in the book—it feels like a crutch to me to make your villains (and only your villains) racist, I don’t ever want to read it. And I thought it was strange that considering how vital to the plot it seemed to be (and possibly a complete fabrication to the details of the case) that Lawhon didn’t address her choices to include that in her afterword in the same way she discusses and defends her use of a Black character with no name and Ballard’s likely relationships with her Black neighbours. It felt like a strange oversight. And it’s tiring how so often racism against indigenous people just doesn’t seem to rate an explanation. I’m not saying she was wrong for writing her story this way, I’m just wondering if it was necessary, and I’d have liked to hear her discuss it in the afterward as well. 

This is what I want to know when a white writer sprinkles some racism into their book: why and for what reason? What is it adding? Could you achieve the same result plot and story-wise without it? Explain yourself.

Despite that very personal reaction, and reason why I didn’t give it 5 stars, I still was completely entranced by this book. And would recommend it. Especially the audiobook which was narrated so excellently by Jane Oppenheimer in a very Meryl-esque way. She was completely captivating.