birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Piranesi by Susanna Clarke
4.0
challenging mysterious

When I tell you I am flabbergasted by how much I ended up enjoying this book…because if it weren’t for Bookclub I would have DNFed this SO QUICK. The first 30-40 pages for me were giving 1 star nonsense. I had to reread so much and it still felt like eVeRyThInG wAs WrItTeN lIkE ThIs and it was not computing. I made my husband read the first page and he looked at me like 🤔 this is supposed to be fun?! 🧐🤨 

Piranesi is about a man trapped in a strange labyrinth-like never-ending stone mansion. It’s told through journal entries by a calendar system invented by him. He’s clearly not totally sure what’s going on himself, but he has a routine. He also has his own name for everything thus the intense amount of Proper Nouns per page. It is confusing as hell to get into. I had to just channel Elsa and let it go, LET IT GOOOO, stop trying to understand, and most vitally, stop reading the journal entry titles and dates, just skim right past them for my mental health. Then things started to work for me.

Once you get into it—paddling past that big wave of confusion—you get plunged into a big mystery. Piranesi has one friend (friend?) a man called The Other who he sees at set days and times and encourages his continued research into the depths of the house. Meanwhile Piranesi is just trying to survive in this half flooded house full of birds, sea life and endless strange statues. Making everything he can think of out of seaweed. He’s been keeping these journals for as long as he can remember and suddenly things get weird. Weirder. There’s things he doesn’t remember writing with context he simply can’t comprehend. Ie anything indicating a world outside the house. Then new people begin to show up and things get wilder and wilder.

I thought this was such an ambitious and interesting novel and if you have the patience to let it grow on you it really does deliver such a fascinating mystery about innocence and knowledge, mental health, what makes a life, free will and what’s worth sacrificing for science and truth. 

I would have enjoyed this so much more if it had not been written as a journal. Bookclub was torn, just as many 1-2 stars as 4s. So she’s polarizing!