710 reviews by:

kaylaramoutar

Filter

Just some quick thoughts-

1. I really enjoyed this. I wish that it had more world-building because what we did get was super interesting and I would've liked to know more about the North/South, the curse, the university, etc.

2. I saw some reviews that said they were annoyed that Lynet's romance wasn't the forefront of the novel and I have to disagree with them. I know it's a YA and we always expect there to be romance but I think it was smart of Bashardoust to keep Lynet’s romance with Nadia low-key. Lynet was barely 16 which is, yes, old enough to have a romance especially in a novel, but she was a lot ~younger. Nadia was semi-right when she said she wouldn't be able to survive outside of the wall. She didn't know anything and I think giving her this epic romance would've done a disservice to her character and to the Real Love Story of the novel. Also Nadia was 17 (Lynet 15 when they met) and I think anything more than the few kisses they shared (not really a spoiler but sorry if it was lol) wouldn't be the best choice.

3. The Real Love Story was between Lynet and Mina and it was GREAT!!!!! I loved that Bashardoust made them both make massive mistakes and had them seem villain-esq to each other. It showed the complexity that female relationships can have, especially between a mother and daughter. I really enjoyed their relationship.

4. Every man in this novel sucked but it didn't take away from the novel itself. How fun!

5. Just quickly jumping back to point 2 - we Need more lgbt* YA fantasy and we need it now. This wasn't a bad attempt - especially because like I said the real love story was between Lynet and Mina - but I want a massive lgbt romance in YA fantasy. (Let me know if you have any recs!!)

I really liked the idea of this novel but felt that it fell short of the mark.

Too many characters were introduced in the first few pages and their relation to each other which made it too much to handle all at once. There were a lot of POVs which I felt detracted from the story a bit. Personally I like one POV, but I will admit that a good novel can incorporate a few and have it work. If it works, it works - and this didn't. I figured out the surprise/twist pretty early on, it felt quite obvious to me, and because of that felt the reveal was pretty lackluster.

I didn't really feel connected to any of the characters. I think this was mostly because of the multiple POVs (like, 9 of them? 10? Too many!!!) but maybe also the depth of writing wasn't... deep?

I know I've complained about fantasy novels always having to be series but sometimes it's needed. I think An Unkindness of Magicians would be benefited from being a duology. The backstories could have been fleshed out and the characters could've had their time to shine.

3.5

The Wedding Date was hard to rate and it'll be hard to review. For the most part: I liked it. It was enjoyable and enough of a page turner that I finished it in a day. It'll seem like I had a lot of issues with it but I think that's just because the potential was Huge and it just.. didn't hit the mark.

The writing felt juvenile, which was a shock and truly unfortunate to encounter. It was such a good plot idea and they're adults and there are sexy scenes but the writing made a lot of feel very young. This was mostly found in the dialogue. It was mechanical which made it juvenile and disappointing. I also found that the way both Alexa and Drew reacted to things was, again, juvenile. They're both older - I don't know if they ever specify an age but Alexa is a lawyer and the chief of staff for a mayor, and Drew is a pediatric surgeon. So they're not young. But the way they acted was so young.

I also didn't love the multiple POVs. There was conflict towards them, but because we were in both of their heads there wasn't any conflict for us. I knew how they felt about each other and instead of making me root for them, it just annoyed me that they wouldn't communicate. I think staying just in Alexa's POV would have been a better choice.

Quickly: we get it. She's not happy with her "curvy" body. You don't need to mention her jiggling stomach every time. I know it was there to show how insecure she was about her body but after the fifth time it felt like the author was reminding us that "if you have a jiggly stomach you too can get laid!".. I don't know. It felt weird to me. Also the amount of times her skin colour is mentioned within the first couple chapters seemed to be too much for me. I absolutely LOVED a romance between a mixed couple - I say this as a non-white-passing child of mixed parents - but the focus on her skin (at the beginning) was too much.

The ending was very abrupt and ended like a fanfiction - VERY quick conflict resolution, happiness, ending. And then a two page epilogue
marriage proposal
. I could see it coming from a mile away and it still irked me.

That all being said: I still enjoyed it and recommend it if you're looking for a new library book.

Somewhere between 3.5 and 4. If there were no issues with this novel I probably would have rated it a 4.5, but the issues dragged the rating down. I think it might "technically" be a 3.5, but I enjoyed it more than that, so... not really sure what to rate it.

The issues I had with The Immortalists weren't so severe that it made me want to stop reading. There were some instances of characters doing ooc (out of character) things and that, while slightly annoying, wasn't a deal breaker for me. There were some sexual phrases/comments, outside of anything actually sexual, which I found unnecessary.

I liked the Gold children to an extent, but I think that was part of the magic. I don't think we were supposed to like all four of them all the time. My favourite section was Varya's; I think she was written really well and her section tied up the story nicely.

I recommend this novel, and am excited to see what else Benjamin writes!

LOVED this. I've been looking for more lgbt stories that aren't 1) depressing as hell or 2) the standard coming of age story. I really just want to read different types of stories, you know? That's why I liked The Mermaid's Daughter. It was a different type of story with an lgbt protagonist.

I really loved all the magical realism found in the stories. Magical Realism is usually one of my favourite genres and I was so excited that so many of the stories (the majority if I can recall correctly) featured them.

Here are my favourite stories from All Out.

Every Shade of Red - Elliot Wake (ROBIN HOOD RETELLING. SO GOOD.)
The Sweet Trade - Natalie C. Parker
The Coven - Kate Scelsa (witch-lore in the 20s in Paris? Sign me up.)
The Girl with the Blue Lantern - Tess Sharpe

I wished a lot of these stories were full novels because I am Greedy.

I have A LOT of feelings about Born a Crime and I don't think I can put them into words. I crave books about mixed children. Fiction, non-fiction, whatever. I look for them everywhere and they're so hard to find. I'm not mixed in the way same Noah is, but everything he said about being a mixed person resonated with me.

Here are two of my favourite quotes.

1. "My mom raised me as if there were no limitations on where I could go or what I could do. When I look back I realize she raised me as a white kid -- not white culturally, but in the sense of believing that the world was my oyster, that I should speak up for myself, that my ideas and thoughts and decisions mattered."

Me too, Trevor.

2. "The history of coloured [mixed] people in South Africa is, in this respect, worse than the history of black people in South Africa. For all that black people have suffered, they know who they are. Coloured people don't."

I felt my breath whoosh out of me when I read that. I've never really felt like I belonged no matter where I looked. I was "too white" for brown people and "too brown" for white people. This, of course, was all decided due to what I liked to do. What my hobbies were/are. What music I listened to. How I spoke. It was unreal - the way that I could feel out of place with people I was supposed to "belong" with. I was too white for some brown girls in high school - they weren't friendly to me because I wasn't Muslim - but I was too brown for the old white man in the train station who berated me, unprompted, for being "a Muslim". I couldn't win in high school and I couldn't win a few years ago. I still can't.

I read that Born a Crime is being turned into a movie starring Lupita Nyong'o as Noah's mother. This is SUPER exciting because 1) I'm so happy more people will be able to learn more about South Africa, 2) we get to watch Nyong'o act because the girl can act, and 3) more people might be able to understand the issues mixed people go through all over the world. (Yes, Noah's situation was worse than most because of apartheid but the point still stands.)

Anyway. Please read this book. Thanks.

3.5

This was a fun, charming book, but nothing new or special. I realize this book came out in 2015 and it is currently 2017, but nothing in it was fresh. Don't get me wrong - I enjoyed it! I really did. I devoured it. I just felt like it lacked something. Maybe if I had read this back in 2015 when it came out I'd have a different opinion, but I just found it slightly overrated. I still recommend it.

The best thing about this book is how diverse it is. And it wasn't diverse to be diverse, it just was, and I really appreciated that. There were some characters I liked - Simon, Abby, Simon's sisters - and some characters that I found unlikable or not-real-enough - Leah, Nick, Martin. If Martin was truly a good guy he wouldn't have done what he did, no ifs ands or buts. "People make mistakes" - okay, sure, true. His mistake is blackmailing Simon. But what he did later in the novel is unforgivable. Nick was bland to me, so so bland that it was shocking so many girls liked him. And Leah.... girl. Take a BREATH. I really didn't like her and found her cringe-worthy and almost a caricature of a real person.

I am really excited to see the movie though. I think I'll like it more than the novel! The first teaser poster was unveiled today on National Coming Out Day, and it looks good.

EDIT: the movie was SO good. I really like how Leah was written in it. Most of the issues I had with the book was “fixed”(/changed?) in the movie which I loved. Movie 5/5 (something I have said v rarely in my life)