Take a photo of a barcode or cover
kaylaramoutar 's review for:
An Unkindness of Magicians
by Kat Howard
I really liked the idea of this novel but felt that it fell short of the mark.
Too many characters were introduced in the first few pages and their relation to each other which made it too much to handle all at once. There were a lot of POVs which I felt detracted from the story a bit. Personally I like one POV, but I will admit that a good novel can incorporate a few and have it work. If it works, it works - and this didn't. I figured out the surprise/twist pretty early on, it felt quite obvious to me, and because of that felt the reveal was pretty lackluster.
I didn't really feel connected to any of the characters. I think this was mostly because of the multiple POVs (like, 9 of them? 10? Too many!!!) but maybe also the depth of writing wasn't... deep?
I know I've complained about fantasy novels always having to be series but sometimes it's needed. I think An Unkindness of Magicians would be benefited from being a duology. The backstories could have been fleshed out and the characters could've had their time to shine.
Too many characters were introduced in the first few pages and their relation to each other which made it too much to handle all at once. There were a lot of POVs which I felt detracted from the story a bit. Personally I like one POV, but I will admit that a good novel can incorporate a few and have it work. If it works, it works - and this didn't. I figured out the surprise/twist pretty early on, it felt quite obvious to me, and because of that felt the reveal was pretty lackluster.
I didn't really feel connected to any of the characters. I think this was mostly because of the multiple POVs (like, 9 of them? 10? Too many!!!) but maybe also the depth of writing wasn't... deep?
I know I've complained about fantasy novels always having to be series but sometimes it's needed. I think An Unkindness of Magicians would be benefited from being a duology. The backstories could have been fleshed out and the characters could've had their time to shine.