kaylaramoutar's profile picture

kaylaramoutar 's review for:

Girls Made of Snow and Glass by Melissa Bashardoust
4.0

Just some quick thoughts-

1. I really enjoyed this. I wish that it had more world-building because what we did get was super interesting and I would've liked to know more about the North/South, the curse, the university, etc.

2. I saw some reviews that said they were annoyed that Lynet's romance wasn't the forefront of the novel and I have to disagree with them. I know it's a YA and we always expect there to be romance but I think it was smart of Bashardoust to keep Lynet’s romance with Nadia low-key. Lynet was barely 16 which is, yes, old enough to have a romance especially in a novel, but she was a lot ~younger. Nadia was semi-right when she said she wouldn't be able to survive outside of the wall. She didn't know anything and I think giving her this epic romance would've done a disservice to her character and to the Real Love Story of the novel. Also Nadia was 17 (Lynet 15 when they met) and I think anything more than the few kisses they shared (not really a spoiler but sorry if it was lol) wouldn't be the best choice.

3. The Real Love Story was between Lynet and Mina and it was GREAT!!!!! I loved that Bashardoust made them both make massive mistakes and had them seem villain-esq to each other. It showed the complexity that female relationships can have, especially between a mother and daughter. I really enjoyed their relationship.

4. Every man in this novel sucked but it didn't take away from the novel itself. How fun!

5. Just quickly jumping back to point 2 - we Need more lgbt* YA fantasy and we need it now. This wasn't a bad attempt - especially because like I said the real love story was between Lynet and Mina - but I want a massive lgbt romance in YA fantasy. (Let me know if you have any recs!!)