Take a photo of a barcode or cover
kaylaramoutar 's review for:
Simon vs. the Homo Sapiens Agenda
by Becky Albertalli
3.5
This was a fun, charming book, but nothing new or special. I realize this book came out in 2015 and it is currently 2017, but nothing in it was fresh. Don't get me wrong - I enjoyed it! I really did. I devoured it. I just felt like it lacked something. Maybe if I had read this back in 2015 when it came out I'd have a different opinion, but I just found it slightly overrated. I still recommend it.
The best thing about this book is how diverse it is. And it wasn't diverse to be diverse, it just was, and I really appreciated that. There were some characters I liked - Simon, Abby, Simon's sisters - and some characters that I found unlikable or not-real-enough - Leah, Nick, Martin. If Martin was truly a good guy he wouldn't have done what he did, no ifs ands or buts. "People make mistakes" - okay, sure, true. His mistake is blackmailing Simon. But what he did later in the novel is unforgivable. Nick was bland to me, so so bland that it was shocking so many girls liked him. And Leah.... girl. Take a BREATH. I really didn't like her and found her cringe-worthy and almost a caricature of a real person.
I am really excited to see the movie though. I think I'll like it more than the novel! The first teaser poster was unveiled today on National Coming Out Day, and it looks good.
EDIT: the movie was SO good. I really like how Leah was written in it. Most of the issues I had with the book was “fixed”(/changed?) in the movie which I loved. Movie 5/5 (something I have said v rarely in my life)
This was a fun, charming book, but nothing new or special. I realize this book came out in 2015 and it is currently 2017, but nothing in it was fresh. Don't get me wrong - I enjoyed it! I really did. I devoured it. I just felt like it lacked something. Maybe if I had read this back in 2015 when it came out I'd have a different opinion, but I just found it slightly overrated. I still recommend it.
The best thing about this book is how diverse it is. And it wasn't diverse to be diverse, it just was, and I really appreciated that. There were some characters I liked - Simon, Abby, Simon's sisters - and some characters that I found unlikable or not-real-enough - Leah, Nick, Martin. If Martin was truly a good guy he wouldn't have done what he did, no ifs ands or buts. "People make mistakes" - okay, sure, true. His mistake is blackmailing Simon. But what he did later in the novel is unforgivable. Nick was bland to me, so so bland that it was shocking so many girls liked him. And Leah.... girl. Take a BREATH. I really didn't like her and found her cringe-worthy and almost a caricature of a real person.
I am really excited to see the movie though. I think I'll like it more than the novel! The first teaser poster was unveiled today on National Coming Out Day, and it looks good.
EDIT: the movie was SO good. I really like how Leah was written in it. Most of the issues I had with the book was “fixed”(/changed?) in the movie which I loved. Movie 5/5 (something I have said v rarely in my life)