92 reviews by:

chrisssl

Filter
adventurous mysterious fast-paced

A short lovely little book that really manages to capture the spirit of childhood, in all its fear and wonder.  Written in the perspective of a 7/8 year old boy living in South England, you might find the prose a bit clumsy, but it quickly finds its form after the first quarter of the book.  At this point the book proceeds to compel the reader to the finish line with great flashes of creative imagery and bizarre, half-understood events and the sudden and irrevocable passing from fearlessness into fearfulness.  Surreal events and characters find their way into this story, coming, and going, and existing in this liminal condition of being in heightened observation, though beyond comprehension as so much of the world can be as a child.  The epilogue of the book (written like the prologue, from a different perspective) is what really elevates the story; the yearning for the half-remembered past where things were more fixed and yet unfixed, the mind's way of holding different or multiple images of memory, snipping and stitching, in ephemeral flashes of recall in which only the emotions linger and are carried forward.
mysterious medium-paced

A gorgeously written book, both excoriating the superciliousness of its main cast of characters: The Greeks, their wealth and privilege and airs of sophistication; while simultaneously making them alluring and intriguing for a time.  For a book whose main preoccupation is about the aestheticism of classical scholarship (more than the scholarship itself), the style of writing is fantastic; lusciously detailed and pointed.  These intolerable self-regarding rich-kids in their Gatsby-esque accoutrements and fashionable substance-abuse habits couple with a meticulous writing about the venerable, nature-bound setting of a liberal arts college in a sleepy college-town in Vermont; these combine to form a dazzling painterly mood which takes firm centre stage over the plot of a murder-mystery (of sorts) and its aftermath.  It's a "picturesque" impressionism that the writing achieves vividly, marrying the prose with the ultimate obsessions of Donna Tart's characters.  It's a dreamlike atmosphere (one only needs to count the ludicrous amount of time the narrator, Richard, spends asleep, only to be constantly awoken, and the plot advanced, by his fellow Greeks, appearing instantly and outrageously at his bedside), sugary and self-satisfied, which then advances into sharp nightmarish qualities.  The characters are perfectly attuned to this atmosphere, and more than that, self-aware of it.  The latter half of the book runs a tad long and descends into something approaching melodrama - which should make it clear to any frustrated reader: this is first and foremost a satire.  I don't imagine myself likely to reread this novel (perhaps I'd feel a stronger impulse had I read this at 19) but it's still a very fine book. 
adventurous challenging informative reflective slow-paced

In popular western culture, we all know something of Moby Dick.  To read the book today is to grapple with a text that seems so foundational to the American literary tradition - call it what you will: a classic, an epic, a masterpiece; it's reputation is widespread and well-earned.  What is perhaps less well-known (at least to this first time reader) is how damn weird this book is.

To describe what the book is about is something of a challenge, and I have a feeling that the author, resurrected, would have no better luck here.  The plot, as is well known, ostensibly centers around Captain Ahab chasing the White Whale, Moby Dick, across all the oceans of the world in vengeance for his lost leg.  But this is only the least part of what the book seems to be about.  Intermingled in such a quest-like structure is a huge systematic treatise on that mystery of the whale itself, nearly breaking readers to exhaustion by the deluge of encyclopedic pseudo-academic chapters where hardly a narrative strand can be found and we simply talk of whales and their anatomies, behaviours, social interactions, significance in ancient history and modern economy, depictions in art, and critiques on contemporary essays upon the subject.  This is coupled with a less academic (though no less thorough) set of chapters elucidating the practice of whaling.  And before any of this, here comes Ishmael, the supposed "narrator" of this story, in which the first 28 chapters centers around him, in a more traditional protagonist framework.  He's a remarkably modern character for such a classic story but these first 100 pages are really the false premise, as Ishmael narratively retreats into oblivion just as soon as Ahab makes his appearance, and what little we see of him are from the various whale/whaling digressions in which he serves as proctor.

This book is a challenging read, and would be nigh impossible to finish if it wasn't for the utter brilliancy of its writing.  Like I'm sure has been said before, this book is nothing short of Shakespearean verse rendered into the form of a novel (albeit a weird, half-experimental one).  This comparison can be lazily drawn based on similar uses of early modern english, but it really lies in how each paragraph (or some of Melville's page-long sentences) revel in their words.  The book consistently produces a rhythm to its writing that begs to be read aloud (or at least consciously subvocalized).  I've used the term "lyrical" to describe the prose of book's I've enjoyed, but I think I've been mis-using the term until now.  The language in Moby Dick is exactly lyrical - poetic, it sings.  And a bit more on its Shakespearean qualities - at certain points it literally becomes a play-script, complete with stage directions and theatrical asides.  And I'd match a great many of Ahab's soliloquies against the very best of Hamlet, Lear, Macbeth and the works in terms of sheer emotional and linguistic achievement and philosophical merit.  Where Melville chooses to indulge in those beautiful prolonged sentences, juggling dozens of conjunctions, they never fail to be a pleasure to read, and, surprisingly, precisely clear as to what is being said.  There's so much in Melville's prose, and yet it's startlingly easy to follow the language; how both depth and approachability are accomplished baffles me.  So much imagery and metaphors and diverse digressions of philosophy and thought are extracted from the setting of the sea, it's almost unreal how much mileage the book gets from such a relatively consistent scenery.  The book is also chalk full of allusions and references to (it seems, anyway) every classical work under the sun, tales from antiquity, biblical parables, and so much else it's almost overwhelming to think how well-read the author must have been to commit all of this into a single book.

These encyclopedic whale chapters can be entertaining in their own right, provided the reader establish their own reasoning for why it is they are in the book in the first place.  They contain a bit of wit to them (moreover, Moby Dick as a whole is much funnier than its reputation suggests) and are still written in a wicked style (though less poetic than some of the philosophical/narrative chapters).  However they can still be a chore, and despite personally warming to them as they became more frequent in the middle of the book, I found myself drowning in the sheer density of Moby Dick.  In a month of exclusive, compact and careful reading, my mind started to become hazy on previous delightful episodes or interactions between the whaler crew, as my memories were crowded out by stuff like the number, width and height of Spermwhale ribs (for christ sake!).  I had to refer to copious notes during my reading to keep a firm understanding of the book's events and I feel this did interfere with my enjoyment of it as a whole.  I'm sure a re-read (if I ever get to it) will be a smoother ride.

Moby Dick contains such a colourful (if a bit dated) cast of characters in the crew of the whaling ship: the Pequod, and it's a shame they had to fight for prominence amid the Great Whale Encyclopedia.  I wanted more on tender Queequeg, the woeful Blacksmith and traumatized Pip.  Luckily Captain Ahab is so wonderfully realized and casts as large a shadow over the book as Moby Dick himself.  In so many chapters concerning this fell, one-legged captain, I had to put the book down and just marvel at what a character he was (assisted by the contrast to his fascinating, level-headed first-mate: Starbuck).

It's a supremely odd book, no question about it, at times seeming like the text is fighting to serve three or four entirely different novels altogether.  But its written in such achingly beautiful prose, mythologizing the whale and its hunt into nothing less than an Arthurian quest replete with dragons and knights, and contending with seemingly everything under the sun:  the deep capacity for evil inside men,  solitude, the weariness of living, limits of rationality, the indifference of nature to man's great toils, and of course the belligerence of a madman.  And it caps off in a spectacular, whirlwind of chapters (starting from Chapter 116) that bring a thrilling end to the mad hunt for Moby Dick. What a book!
dark fast-paced

Prima Facie is a book adaptation of a recent hit one-woman play written by Suzie Miller, performed by Jodie Comer.  Having seen a recording of the stage play over a year ago and being floored by how phenomenal it was, I was intrigued but perplexed upon hearing that the playwright would adapt and elaborate on her brisk 2-act play into a novel.  I specifically sought out the audiobook rendition, in which the play's star, Jodie Comer, returns as the main character and narrator.

It's too difficult to assemble my thoughts in a way which evaluates this novel independently from its originating stage play, and separates the written words from the audio performance so I'm not even going to try.  This is a frank and blunt story of a criminal defence lawyer, her rape and experiences with her brave decision to hold her rapist to account by the same laws, courts and institutions she used to acquit so many over her own accused clients (many also being sexual-assault cases).  It's a story told with an exacting measure of familiarity with the law and the psychological turmoil of rape victims;  for these ambitions alone might be worth a read.  There are brutal parts in the book, very powerful, very affecting and without adornment or refinement.

However, this book (in audio form) is more than five times the duration of the original stage play and not only does it not deliver anything beyond the original play, it has actually made me re-evaluate what I thought of the play in the first place: namely that the brilliance of the play was carried far more by Jodie Comer's stage performance than the strengths of the text.  I originally thought this piece of theatre was better positioned for novelization than most, since it is delivered with a single distinct voice and perspective, told entirely as an aside with at least as many words directly transposable to prose as those to dialogue.  But where clipped directness of words works when associated with live performance, it fares less well on page.  I'm not sure if the following are present in the stage play, but the need to forthrightly declare the emotional state of the main character is maddening to read.  Some unaltered examples are as follows:

  • I feel angry.
  • I feel scared.
  • I feel humiliated.
  • I feel anxious.
  • I feel so sad.

The worst part about the above is that these usually precede sentences very decently illustrating her state of mind, making these silly preceding statements entirely unnecessary.  The book as a whole suffers a lot from a feeling of repetition; very few of its elaborations on the play feel insightful.  Side characters who were formerly afforded only a sentence or two, have a bit more prominent role (the brother, Adam and Alice).  But they never transcend their obvious purposes as avatars for various tangents (guilt of social mobility, male positivity, and internalized misogyny respectively).

I also have a problem with how the acute gut punch during the voir dire towards the end of the story is muted by the new medium.  Having emphasized the role of barristers as storytellers to the captive jury, the decision to have the main character, Tessa, makes an elaborate monologue absent of the jury.  The play presents this as an untameable outburst of emotion that has been building since Tessa's assault and it is made clear that her words are not for the judge in some legal capacity than for the audience - the audience who she has been talking to the entire time, and yet it never felt conscious, motivated or acknowledged until that moment.  But the novel doesn't (or perhaps CAN'T) simulate this feeling exactly; we aren't staring at a human performance (even the disembodied narration is no substitute).  This theatre-specific moment and would require some textual creativity to try and reach the same emotional beats.  So lacking this, the moment loses its stunning power and instead becomes a hopeless vaguely targeted statement against the system.  Here a shallow surrogate of the audience, a court reporter, makes limited success in salvaging the play's crowning fourth-wall moment in a book-specific epilogue.

Reading this is not like Shakespeare or Chekov or Tom Stoppard or even Martin McDonagh plays.  All Prima Facie's power rests in its delivery.  And the delivery here (reminder: from the same actor) is wildly different from the original performance and undermines the story.  The brash, confident projection of the theatrical performance is exchanged for a soft, subdued, reflective audio performance that carries this tone throughout the entire novel.  I guess it makes sense to take advantage of a medium which in some ways is more forgiving and intimate, but this choice sabotages the emotional impact of the novel.  The stage play allows us to see that what happens to the main character and how it utterly transforms her, not only in terms of the plot but in her voice and in her physical performance.  The novel follows the plays vivid first-person present-tense style, but the narration almost serves as a past-tense recounting - the sadness of the narrator's tone fits the character she becomes after the event, but not who she is for the first half of the event.  There is no subtextual juxtaposition here book is much weaker for it.

This book's story remains important but it's painfully obvious that this is a book working against its own medium (a weakness I would assume most novelizations share), and is best experienced on the stage.  If one has access to National Theatre Live at Home,  seek out the recording of this play, which is invariably superior rendition of this story.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
dark reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes

 Often recommended as the literary novel for people who dislike literary novels, this is certainly an interesting book and a more compelling premise than is normally found in some Pulitzer Prize-winning novels.  There are certain cursory elements of spy-thriller in this book but its strengths extend well beyond coded messages and plots.  The writing is rich and curious; no detail is beyond metaphorical scrutiny to the narration.  The author manages a decent pace, in spite of its constant inquisition of 1970s America as seen from the eyes of a Vietnamese refugee and covert spy for the North Vietnamese.  Not every insight is original (and some are pretty trite) and yet, it feels like a popular approachable piece of fiction sympathizing, excoriating and espying the West from an Asian perspective is so long overdue.  It has something new to say and your mileage might vary with how groundbreaking that message might be, but it seems incontrovertibly different (or at least comes to the point in far different ways).
 
The main thing holding this novel back is that it is too self-aware or insecure of its sleekness and cleverness.  No metaphor can be allowed without exhaustively elaborating on it to completion.  No literary device or thematic parallel can be used without laboriously calling attention to itself.  This leaves the reader with many answers and scarce few lingering questions.  To a thriller this might be desirable, but just as the sympathizer is slave to two masters: capitalist and communist, Catholic western father and Vietnamese Mother, oriental and occidental, The Sympathizer as a novel is similarly tugged between literary and genre dispositions, and ends up serving one to the detriment of the other.  In embroiling itself in self-study (albeit an easy temptation given that the story is framed as a confessional writing in the first person),  the book is a satisfying read, but holds the reader’s hand too firmly.  I can’t help but compare this against Kurt Vonnegut’s superior double-agent novel: Mother Night, to which The Sympathizer owes a great deal at least in premise.  Vonnegut’s customary curtness serves to frustrate and engage the reader to further understand the twin perceptions and deceptions of the narrator, meanwhile The Sympathizer marches along the main body of its text to a smooth unbroken cadence of observation-analysis, observation-analysis. 
 
One of the best moments in the novel is a chapter in which the prose dissociates stylistically in response to the sleep-deprivation and tortured self-reflection of a character.  The writing becomes feverish and distracted, weaving in and out of focus, consciousness and perspective, digressing to a wonderful (if again overly-extensive) discourse about the Foot vs. the Hand.  It’s splendid and thrilling, but undercut by the author’s need to immediately make sure the reader is following along and understanding its (initial) subtextual quality.  Luckily, the final chapter of the novel allows itself to explode into new territory, free from the author’s terminal over-analysis, with a command of writing that feels ambitious and deliberate; adopting and embracing old pretences and terminology in new ways that drive home a satisfying and (in hindsight) inevitable culmination of the novel. 
 
Some elements, like the spectres dogging the main character or a rather over-long interlude with the American movie industry, feel a bit perfunctory and underdeveloped.  Certainly, the middle portion of the novel contains a certain rote detached condescension that maybe endeared it to Pulitzer Prize heights.  But the novel contains a unique and rare voice and confidence that stumbles occasionally but caps off with a brilliant ending that will surely endear more than a few skeptical readers to the novel as a whole. 
emotional funny reflective medium-paced

One definitely feels like "the internet" is the ultimate taboo in contemporary fiction.  For those fiction writers who aspire to verisimilitude in the 21st century (at least from the over-represented American experience), it seems unfathomable that anything meaningful might be attempted without addressing the most transformative and ubiquitous force of the time.  And yet nearly all authors tip-toe around this sleeping beast of a subject,  and who can rightly blame them?  The internet is too large, too fragmented,  too dynamic for any author to capture in some maximalist oeuvre.

Patricia Lockwood takes a brave stab at this woefully under-explored subject in fiction.  The result is one small weird book that somehow genuinely captures an experience of the internet like no other piece of fiction I've ever read.  An experience - not the experience (there is no the experience; the only text which could possibly represent it, is the internet itself).  In No One Is Talking About This, the main character's slice of the internet (or as she refers to it: the portal) is seemingly that of the early twitter power-user; a light-hearted troll-ish sensibility; the meme-maker; internet-lingo coiner and connoisseur.   Her's is the arena of the topical, exaggerated, sometimes lurid, throwaway humour; communicating by static text and image.  The other diverse corners of the internet are broached briefly but the focus here is necessarily tight and personal.

The text is formed as a series of ~450 excerpts, sometimes tightly connected, other times fleeting digressions; delineated by visual line-breaks.  Some readers might find some textual similarities to message boards or tweets or facebook posts.  Others, like me, will find it a tad annoying.  But whichever way it strikes you, the result should be a narrative that is scattered, distracted, drawn to everything, yet seemingly about nothing;  mile-wide, inch-deep, abbreviated thought-bunnies tossed into the ether.  Could there be a more perfect representation of this part of the internet?  Yet there is, of course, more to it than that.  Because the writing is not (or not only) the pastiche of chronically-online millenials.  These aggravatingly brief excerpts assume the form of disposable text in an endless scroll, but in fact are really beautiful and meditative pieces of fragmented prose, hiding in pop-culture references, internet in-speak and quotidian affairs.  To a lesser writer, this might devolve into lists of glib pretentious aphorisms drawn straight from the fortune-cookie factory.  But Patricia Lockwood's writing is approachable, self-deprecating, self-assured and funny as hell.  At times some sentences hardly relate at all to surrounding ones, other times the author draws upon very bizarre metaphors; and it's tempting to conclude the writing is as wild and superfluous as its subject.  Some sentences and excerpts need to be read and re-read before continuing and the book demands a bit more diligence than its length would suggest.  That the book's author is also a published poet should come as no surprise.

But taken together and with help of the plot which begins in earnest halfway through the book, the disparate excerpts (told more or less linearly, thank goodness) come together into a patchwork of moments and vibes that are serene and nostalgic, angry and devastating, witty and charming and really do evoke some key part of the western experience in the 21st century as yet unrecorded in fiction.  This scratches a huge itch for me - a 21st century novel that aspires to be timeful instead of chasing timelessness, that describes some portrait of existence in a confounding age.  Real world events are commented on, immediately (and potentially poorly) dating the novel.  Specific internet memes are sprinkled throughout the book, some I know, some I don't, but even those I don't know nevertheless feel real, like they are an authoritative part of the online culture that the book's readers are irrevocably a part of.

The novel resists the easy moralization of its subject and is constantly reflecting and reacting to this digital world's effect on the main characters real-world perceptions (there is far more excerpts set in the real world than those describing engagements in the portal, and they are sometimes more absurd than any online cogitations).  One of its more pervasive themes, is how the quippy, ironic, hindsight-ed internet meme humour might bleed into real-world speech through an increasingly callow perspective.  And how such new rhetorics fail when confronted with brutal real-world events for which there is no joke or punchline, where digital recourses are performative or without conviction and the ironical internet culture guru must draw up for breath and realize they are, at least partly, the architects of their own stupidity and impotence.

This takes shape in the second half of the book, which takes a sharp turn towards the plot, which feels familiar yet so devastating and painful and personal.  The excerpts become more tightly focused (more as successive scenes, than hypertext).  The writing becomes more poetic and full of brief intense imagery, and it feels like the excerpts are becoming longer, deeper, more meditative, when in fact, the form never changes throughout the whole book.  The portal is interacted with less and less, but its affects on the main character's mind and constitution are no less pronounced.

This book is weird and not for everyone but is a quick read for those who can get into the vibe and rhythm of the novel's structure.  It would seem targeted at a specific demographic and be of and about a unique time so how broadly appealing this book might be is anyone's guess.  But as for this millenial, if you want a quirky, funny novel that takes an earnest and visceral stab at describing the bewilderment of living in the digital age, this is a great place to start!

The City of Brass

S.A. Chakraborty

DID NOT FINISH: 39%

Paladin's Grace

T. Kingfisher

DID NOT FINISH: 46%