chrisssl 's review for:

The Sympathizer by Viet Thanh Nguyen
4.0
dark reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes

 Often recommended as the literary novel for people who dislike literary novels, this is certainly an interesting book and a more compelling premise than is normally found in some Pulitzer Prize-winning novels.  There are certain cursory elements of spy-thriller in this book but its strengths extend well beyond coded messages and plots.  The writing is rich and curious; no detail is beyond metaphorical scrutiny to the narration.  The author manages a decent pace, in spite of its constant inquisition of 1970s America as seen from the eyes of a Vietnamese refugee and covert spy for the North Vietnamese.  Not every insight is original (and some are pretty trite) and yet, it feels like a popular approachable piece of fiction sympathizing, excoriating and espying the West from an Asian perspective is so long overdue.  It has something new to say and your mileage might vary with how groundbreaking that message might be, but it seems incontrovertibly different (or at least comes to the point in far different ways).
 
The main thing holding this novel back is that it is too self-aware or insecure of its sleekness and cleverness.  No metaphor can be allowed without exhaustively elaborating on it to completion.  No literary device or thematic parallel can be used without laboriously calling attention to itself.  This leaves the reader with many answers and scarce few lingering questions.  To a thriller this might be desirable, but just as the sympathizer is slave to two masters: capitalist and communist, Catholic western father and Vietnamese Mother, oriental and occidental, The Sympathizer as a novel is similarly tugged between literary and genre dispositions, and ends up serving one to the detriment of the other.  In embroiling itself in self-study (albeit an easy temptation given that the story is framed as a confessional writing in the first person),  the book is a satisfying read, but holds the reader’s hand too firmly.  I can’t help but compare this against Kurt Vonnegut’s superior double-agent novel: Mother Night, to which The Sympathizer owes a great deal at least in premise.  Vonnegut’s customary curtness serves to frustrate and engage the reader to further understand the twin perceptions and deceptions of the narrator, meanwhile The Sympathizer marches along the main body of its text to a smooth unbroken cadence of observation-analysis, observation-analysis. 
 
One of the best moments in the novel is a chapter in which the prose dissociates stylistically in response to the sleep-deprivation and tortured self-reflection of a character.  The writing becomes feverish and distracted, weaving in and out of focus, consciousness and perspective, digressing to a wonderful (if again overly-extensive) discourse about the Foot vs. the Hand.  It’s splendid and thrilling, but undercut by the author’s need to immediately make sure the reader is following along and understanding its (initial) subtextual quality.  Luckily, the final chapter of the novel allows itself to explode into new territory, free from the author’s terminal over-analysis, with a command of writing that feels ambitious and deliberate; adopting and embracing old pretences and terminology in new ways that drive home a satisfying and (in hindsight) inevitable culmination of the novel. 
 
Some elements, like the spectres dogging the main character or a rather over-long interlude with the American movie industry, feel a bit perfunctory and underdeveloped.  Certainly, the middle portion of the novel contains a certain rote detached condescension that maybe endeared it to Pulitzer Prize heights.  But the novel contains a unique and rare voice and confidence that stumbles occasionally but caps off with a brilliant ending that will surely endear more than a few skeptical readers to the novel as a whole.