You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.
Take a photo of a barcode or cover
chrisssl 's review for:
No One Is Talking About This
by Patricia Lockwood
emotional
funny
reflective
medium-paced
One definitely feels like "the internet" is the ultimate taboo in contemporary fiction. For those fiction writers who aspire to verisimilitude in the 21st century (at least from the over-represented American experience), it seems unfathomable that anything meaningful might be attempted without addressing the most transformative and ubiquitous force of the time. And yet nearly all authors tip-toe around this sleeping beast of a subject, and who can rightly blame them? The internet is too large, too fragmented, too dynamic for any author to capture in some maximalist oeuvre.
Patricia Lockwood takes a brave stab at this woefully under-explored subject in fiction. The result is one small weird book that somehow genuinely captures an experience of the internet like no other piece of fiction I've ever read. An experience - not the experience (there is no the experience; the only text which could possibly represent it, is the internet itself). In No One Is Talking About This, the main character's slice of the internet (or as she refers to it: the portal) is seemingly that of the early twitter power-user; a light-hearted troll-ish sensibility; the meme-maker; internet-lingo coiner and connoisseur. Her's is the arena of the topical, exaggerated, sometimes lurid, throwaway humour; communicating by static text and image. The other diverse corners of the internet are broached briefly but the focus here is necessarily tight and personal.
The text is formed as a series of ~450 excerpts, sometimes tightly connected, other times fleeting digressions; delineated by visual line-breaks. Some readers might find some textual similarities to message boards or tweets or facebook posts. Others, like me, will find it a tad annoying. But whichever way it strikes you, the result should be a narrative that is scattered, distracted, drawn to everything, yet seemingly about nothing; mile-wide, inch-deep, abbreviated thought-bunnies tossed into the ether. Could there be a more perfect representation of this part of the internet? Yet there is, of course, more to it than that. Because the writing is not (or not only) the pastiche of chronically-online millenials. These aggravatingly brief excerpts assume the form of disposable text in an endless scroll, but in fact are really beautiful and meditative pieces of fragmented prose, hiding in pop-culture references, internet in-speak and quotidian affairs. To a lesser writer, this might devolve into lists of glib pretentious aphorisms drawn straight from the fortune-cookie factory. But Patricia Lockwood's writing is approachable, self-deprecating, self-assured and funny as hell. At times some sentences hardly relate at all to surrounding ones, other times the author draws upon very bizarre metaphors; and it's tempting to conclude the writing is as wild and superfluous as its subject. Some sentences and excerpts need to be read and re-read before continuing and the book demands a bit more diligence than its length would suggest. That the book's author is also a published poet should come as no surprise.
But taken together and with help of the plot which begins in earnest halfway through the book, the disparate excerpts (told more or less linearly, thank goodness) come together into a patchwork of moments and vibes that are serene and nostalgic, angry and devastating, witty and charming and really do evoke some key part of the western experience in the 21st century as yet unrecorded in fiction. This scratches a huge itch for me - a 21st century novel that aspires to be timeful instead of chasing timelessness, that describes some portrait of existence in a confounding age. Real world events are commented on, immediately (and potentially poorly) dating the novel. Specific internet memes are sprinkled throughout the book, some I know, some I don't, but even those I don't know nevertheless feel real, like they are an authoritative part of the online culture that the book's readers are irrevocably a part of.
The novel resists the easy moralization of its subject and is constantly reflecting and reacting to this digital world's effect on the main characters real-world perceptions (there is far more excerpts set in the real world than those describing engagements in the portal, and they are sometimes more absurd than any online cogitations). One of its more pervasive themes, is how the quippy, ironic, hindsight-ed internet meme humour might bleed into real-world speech through an increasingly callow perspective. And how such new rhetorics fail when confronted with brutal real-world events for which there is no joke or punchline, where digital recourses are performative or without conviction and the ironical internet culture guru must draw up for breath and realize they are, at least partly, the architects of their own stupidity and impotence.
This takes shape in the second half of the book, which takes a sharp turn towards the plot, which feels familiar yet so devastating and painful and personal. The excerpts become more tightly focused (more as successive scenes, than hypertext). The writing becomes more poetic and full of brief intense imagery, and it feels like the excerpts are becoming longer, deeper, more meditative, when in fact, the form never changes throughout the whole book. The portal is interacted with less and less, but its affects on the main character's mind and constitution are no less pronounced.
This book is weird and not for everyone but is a quick read for those who can get into the vibe and rhythm of the novel's structure. It would seem targeted at a specific demographic and be of and about a unique time so how broadly appealing this book might be is anyone's guess. But as for this millenial, if you want a quirky, funny novel that takes an earnest and visceral stab at describing the bewilderment of living in the digital age, this is a great place to start!
Patricia Lockwood takes a brave stab at this woefully under-explored subject in fiction. The result is one small weird book that somehow genuinely captures an experience of the internet like no other piece of fiction I've ever read. An experience - not the experience (there is no the experience; the only text which could possibly represent it, is the internet itself). In No One Is Talking About This, the main character's slice of the internet (or as she refers to it: the portal) is seemingly that of the early twitter power-user; a light-hearted troll-ish sensibility; the meme-maker; internet-lingo coiner and connoisseur. Her's is the arena of the topical, exaggerated, sometimes lurid, throwaway humour; communicating by static text and image. The other diverse corners of the internet are broached briefly but the focus here is necessarily tight and personal.
The text is formed as a series of ~450 excerpts, sometimes tightly connected, other times fleeting digressions; delineated by visual line-breaks. Some readers might find some textual similarities to message boards or tweets or facebook posts. Others, like me, will find it a tad annoying. But whichever way it strikes you, the result should be a narrative that is scattered, distracted, drawn to everything, yet seemingly about nothing; mile-wide, inch-deep, abbreviated thought-bunnies tossed into the ether. Could there be a more perfect representation of this part of the internet? Yet there is, of course, more to it than that. Because the writing is not (or not only) the pastiche of chronically-online millenials. These aggravatingly brief excerpts assume the form of disposable text in an endless scroll, but in fact are really beautiful and meditative pieces of fragmented prose, hiding in pop-culture references, internet in-speak and quotidian affairs. To a lesser writer, this might devolve into lists of glib pretentious aphorisms drawn straight from the fortune-cookie factory. But Patricia Lockwood's writing is approachable, self-deprecating, self-assured and funny as hell. At times some sentences hardly relate at all to surrounding ones, other times the author draws upon very bizarre metaphors; and it's tempting to conclude the writing is as wild and superfluous as its subject. Some sentences and excerpts need to be read and re-read before continuing and the book demands a bit more diligence than its length would suggest. That the book's author is also a published poet should come as no surprise.
But taken together and with help of the plot which begins in earnest halfway through the book, the disparate excerpts (told more or less linearly, thank goodness) come together into a patchwork of moments and vibes that are serene and nostalgic, angry and devastating, witty and charming and really do evoke some key part of the western experience in the 21st century as yet unrecorded in fiction. This scratches a huge itch for me - a 21st century novel that aspires to be timeful instead of chasing timelessness, that describes some portrait of existence in a confounding age. Real world events are commented on, immediately (and potentially poorly) dating the novel. Specific internet memes are sprinkled throughout the book, some I know, some I don't, but even those I don't know nevertheless feel real, like they are an authoritative part of the online culture that the book's readers are irrevocably a part of.
The novel resists the easy moralization of its subject and is constantly reflecting and reacting to this digital world's effect on the main characters real-world perceptions (there is far more excerpts set in the real world than those describing engagements in the portal, and they are sometimes more absurd than any online cogitations). One of its more pervasive themes, is how the quippy, ironic, hindsight-ed internet meme humour might bleed into real-world speech through an increasingly callow perspective. And how such new rhetorics fail when confronted with brutal real-world events for which there is no joke or punchline, where digital recourses are performative or without conviction and the ironical internet culture guru must draw up for breath and realize they are, at least partly, the architects of their own stupidity and impotence.
This takes shape in the second half of the book, which takes a sharp turn towards the plot, which feels familiar yet so devastating and painful and personal. The excerpts become more tightly focused (more as successive scenes, than hypertext). The writing becomes more poetic and full of brief intense imagery, and it feels like the excerpts are becoming longer, deeper, more meditative, when in fact, the form never changes throughout the whole book. The portal is interacted with less and less, but its affects on the main character's mind and constitution are no less pronounced.
This book is weird and not for everyone but is a quick read for those who can get into the vibe and rhythm of the novel's structure. It would seem targeted at a specific demographic and be of and about a unique time so how broadly appealing this book might be is anyone's guess. But as for this millenial, if you want a quirky, funny novel that takes an earnest and visceral stab at describing the bewilderment of living in the digital age, this is a great place to start!