Take a photo of a barcode or cover
mysterious
relaxing
medium-paced
A truly atmospheric novel of a strange labyrinth and stillness and emptiness. The main character charters his way through impossible, limitless cathedral halls containing the seas and the clouds, lined with marbled statues and only one other living person. The book works best as a mood piece, channeling the eery quietness and solemnity just as well as the author did in various parts of her debut novel: Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell. Compelling the reader onwards is the mystery of who this main character is, what is the nature of this labyrinth and how come things aren't quite adding up? It's not an ineffective mystery and makes this novel more of a page-turner than the author's last giant tome but at the same time it amounts to far less than the environment encompassing it. It's too much to suggest the novel would have been better served with less plot but all the same it's a somewhat average mystery that bleeds the setting of a lot of its power. A quick and pleasant read but one that feels like it's all the lesser bits of some of Jorge Borges own short stories.
fast-paced
A Portugese woman barricades herself in her bourgeois apartment on the eve of Angolan independence. Inside she makes do with what she has, consuming the apartment which consumes her in turn, while watching from the windows as the streets and people below flex under the changes and disappointments of independence, revolution and civil war.
Above is something like the blurb on the back-cover of this book and it is technically correct while being largely misleading. For a premise like this, one might expect a sort of claustrophobic introspection of a woman who has, for her own obvious and less obvious reasons, shut herself off from a world gone mad. However a reader will quickly pick up on the fact that the author has only a scarce desire to flesh her out and develop her interiority. Her struggles of surviving in seclusion reaches no higher purpose than her stomach - little do we learn of her psychology, her fear and isolation. Instead of a narrative locked in the walls of an apartment, with no other recourse than to look inward, the author spreads the plot across numerous characters, free to roam the capital city of Luanda, going about their own journeys until entwining and encircling, eventually, back to that secluded apartment. The novel, to its credit, cares little about orienting the reader with a summary of historical events, the major factions and interests and regimes. Instead the reader is left to scrape together a confusing portrait of a confusing time and it manages to work in the effect of distant observation from the high window of a disaffected recluse like our main character Ludo.
This fiction draws from a real premise and supposedly, scattered throughout the short novel are entries of the real woman's own journal. These turn out to be the best and most poetic writing in the whole book - which otherwise contents itself on easy and smooth but not arresting prose. These are the only moments of acute interiority afforded to our main character and it seems the author's goal was not so much to flesh out such a real person than to place them in a small self-contained story, less concerned about colonialism, revolutions and foreign exploitation than simply being a story in the backdrop of such things. The narrative eventually comes together in a relatively satisfying way but it felt like it had the promise to be so much more.
Above is something like the blurb on the back-cover of this book and it is technically correct while being largely misleading. For a premise like this, one might expect a sort of claustrophobic introspection of a woman who has, for her own obvious and less obvious reasons, shut herself off from a world gone mad. However a reader will quickly pick up on the fact that the author has only a scarce desire to flesh her out and develop her interiority. Her struggles of surviving in seclusion reaches no higher purpose than her stomach - little do we learn of her psychology, her fear and isolation. Instead of a narrative locked in the walls of an apartment, with no other recourse than to look inward, the author spreads the plot across numerous characters, free to roam the capital city of Luanda, going about their own journeys until entwining and encircling, eventually, back to that secluded apartment. The novel, to its credit, cares little about orienting the reader with a summary of historical events, the major factions and interests and regimes. Instead the reader is left to scrape together a confusing portrait of a confusing time and it manages to work in the effect of distant observation from the high window of a disaffected recluse like our main character Ludo.
This fiction draws from a real premise and supposedly, scattered throughout the short novel are entries of the real woman's own journal. These turn out to be the best and most poetic writing in the whole book - which otherwise contents itself on easy and smooth but not arresting prose. These are the only moments of acute interiority afforded to our main character and it seems the author's goal was not so much to flesh out such a real person than to place them in a small self-contained story, less concerned about colonialism, revolutions and foreign exploitation than simply being a story in the backdrop of such things. The narrative eventually comes together in a relatively satisfying way but it felt like it had the promise to be so much more.
challenging
dark
I have no idea what to make of this book. On one hand, it presents a female friendship between two black girls: Nel and Sula, in the quaint weird setting of Bottom, a joke of a community offshoot of Medallion, Ohio. In so many ways it reminds one of 100 Years of Solitude by Gabriel Garcia Marquez: the quirky community, in some ways displaced from reality, but in other ways, deeply grounded in lived history; the peculiar enigmas (flocks of robins following one character, or a trio of dis-identified ageless boys) both inexplicable and unremarkable, and the rural quotidian quality of a fable interspersed with moments of sharp, unexpected violence.
Likewise, expect some beautiful writing, not showy or self-reflexive but done with an easy mastery over setting and imagery:
Likewise, expect some beautiful writing, not showy or self-reflexive but done with an easy mastery over setting and imagery:
Behind Nel was the bright and blazing light of her mother's smile; before her the midnight eyes of the soldiers. She saw the muscles of their faces tighten, a movement under the skin from blood to marble. No change in the expression of the eyes, but a hard wetness that veiled them as they looked at the stretch of her mother's foolish smile.
...old women sprinkled stove ashes, like ancient onyx, onto the new-minted silver. They hugged trees simply to hold for a moment all that life and largeness stilled in glass, and glazed at the sun pressed against the gray sky like a worn doubloon, wondering all the while if the world were coming to an end. Grass stood blade by blade, shocked into separateness by an ice that held for days.
However, in contrast to Marquez, Toni Morrison brings us far closer, far longer to the minds of adolescent, then later adult Nel and Sula, depicting two girls who have branched off into wildly different lives: Nel, consumed by the quiet domesticity shared by her fellow peers of the Bottom; Sula, seeking out the world with libertine delight. But however richly written Sula's pathological faithfulness to none but herself, it's very hard for me to empathize with such a swollen and total sense of self-regard; and so, strangely, her story leaves me fairly cold and less affected than others. Overall in my reading, I get the sense that I'm missing at least half of the author's subtext (Shadrack's National Suicide Day and the parade of 1941, stillness and change, and Eva's final conversation with Nel). Aware that the finer points of this book seems to have gone over my head, I suppose I can only say it was impressively written, but beyond my scope to fully appreciate in a first reading.
challenging
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
This is an incredible novel, a harrowing study of a man suffering an unrelenting tragic downfall, wrapped in a nuanced though somewhat distorted portrait of the post-war American boom and one generation's reaction to the countercultural movement. At its heart is the thoroughly realized character of Seymour "Swede" Levov: the city boy who loves the bucolic lifestyle of countryside living; the full-blooded Jewish son but every inch that blond-haired Aryan look and athletic predisposition that makes him both the envy and the oddity of his Jewish community; a man for whom stoic ordinariness of American living is the highest calling though whose early path through life is so charmed, fated and privileged this can hardly be written without inducing a snort of contempt in the reader; a thoroughly decent man whose entire world is turned upside down by the extreme actions of a wayward daughter; and, summarily, an avatar of the Silent Generation struggling and failing to understand that Man was expelled from Eden many millennia ago.
If you're looking for plot, this book is not it. There are certain moments where a smoother progression of thrilling events is hinted at: the mystery of how such a good-man as Swede and his pretty, multi-dimensional wife Dawn manage to raise a terrorist. But the author teases these things only to subsequently bury the promise of pace by way of protracted, comprehensive digressions into the Swede's past. But each of these stifling adventures into the Swede's memory is so effusively and lushly written, and forms such a complete account of Swede's bewilderment and shattered unity of spirit, that it should be appreciated for what it is. An attempt to write down particularly moving sentences from the novel had to be abandoned as I ended up nearly transcribing an entire third of the novel up to that point. The prose and writing is staggering: everything from turns of phrase, deep psychological conceits and sincerities, the instability of the perspective and framing (in which 3rd person point of view gives way to fevered, passionate 1st person and 2nd person interludes, as if in extreme moments, the reader can see, on the page: the nascent Id, the repressed furious interiority of Swede smashing its head against the immovable gates of his agreeable countenance), and a great thematic preoccupation with the truth about people, how little we know about them, and they about themselves; a somewhat meta-textual aside about the powers and limits of analysis and fiction, subtext and surface.
If you're looking for plot, this book is not it. There are certain moments where a smoother progression of thrilling events is hinted at: the mystery of how such a good-man as Swede and his pretty, multi-dimensional wife Dawn manage to raise a terrorist. But the author teases these things only to subsequently bury the promise of pace by way of protracted, comprehensive digressions into the Swede's past. But each of these stifling adventures into the Swede's memory is so effusively and lushly written, and forms such a complete account of Swede's bewilderment and shattered unity of spirit, that it should be appreciated for what it is. An attempt to write down particularly moving sentences from the novel had to be abandoned as I ended up nearly transcribing an entire third of the novel up to that point. The prose and writing is staggering: everything from turns of phrase, deep psychological conceits and sincerities, the instability of the perspective and framing (in which 3rd person point of view gives way to fevered, passionate 1st person and 2nd person interludes, as if in extreme moments, the reader can see, on the page: the nascent Id, the repressed furious interiority of Swede smashing its head against the immovable gates of his agreeable countenance), and a great thematic preoccupation with the truth about people, how little we know about them, and they about themselves; a somewhat meta-textual aside about the powers and limits of analysis and fiction, subtext and surface.
...and yet you never fail to get them wrong. You might as well have the brain of a tank. You get them wrong before you meet them, while you're anticipating meeting them; you get them wrong while you're with them; and then you go home to tell somebody else about the meeting and you get them all wrong again. Since the same generally goes for them with you, the whole thing is really a dazzling illusion empty of all perception, an astonishing farce of misperception. And yet what are we to do about this terrible significant business of other people, which gets bled of the significance we think it has and takes on instead a significance that is ludicrous, so ill-equipped are we to envision one another's interior workings and invisible aims? Is everyone to go off and lock the door and sit secluded like the lonely writers do, in a soundproof cell, summoning people out of words and then proposing that these word people are closer to the real thing than the real people that we mangle with our ignorance every day? The fact remains that getting people right is not what living is all about anyway. It's getting them wrong that is living, getting them wrong and wrong and wrong and then, on careful reconsideration, getting them wrong again.
In many ways I feel like this is as close as it gets to the definitive post-war American novel. The countercultural movement is not written in an especially flattering light (through Swede's perspective and that of the frame-writer Zuckerman belonging to that same generation), but it all serves less as an academically truthful inspection of a moment in history and more as a revealing truth of Swede's own limits of world-view and imagination, the men behind their heroic myths, the eternal inter-generational struggle, the broken social contract of that fabled American Dream for which earlier ancestral immigrants broke their backs for the sake of their grandchildren, the sheer horror of a world, which at the turn of one dramatic moment, becomes utterly unreasonable for those whom the world had, for a time, conspired for their success.
And who can adjust then? Here is someone not set up for life's working out poorly, let alone for the impossible. But who is set up for the impossible that is going to happen? Who is set up for tragedy and the incomprehensibility of suffering? Nobody. The tragedy of the man not set up for tragedy - that is every man's tragedy.
emotional
informative
sad
medium-paced
A deeply moving novel, full of unique perspectives from each of the Price women - ill-fated passengers on a disastrous, belligerent Baptist mission to the Congo, which will end in calamity and dissolution. A book of many perspectives, and largely about perspective, each of the Price women have a unique voice, guiding the reader into their new strange world, skillfully developing in ways to show how irrevocably they are being changed by their poorly-planned new life as missionaries. This is a story of the Congo, of a continent assailed with the legacy of colonialism, of dictators and civil wars and widespread famines and despotic, capitalistic greed; it's also the story of the destruction of a family. The small story tells the big story, and in turn is shaped by it. Perhaps there's nothing more pointed in the book than each character's individual reckoning of their own minute nature in so vast a land, their brief mortality over so vast a past and future, and the violent, myriad ways in which their unconscious self-centredness must be corrected by the brutal happenstance and fates of diseases and patriarchal tyrannies.
This book is a huge achievement in empathy. No character can see the full picture, each riddled with prejudices and flaws and interiority; their struggles are familiar, their gains and losses keenly felt by the reader, and even the monstrous bullying bigot that is the father Nathan Price; even this unsubtle avatar of all the worst vices of an arrogant man with scriptural authority, even for him, the author manages to engender the tiniest sliver of sympathy.
The writing is super vivid - one can easily picture the red dust of Kilanga, the carnivorous jungle deep - and though not especially quotable, the level of craft in the writing is a sight to behold, particularly when effortlessly juggling the different voices of the Price women; sometimes hilarious, other times sombre and poetic. Very readable yet filled with great prose; it's not the subtlest of novels but one can appreciate the craft, even if you can spot it from a distance.
I will say, this is a long book, and it is a bit bloated with a denouement that goes on far too long, despite I think, the well-intentions of the author to fully realize a Congo that exists before, and beyond the misbegotten travails of the Price mission; and likewise, the characters who go on after their family unit becomes utterly undone. But this is a staggeringly empathetic and emotional novel, which hardly ever broaches sentimentality or some parochial didacticism; and instead tells its story with unabashed sincerity, elucidating all these unique African lands marred and struggling under the weight of European powers and American commercial interests; and a family whose spiritual foundations similarly groan under the despotism of the Father. A book for basically anyone who can read.
This book is a huge achievement in empathy. No character can see the full picture, each riddled with prejudices and flaws and interiority; their struggles are familiar, their gains and losses keenly felt by the reader, and even the monstrous bullying bigot that is the father Nathan Price; even this unsubtle avatar of all the worst vices of an arrogant man with scriptural authority, even for him, the author manages to engender the tiniest sliver of sympathy.
The writing is super vivid - one can easily picture the red dust of Kilanga, the carnivorous jungle deep - and though not especially quotable, the level of craft in the writing is a sight to behold, particularly when effortlessly juggling the different voices of the Price women; sometimes hilarious, other times sombre and poetic. Very readable yet filled with great prose; it's not the subtlest of novels but one can appreciate the craft, even if you can spot it from a distance.
I will say, this is a long book, and it is a bit bloated with a denouement that goes on far too long, despite I think, the well-intentions of the author to fully realize a Congo that exists before, and beyond the misbegotten travails of the Price mission; and likewise, the characters who go on after their family unit becomes utterly undone. But this is a staggeringly empathetic and emotional novel, which hardly ever broaches sentimentality or some parochial didacticism; and instead tells its story with unabashed sincerity, elucidating all these unique African lands marred and struggling under the weight of European powers and American commercial interests; and a family whose spiritual foundations similarly groan under the despotism of the Father. A book for basically anyone who can read.
dark
medium-paced
I reckon most will know of Gabriel Garcia Marquez from his seminal work: 100 Years of Solitude. This short little book has certain shades of that giant work of literature; less expansive and ambitious but undeniably written with Marquez's customary rich language, detailed, memorable family units and far more focused than 100 Years of Solitude. There is not the same level of stunning writing as in Marquez's masterpiece but this novel does share a similar nonlinearity, forcefully mixing the setup of events with the tragic end result to tremendous effect (the reader is reminded on nearly ever page of Santiago Nasar's imminent murder). The title of the book describes the story well enough; a murder mystery of sorts, in which the mystery is less about who killed Santiago Nasar but rather how everyone in the town failed to prevent it, despite the murder being foretold. The following excerpt should prepare readers for what to expect:
He was so perplexed by the enigma that fate had touched him with, that he kept falling into lyrical distractions that ran contrary to the rigor of his profession. Most of all, he never thought it legitimate that life should make use of so many coincidences forbidden literature, so that there should be the untrammelled fulfillment of a death so clearly foretold.
What follows is a tragic unravelling of a dizzying number of named witnesses packed into such a short book; each having their own justifications to excuse their part in allowing such a murder to take place. There are moments of happenstance and coincidence, confusion and revenge, but most of all, the sense of collective contradiction; the townspeople who were warned of the murder laugh it off as implausible and yet still crowd around in anticipation of the event, bystanders shrug off their inaction as an uncontrollable realization of destiny (they are foretold of murder, not forewarned), even the murderers themselves, doubting their own cause, eventually believe the victim to be already doomed to death independent of their own actions and so go about their bloody business without remorse.
Again like 100 Years of Solitude, this novel can be difficult to warm to because hardly any of the characters act like human beings. There's a surreal (even self-aware) fatalism pervading all their quirks and behaviours. Characters act queer and dramatic, full of symmetries and ironies, lulling a reader with literary contraptions, predestination, fate and picturesque tragedy. So when the actual murder itself comes, gory, brutal and without poetics, despite knowing it's coming, it's horrifying and vicious and you can't help but feel a bit personally complicit in the story yourself.
dark
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
Richly written with incredibly sleek prose, this short story lures you into a house - this relic of the past, of colonial heritage, bewitches you with rapture from strange imagery, of the girl Aura and her ocean-green eyes, the mesmerizing, confusing lights in which... The scattered lights are braided in your eyelashes, as if you were seeing them through a silken net, the darkness and the silence; all this draws the reader in, leaning closer and closer to the pages, little suspecting the tale of horror and tragedy as old as time that comes to pass. Haunting with gorgeous prose, in a rare immersive second-person perspective, this is an incredible novella.
adventurous
funny
fast-paced
This is in many ways, a perfect novel. It's hard to imagine someone reading this and not falling in love with the amount of charm that oozes from each of its 200-odd pages. The prose is incredible - adopting the exacting observations of its pubescent, puritanical and outstandingly willful protagonist: Mattie Ross. The writing has so much character in it; this is a first-person perspective novel done properly, in which the narrator's voice and the book's tone are inseparable and perfectly in unison. The reader is attuned to the sense that this is a story about a young girl told in retrospect by the grown woman - a stern and erudite Christian worldview is projected onto all things, and yet there are always charming moments of girlhood and youthful exuberance that explode from the prose. Mattie Ross is eager to recount the story to us and entirely convinced of her own invincibility and capability in the rough world which she has only ever seen from the comforts of a brief privileged life. She is proven right and wrong in equal measure over the course of this adventure and it is delightful and comedic and occasionally poignant. This is such an unrelentingly funny novel in the most unexpected ways; the Western setting has never been done quite like this, especially through the eyes of a teenage girl, for whom the grisliness of this world is commonplace, all the while never failing to pass judgement on everything she sees. The amount of times you can laugh per page is altogether more remarkable because of how our protagonist Mattie Ross utterly lacks any sense of humour; her wry remarks about the moral failings of her surroundings translate into fits of laughter for the reader. Some hilarious moments off the top of my head include:
- Mattie Ross continually offering the services of her excellent lawyer to her captors
- The passive-aggressive remarks about a Catholic judge who turns Methodist on his deathbed.
- The proud but noble Texas Ranger LaBoeuf and how no one takes him seriously and is the butt of everyone's jokes.
There is not an ounce of fat in this novel. It is an absolute breeze to read and one only laments that the journey is over too soon. I can't think of anyone in the world that wouldn't love this book.
dark
funny
mysterious
fast-paced
The Trees is a brisk novel chock-full of the darkest humour that temporarily assumes the form of a detective thriller - complete with zany peculiarly named characters, jaded investigators and a plot which moves quickly, and yet not at all. There's a tired Faulkner quote about the nature of "the past" that needs no repetition here, and yet is beautifully imagined in this novel in the form of the wandering corpse of a disfigured black man finding its way into various grizzly murder scenes. This impossibly recurring black body among horrific scenes of castrated dead white men in Money, Mississippi baffle the incompetent and disturbed local authorities (whom might be most generously described as white trash), who must then yield authority to competent, yet undisturbed black state investigators. The author places the idea in our heads of the illusory terminal nature of death and the safe corner we call "the past" in which we irretrievably catalogue our collective sins. In the contrast of holding Trump-rallies in one hand and lived memories of lynched black people in the other we are called to jarringly examine a history that is not finished, but disturbingly alive and closer to us than we wish to contemplate.
These big ideas about the legacy of racial violence and the American history of lynching are handled deftly by the author through cold sardonic humour, outrageously funny dialogue and a surreal escalation of events. There are certain similarities here with Paul Beatty's outrageous satire: The Sellout. The Trees is a measure less absurd and not quite as funny as The Sellout but shares a high-minded furious subtext, working in comedy and metaphor to form a picture ambiguous enough to escape didacticism, and yet pointed, uncomfortable and eternally relevant.
The prose itself is nothing all that remarkable, lacking any distinguished style from either hardboiled fiction writers or the charm of prominent satirists; with the exception of two moments of sobering, haunting textual brilliance. A chapter is dedicated to a list of named and sometimes unnamed victims of racial violence. How easy it would be to bore a reader with such a monotonous tabulation and yet this is the most affecting moment of the novel, where no hint of humour is suggested. A reader might recognize the odd name here, be it more famous cases like Leo Frank or one of the endless victims of contemporary lynchings (clinically hiding behind the disingenuous euphemism of "regrettable police shootings"); but more haunting than these are the scores and scores of names which provoke no memory at all in the reader - all these unremembered disembodied unique names, and not an exhaustive list at that, in which the reader can only imagine the terror and indignity of their final moments on earth.
The final third of the novel careens uncontrollably into something far stranger and wider in scope than a series of Mississippian murders (and copycats), idiotic, incoherent, impoverished and incapable racist relics and the spectre of one Emmett Till. Things get positively Weird. A few readers might lose heart in how the careful plot and investigators seem to fall away as the novel sheds its detective trappings into the surreal. But before things can go entirely off the rails, the author reels everything back in at the very end in a thought-provoking final chapter. This is a satire, and elements of revenge-fantasy pastiche are adopted (who doesn't have a dark chuckle at the idea of lynching the lynchers?). But where something like The Sellout manages to rise far beyond gleeful, bloody irony, The Trees doesn't quite manage this. While entertaining, incredibly funny and thought-provoking, the story and satire don't quite come together as well as one would hope; the detective story and its protagonists ends up being more misdirection than a complementary aspect to a novel having grown well beyond those confines.
These big ideas about the legacy of racial violence and the American history of lynching are handled deftly by the author through cold sardonic humour, outrageously funny dialogue and a surreal escalation of events. There are certain similarities here with Paul Beatty's outrageous satire: The Sellout. The Trees is a measure less absurd and not quite as funny as The Sellout but shares a high-minded furious subtext, working in comedy and metaphor to form a picture ambiguous enough to escape didacticism, and yet pointed, uncomfortable and eternally relevant.
The prose itself is nothing all that remarkable, lacking any distinguished style from either hardboiled fiction writers or the charm of prominent satirists; with the exception of two moments of sobering, haunting textual brilliance. A chapter is dedicated to a list of named and sometimes unnamed victims of racial violence. How easy it would be to bore a reader with such a monotonous tabulation and yet this is the most affecting moment of the novel, where no hint of humour is suggested. A reader might recognize the odd name here, be it more famous cases like Leo Frank or one of the endless victims of contemporary lynchings (clinically hiding behind the disingenuous euphemism of "regrettable police shootings"); but more haunting than these are the scores and scores of names which provoke no memory at all in the reader - all these unremembered disembodied unique names, and not an exhaustive list at that, in which the reader can only imagine the terror and indignity of their final moments on earth.
The final third of the novel careens uncontrollably into something far stranger and wider in scope than a series of Mississippian murders (and copycats), idiotic, incoherent, impoverished and incapable racist relics and the spectre of one Emmett Till. Things get positively Weird. A few readers might lose heart in how the careful plot and investigators seem to fall away as the novel sheds its detective trappings into the surreal. But before things can go entirely off the rails, the author reels everything back in at the very end in a thought-provoking final chapter. This is a satire, and elements of revenge-fantasy pastiche are adopted (who doesn't have a dark chuckle at the idea of lynching the lynchers?). But where something like The Sellout manages to rise far beyond gleeful, bloody irony, The Trees doesn't quite manage this. While entertaining, incredibly funny and thought-provoking, the story and satire don't quite come together as well as one would hope; the detective story and its protagonists ends up being more misdirection than a complementary aspect to a novel having grown well beyond those confines.
informative
inspiring
medium-paced
The Ministry for the Future starts with an absolute banger of an introduction - a harrowing chapter in which the reader is invited into the mind of the proverbial frog slowly roasting away in the pot of hot water. A dramatic, in-your-face, acute consequence of the general problem the author wishes to tackle over the course of some 500 pages or 20-hours of audio. Unfortunately the novel is never able to reach the heights of its introductory chapter again. This book, not unlike World War Z, is a semi-epistolic novel that branches out to a myriad of character perspectives over the course of many decades, most being relatively isolated vignettes describing the undertakings of the next forty odd years of human civilization on Earth. It is reductive to say this is a book about climate change, unless we are to admit that no book in the future can truly be about anything but climate change - so expansive, pervasive and inescapable is such a topic that the epistolary form works very well here. This book can tentatively be said to take the position of a climate optimist, and so it has its work cut out for it, given that I imagine the readership shares a general nihilistic perspective as it comes to the state of climate-change efforts.
To its credit, this book admits no silver bullet, no grand technological leap-ahead (no sudden appearance of industrial-scale fusion, or revolutionary energy storage, etc.) and no single global cataclysm in which to work out the problem of climate change. Instead it is refreshingly more intellectually honest, writing widely about a plethora of independent efforts, so varied that they form an entire portrait of a future civilization. Some of these vignettes are more convincing than others; some require somewhat implausible impetuses (a forced drawdown of beef consumption, the crippling of commercial aviation and maritime trade), but together they successfully describe the holistic nature of the problem and solutions facing climate-change. One particular fascination of the book is surrounding the role of global financial system (and neoliberalism at large) in inducing new paths towards sustainable living. The suggested approach is not entirely convincing, though at the very least the prolonged focus sheds light on a far under-appreciated and utterly crucial subject for any realistic global climate relief effort.
Interluding these various chapters from many different walks of life, jumping forward and backwards across the years, are a few Wikipedia-style pop-history article summaries in which a higher lens is applied over a wider scale of time to address similar subject matter. This comes onto the fatal problem with this novel: the non-linearity in this specific book breaks the necessary causality to fully understand climate-change solutions, their challenges and outcomes. The amount of radical societal change that the book describes is so wrought with inevitable pushback and wild unstoppable aftereffects - and consistently, the book will wind down a chapter just as a specific solution has been described and begun implementation. Then it will later reference it in some form, perhaps a dozen or so chapters later, tidily summarizing how it went off (usually without a hitch). But the reader never gets to see this. In that way the book takes the easy way out, dancing from one radical but realistic proposal and change to the next, dazzling the reader in hope and practical solutions and painting a picture of deeply-described efforts and vaguely-referenced positive outcomes.
Much of this becomes difficult to buy because of the sole narrative strand this book uses as the scaffolding of plot: a woman named Mary who leads the Ministry for the Future (an idea which is more radical than its name suggests). It makes sense to centralize the narrative strand of the book on a character and organization that has its fingers in every pie and is afforded great agency and insight into various efforts. However she is a rich bureaucrat living in Switzerland; through her, and her surrounding insulated and affluent Zurich environs, the reader is privy to none of the vast transformations of society: the shortage of commodities and basic goods as global trade grinds to a halt, the collapse of wide swaths of tourist-based economies as commercial aviation becomes all but impossible, a systematic collapse of banks across the world and the global loss of faith in fiat currency... To all of this, our relatively well-off protagonist is impervious and so the book constantly hints at the ongoing radical transformations of society without actually depicting them at all.
This is not a problem that can be overlooked, as the main aim of the book can't rise above this. Despite it all, there are some interesting moments to commend it: the life of a refugee, spent almost exclusively behind camp walls, and the journey of Frank, the secondary protagonist, whose trauma is interestingly expanded on and depicted, but whose eventual interactions with Mary (in what are the longest chapters of the book) lose all sense of reason and become too didactic and unsubtle to stomach (not helped by the truly awful and elongated American-accent used by the Irish narrator in these chapters).
The book raises interesting questions and maintains an illusion of a realistic society dedicated to the preservation of the earth, but fails to truly commit to showing the radical outcomes to radical efforts.
To its credit, this book admits no silver bullet, no grand technological leap-ahead (no sudden appearance of industrial-scale fusion, or revolutionary energy storage, etc.) and no single global cataclysm in which to work out the problem of climate change. Instead it is refreshingly more intellectually honest, writing widely about a plethora of independent efforts, so varied that they form an entire portrait of a future civilization. Some of these vignettes are more convincing than others; some require somewhat implausible impetuses (a forced drawdown of beef consumption, the crippling of commercial aviation and maritime trade), but together they successfully describe the holistic nature of the problem and solutions facing climate-change. One particular fascination of the book is surrounding the role of global financial system (and neoliberalism at large) in inducing new paths towards sustainable living. The suggested approach is not entirely convincing, though at the very least the prolonged focus sheds light on a far under-appreciated and utterly crucial subject for any realistic global climate relief effort.
Interluding these various chapters from many different walks of life, jumping forward and backwards across the years, are a few Wikipedia-style pop-history article summaries in which a higher lens is applied over a wider scale of time to address similar subject matter. This comes onto the fatal problem with this novel: the non-linearity in this specific book breaks the necessary causality to fully understand climate-change solutions, their challenges and outcomes. The amount of radical societal change that the book describes is so wrought with inevitable pushback and wild unstoppable aftereffects - and consistently, the book will wind down a chapter just as a specific solution has been described and begun implementation. Then it will later reference it in some form, perhaps a dozen or so chapters later, tidily summarizing how it went off (usually without a hitch). But the reader never gets to see this. In that way the book takes the easy way out, dancing from one radical but realistic proposal and change to the next, dazzling the reader in hope and practical solutions and painting a picture of deeply-described efforts and vaguely-referenced positive outcomes.
Much of this becomes difficult to buy because of the sole narrative strand this book uses as the scaffolding of plot: a woman named Mary who leads the Ministry for the Future (an idea which is more radical than its name suggests). It makes sense to centralize the narrative strand of the book on a character and organization that has its fingers in every pie and is afforded great agency and insight into various efforts. However she is a rich bureaucrat living in Switzerland; through her, and her surrounding insulated and affluent Zurich environs, the reader is privy to none of the vast transformations of society: the shortage of commodities and basic goods as global trade grinds to a halt, the collapse of wide swaths of tourist-based economies as commercial aviation becomes all but impossible, a systematic collapse of banks across the world and the global loss of faith in fiat currency... To all of this, our relatively well-off protagonist is impervious and so the book constantly hints at the ongoing radical transformations of society without actually depicting them at all.
This is not a problem that can be overlooked, as the main aim of the book can't rise above this. Despite it all, there are some interesting moments to commend it: the life of a refugee, spent almost exclusively behind camp walls, and the journey of Frank, the secondary protagonist, whose trauma is interestingly expanded on and depicted, but whose eventual interactions with Mary (in what are the longest chapters of the book) lose all sense of reason and become too didactic and unsubtle to stomach (not helped by the truly awful and elongated American-accent used by the Irish narrator in these chapters).
The book raises interesting questions and maintains an illusion of a realistic society dedicated to the preservation of the earth, but fails to truly commit to showing the radical outcomes to radical efforts.