Take a photo of a barcode or cover
chrisssl 's review for:
The Ministry for the Future
by Kim Stanley Robinson
informative
inspiring
medium-paced
The Ministry for the Future starts with an absolute banger of an introduction - a harrowing chapter in which the reader is invited into the mind of the proverbial frog slowly roasting away in the pot of hot water. A dramatic, in-your-face, acute consequence of the general problem the author wishes to tackle over the course of some 500 pages or 20-hours of audio. Unfortunately the novel is never able to reach the heights of its introductory chapter again. This book, not unlike World War Z, is a semi-epistolic novel that branches out to a myriad of character perspectives over the course of many decades, most being relatively isolated vignettes describing the undertakings of the next forty odd years of human civilization on Earth. It is reductive to say this is a book about climate change, unless we are to admit that no book in the future can truly be about anything but climate change - so expansive, pervasive and inescapable is such a topic that the epistolary form works very well here. This book can tentatively be said to take the position of a climate optimist, and so it has its work cut out for it, given that I imagine the readership shares a general nihilistic perspective as it comes to the state of climate-change efforts.
To its credit, this book admits no silver bullet, no grand technological leap-ahead (no sudden appearance of industrial-scale fusion, or revolutionary energy storage, etc.) and no single global cataclysm in which to work out the problem of climate change. Instead it is refreshingly more intellectually honest, writing widely about a plethora of independent efforts, so varied that they form an entire portrait of a future civilization. Some of these vignettes are more convincing than others; some require somewhat implausible impetuses (a forced drawdown of beef consumption, the crippling of commercial aviation and maritime trade), but together they successfully describe the holistic nature of the problem and solutions facing climate-change. One particular fascination of the book is surrounding the role of global financial system (and neoliberalism at large) in inducing new paths towards sustainable living. The suggested approach is not entirely convincing, though at the very least the prolonged focus sheds light on a far under-appreciated and utterly crucial subject for any realistic global climate relief effort.
Interluding these various chapters from many different walks of life, jumping forward and backwards across the years, are a few Wikipedia-style pop-history article summaries in which a higher lens is applied over a wider scale of time to address similar subject matter. This comes onto the fatal problem with this novel: the non-linearity in this specific book breaks the necessary causality to fully understand climate-change solutions, their challenges and outcomes. The amount of radical societal change that the book describes is so wrought with inevitable pushback and wild unstoppable aftereffects - and consistently, the book will wind down a chapter just as a specific solution has been described and begun implementation. Then it will later reference it in some form, perhaps a dozen or so chapters later, tidily summarizing how it went off (usually without a hitch). But the reader never gets to see this. In that way the book takes the easy way out, dancing from one radical but realistic proposal and change to the next, dazzling the reader in hope and practical solutions and painting a picture of deeply-described efforts and vaguely-referenced positive outcomes.
Much of this becomes difficult to buy because of the sole narrative strand this book uses as the scaffolding of plot: a woman named Mary who leads the Ministry for the Future (an idea which is more radical than its name suggests). It makes sense to centralize the narrative strand of the book on a character and organization that has its fingers in every pie and is afforded great agency and insight into various efforts. However she is a rich bureaucrat living in Switzerland; through her, and her surrounding insulated and affluent Zurich environs, the reader is privy to none of the vast transformations of society: the shortage of commodities and basic goods as global trade grinds to a halt, the collapse of wide swaths of tourist-based economies as commercial aviation becomes all but impossible, a systematic collapse of banks across the world and the global loss of faith in fiat currency... To all of this, our relatively well-off protagonist is impervious and so the book constantly hints at the ongoing radical transformations of society without actually depicting them at all.
This is not a problem that can be overlooked, as the main aim of the book can't rise above this. Despite it all, there are some interesting moments to commend it: the life of a refugee, spent almost exclusively behind camp walls, and the journey of Frank, the secondary protagonist, whose trauma is interestingly expanded on and depicted, but whose eventual interactions with Mary (in what are the longest chapters of the book) lose all sense of reason and become too didactic and unsubtle to stomach (not helped by the truly awful and elongated American-accent used by the Irish narrator in these chapters).
The book raises interesting questions and maintains an illusion of a realistic society dedicated to the preservation of the earth, but fails to truly commit to showing the radical outcomes to radical efforts.
To its credit, this book admits no silver bullet, no grand technological leap-ahead (no sudden appearance of industrial-scale fusion, or revolutionary energy storage, etc.) and no single global cataclysm in which to work out the problem of climate change. Instead it is refreshingly more intellectually honest, writing widely about a plethora of independent efforts, so varied that they form an entire portrait of a future civilization. Some of these vignettes are more convincing than others; some require somewhat implausible impetuses (a forced drawdown of beef consumption, the crippling of commercial aviation and maritime trade), but together they successfully describe the holistic nature of the problem and solutions facing climate-change. One particular fascination of the book is surrounding the role of global financial system (and neoliberalism at large) in inducing new paths towards sustainable living. The suggested approach is not entirely convincing, though at the very least the prolonged focus sheds light on a far under-appreciated and utterly crucial subject for any realistic global climate relief effort.
Interluding these various chapters from many different walks of life, jumping forward and backwards across the years, are a few Wikipedia-style pop-history article summaries in which a higher lens is applied over a wider scale of time to address similar subject matter. This comes onto the fatal problem with this novel: the non-linearity in this specific book breaks the necessary causality to fully understand climate-change solutions, their challenges and outcomes. The amount of radical societal change that the book describes is so wrought with inevitable pushback and wild unstoppable aftereffects - and consistently, the book will wind down a chapter just as a specific solution has been described and begun implementation. Then it will later reference it in some form, perhaps a dozen or so chapters later, tidily summarizing how it went off (usually without a hitch). But the reader never gets to see this. In that way the book takes the easy way out, dancing from one radical but realistic proposal and change to the next, dazzling the reader in hope and practical solutions and painting a picture of deeply-described efforts and vaguely-referenced positive outcomes.
Much of this becomes difficult to buy because of the sole narrative strand this book uses as the scaffolding of plot: a woman named Mary who leads the Ministry for the Future (an idea which is more radical than its name suggests). It makes sense to centralize the narrative strand of the book on a character and organization that has its fingers in every pie and is afforded great agency and insight into various efforts. However she is a rich bureaucrat living in Switzerland; through her, and her surrounding insulated and affluent Zurich environs, the reader is privy to none of the vast transformations of society: the shortage of commodities and basic goods as global trade grinds to a halt, the collapse of wide swaths of tourist-based economies as commercial aviation becomes all but impossible, a systematic collapse of banks across the world and the global loss of faith in fiat currency... To all of this, our relatively well-off protagonist is impervious and so the book constantly hints at the ongoing radical transformations of society without actually depicting them at all.
This is not a problem that can be overlooked, as the main aim of the book can't rise above this. Despite it all, there are some interesting moments to commend it: the life of a refugee, spent almost exclusively behind camp walls, and the journey of Frank, the secondary protagonist, whose trauma is interestingly expanded on and depicted, but whose eventual interactions with Mary (in what are the longest chapters of the book) lose all sense of reason and become too didactic and unsubtle to stomach (not helped by the truly awful and elongated American-accent used by the Irish narrator in these chapters).
The book raises interesting questions and maintains an illusion of a realistic society dedicated to the preservation of the earth, but fails to truly commit to showing the radical outcomes to radical efforts.