chrisssl 's review for:

The Trees by Percival Everett
3.5
dark funny mysterious fast-paced

The Trees is a brisk novel chock-full of the darkest humour that temporarily assumes the form of a detective thriller - complete with zany peculiarly named characters, jaded investigators and a plot which moves quickly, and yet not at all.  There's a tired Faulkner quote about the nature of "the past" that needs no repetition here, and yet is beautifully imagined in this novel in the form of the wandering corpse of a disfigured black man finding its way into various grizzly murder scenes.  This impossibly recurring black body among horrific scenes of castrated dead white men in Money, Mississippi baffle the incompetent and disturbed local authorities (whom might be most generously described as white trash), who must then yield authority to competent, yet undisturbed black state investigators.  The author places the idea in our heads of the illusory terminal nature of death and the safe corner we call "the past" in which we irretrievably catalogue our collective sins.  In the contrast of holding Trump-rallies in one hand and lived memories of lynched black people in the other we are called to jarringly examine a history that is not finished, but disturbingly alive and closer to us than we wish to contemplate.

These big ideas about the legacy of racial violence and the American history of lynching are handled deftly by the author through cold sardonic humour, outrageously funny dialogue and a surreal escalation of events.  There are certain similarities here with Paul Beatty's outrageous satire: The Sellout.  The Trees is a measure less absurd and not quite as funny as The Sellout but shares a high-minded furious subtext, working in comedy and metaphor to form a picture ambiguous enough to escape didacticism, and yet pointed, uncomfortable and eternally relevant.

The prose itself is nothing all that remarkable, lacking any distinguished style from either hardboiled fiction writers or the charm of prominent satirists; with the exception of two moments of sobering, haunting textual brilliance.  A chapter is dedicated to a list of named and sometimes unnamed victims of racial violence.  How easy it would be to bore a reader with such a monotonous tabulation and yet this is the most affecting moment of the novel, where no hint of humour is suggested.  A reader might recognize the odd name here, be it more famous cases like Leo Frank or one of the endless victims of contemporary lynchings (clinically hiding behind the disingenuous euphemism of "regrettable police shootings"); but more haunting than these are the scores and scores of names which provoke no memory at all in the reader - all these unremembered disembodied unique names, and not an exhaustive list at that, in which the reader can only imagine the terror and indignity of their final moments on earth.

The final third of the novel careens uncontrollably into something far stranger and wider in scope than a series of Mississippian murders (and copycats), idiotic, incoherent, impoverished and incapable racist relics and the spectre of one Emmett Till.  Things get positively Weird.  A few readers might lose heart in how the careful plot and investigators seem to fall away as the novel sheds its detective trappings into the surreal.  But before things can go entirely off the rails, the author reels everything back in at the very end in a thought-provoking final chapter.  This is a satire, and elements of revenge-fantasy pastiche are adopted (who doesn't have a dark chuckle at the idea of lynching the lynchers?).  But where something like The Sellout manages to rise far beyond gleeful, bloody irony, The Trees doesn't quite manage this.  While entertaining, incredibly funny and thought-provoking, the story and satire don't quite come together as well as one would hope; the detective story and its protagonists ends up being more misdirection than a complementary aspect to a novel having grown well beyond those confines.