birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Long Island Compromise by Taffy Brodesser-Akner
2.0
challenging slow-paced

Well! That was a journey. I feel like I dragged myself by my fingernails through the last of it but I’m here! It’s completed!! But at what cost?!

Long Island Compromise was a constant compromise with myself, we negotiated and I didn’t DNF but it never redeemed itself either, so joke’s on me! The ending to this book is the most maddening thing I’ve ever read. Why have such shitty unlikeable characters if you’re not going to give them any growth or redeem them in anyway?! The women in this book were all the worst caricatures of Jewish matriarchs I’ve encountered in awhile and the adult children, our main characters, are all reduced to one quality—depraved Beamer, Anxious Nathan and Self-flagellating Jenny. They were all the worst and not in a “haha look at these rich people behaving badly fun sort of way” but an “ew look at these rich people behaving badly for 464 pages but learning almost nothing sort of way.” Yikes.

These are the children of Carl—he was kidnapped in their childhood and then returned with unattended trauma and the book is about how that trauma has been passed down to each of them. They are the Fletchers, a rich Jewish family in a wealthy suburb who own a styrofoam factory and we interrogate how their wealth has or hasn’t insulated or helped them. I dunno, there’s a lot going on here that’s good—capitalism, inheritance, family history and secrets, the trappings of wealth, what the rich do to hang on to it, entitlement, yadda yadda yadda but I absolutely could not enjoy any of it because these characters were just so freaking insufferable. Beamer in particular, who unfortunately we start out with, is a sex/drug addict who we spend waaaay too much time with as he spirals out of control and hits every gross rung on the way down. Nathan was anxious and his anxiety was palpable but that was more annoying than anything and Jenny was just ugh the worst somehow because she didn’t want her wealth and struggles against it but doesn’t seem to do any good either, just kinda floats there unsure who or what to blame. Eye rolllllll. This was just such a tedious read but I read it. So yay for me? Gold star!⭐️ 🙄

Audiobook gifted through the Librofm influencer program in exchange for my honest review.