Take a photo of a barcode or cover
328 reviews by:
birdykinsreads
dark
slow-paced
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
This was such a slog. Multiple times I wanted to abandon it but I kept thinking it would get going after the next chapter, or the next, or the next. Sadly, it just existed in that stasis the whole time—right on the cusp of something gripping happening but never quite delivering.
I liked the setting, a girls’ boarding school, and a misfit with mental health struggles arriving and immediately falling into a high-stakes rivalry with popular mean girls. But, I found the characters pretty shallow and the depiction of Sarah’s bipolar disorder just, kinda off somehow? This book also played pretty fast and loose with suicidal ideation so I’d watch out for that if it’s a trigger for you.
I’m not sure if it was the pace, writing, overall staleness or a problem with my own attention to detail but I struggled to follow what was happening sometimes and didn’t care to figure it out.
A big meh.😑
I liked the setting, a girls’ boarding school, and a misfit with mental health struggles arriving and immediately falling into a high-stakes rivalry with popular mean girls. But, I found the characters pretty shallow and the depiction of Sarah’s bipolar disorder just, kinda off somehow? This book also played pretty fast and loose with suicidal ideation so I’d watch out for that if it’s a trigger for you.
I’m not sure if it was the pace, writing, overall staleness or a problem with my own attention to detail but I struggled to follow what was happening sometimes and didn’t care to figure it out.
A big meh.😑
Graphic: Suicidal thoughts
A solid collection of poems with such a distinctive voice. Melding serious topics with more lighthearted pop culture references, sometimes merging the two in unexpected ways. Tiana Clark is new to me and I'll definitely be looking up more of her work in the future.
My thanks to Netgalley and Atria & Washington Square Books for the review ebook.
My thanks to Netgalley and Atria & Washington Square Books for the review ebook.
mysterious
slow-paced
From rough beginning to slow as molasses middle all the way to anticlimactic end, I just couldn’t see the point of any of this.
I can’t really understand why Jean Hanff Korelitz revisited this story if she only planned to biff it on the ground and rub dirt in its face. The Plot was so good! Like all the unnecessary Hollywood remakes and sequels why couldn’t she just leave well enough alone?!
All the cleverness and intrigue of The Plot (a struggling writer steals the main idea for his successful book from a student he taught who dies without publishing) was really lost with The Sequel. This one follows his wife Anna and she’s just the worst, boring and predictable. A whole lot of nonsense happens and I didn’t enjoy any of it. Every few pages I kept asking why—why is this character so uninteresting when she really should be riveting? Why are we here? Why isn’t it getting any better as we go? Why did I bother finishing it? Why why why?
This whole book was a lesson in restraint and why we need more of it. I’m sad, I was really looking forward to this one.
My thanks to NetGalley and Celadon Books for the ebook in exchange for my honest review.
I can’t really understand why Jean Hanff Korelitz revisited this story if she only planned to biff it on the ground and rub dirt in its face. The Plot was so good! Like all the unnecessary Hollywood remakes and sequels why couldn’t she just leave well enough alone?!
All the cleverness and intrigue of The Plot (a struggling writer steals the main idea for his successful book from a student he taught who dies without publishing) was really lost with The Sequel. This one follows his wife Anna and she’s just the worst, boring and predictable. A whole lot of nonsense happens and I didn’t enjoy any of it. Every few pages I kept asking why—why is this character so uninteresting when she really should be riveting? Why are we here? Why isn’t it getting any better as we go? Why did I bother finishing it? Why why why?
This whole book was a lesson in restraint and why we need more of it. I’m sad, I was really looking forward to this one.
My thanks to NetGalley and Celadon Books for the ebook in exchange for my honest review.
slow-paced
Reading this felt a little bit like having an old man chat nonsense at you on the bus. Does some of it start like it's going to sound wise, moving and profound? Sure, but then he starts clucking like a chicken and the moment's passed.
(Yes, there are actually chicken clucks in these poems).
Observational, pondering, aimless-feeling poems that really didn't strike me in any particular way except for how I wasn't really enjoying the company and was ready to move seats and be away with it.
My thanks to Netgalley and Random House for the ebook in exchange for my honest review.
(Yes, there are actually chicken clucks in these poems).
Observational, pondering, aimless-feeling poems that really didn't strike me in any particular way except for how I wasn't really enjoying the company and was ready to move seats and be away with it.
My thanks to Netgalley and Random House for the ebook in exchange for my honest review.
funny
lighthearted
relaxing
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
Utterly and completely charming. I was smiling and kicking my feet through the entire audio production, it was so beautifully narrated, humour and emotion injected into every sentence. I feel like Samara MacLaren took a great book and in her narration made it exceptional. Truly, feel like I’d have missed some of the magic without her.
The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches is about Mika Moon, who is a witch who has been living a quiet, if lonely and isolated life in accordance with local covenant rules to minimize risk by not gathering together. When she receives a request to be a tutor for 3 young witches, from an odd mishmash of a family and promptly upends her life with interest, intrigue, and of course, a very handsome grumpy man.
I loved the low stakes cozy mystery and the world Sangu Mandanna built here. The way she describes magic as a mischievous puppy, the spells and how they worked and of course the lovely characters of all races, ethnicities and sexualities was a breath of fresh air in the cozy fantasy realm. Truly such a joy to read that I’m crushed to realize it’s not a series like I thought it was!!
I need more Sangu!!! Please! Immediately!!
The Very Secret Society of Irregular Witches is about Mika Moon, who is a witch who has been living a quiet, if lonely and isolated life in accordance with local covenant rules to minimize risk by not gathering together. When she receives a request to be a tutor for 3 young witches, from an odd mishmash of a family and promptly upends her life with interest, intrigue, and of course, a very handsome grumpy man.
I loved the low stakes cozy mystery and the world Sangu Mandanna built here. The way she describes magic as a mischievous puppy, the spells and how they worked and of course the lovely characters of all races, ethnicities and sexualities was a breath of fresh air in the cozy fantasy realm. Truly such a joy to read that I’m crushed to realize it’s not a series like I thought it was!!
I need more Sangu!!! Please! Immediately!!
dark
mysterious
slow-paced
On the spectrum of weird girl wellness reads (Natural Beauty at the top, obviously) this one doesn’t really compete, but I didn’t mind reading it, if that makes sense. It’s still enjoyable!
Girl gets job at wellness brand and discovers something sinister in the product. It’s been done better, for sure, but there was something fairly believable about this one despite the plot being overly convenient in multiple places. I liked the workplace setting and dynamics, the insidious way face-famous brands and their mandates can almost indoctrinate you. The cult of beauty. I’ll never get tired of reading these types of stories, but I think if this one had stayed more realistic and grounded instead of losing the plot a bit at the end and verging a little wildly whodunnit then it would have carved its own niche in the space.
Still, pretty good! Fine! Not deserving of the totally negative reviews I’ve been seeing this year. I’d say if you’ve wanted to read it, don’t let them deter you!
My thanks to @soho_press for the #gifted copy in exchange for my honest review.
Girl gets job at wellness brand and discovers something sinister in the product. It’s been done better, for sure, but there was something fairly believable about this one despite the plot being overly convenient in multiple places. I liked the workplace setting and dynamics, the insidious way face-famous brands and their mandates can almost indoctrinate you. The cult of beauty. I’ll never get tired of reading these types of stories, but I think if this one had stayed more realistic and grounded instead of losing the plot a bit at the end and verging a little wildly whodunnit then it would have carved its own niche in the space.
Still, pretty good! Fine! Not deserving of the totally negative reviews I’ve been seeing this year. I’d say if you’ve wanted to read it, don’t let them deter you!
My thanks to @soho_press for the #gifted copy in exchange for my honest review.
emotional
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
Diverse cast of characters:
Yes
I just love reading Nikki May’s messy but relatable characters. I really enjoyed Wahala and this reimagining of Jane Austen’s Mansfield Park hit the same tonal note while dipping deeper into classism, colourism and the different ways Nigeria and England can feel both stifling and home for cousins Funke and Liv and the way their fraught familial relationships affect how they see themselves and where they live.
I love Jane Austen, but I haven’t read Mansfield Park yet I don’t think, so I’m not sure how faithful this decolonial retelling stays to the plot but I enjoyed the melodramatic twists and turns and the audiobook narration was perfection.
I think this would have been a 5 star read for me if the miscommunication and trusting of clearly distrustful characters weren’t such a crux of the narrative. But, that’s typical Jane Austen so it could be classic Mansfield Park shinning through.
Truly I just love Nikki May, her books are thoughtful and working through difficult subjects sometimes but deeply FUN and don’t get too bogged down in seriousness, despite the serious nature of things… if that makes sense. I love how she does that, how easy it is to get swept up in her stories. One of my favourite authors for sure!
My thanks to @librofm and @harperaudio for the audiobook in exchange for my honest review.
I love Jane Austen, but I haven’t read Mansfield Park yet I don’t think, so I’m not sure how faithful this decolonial retelling stays to the plot but I enjoyed the melodramatic twists and turns and the audiobook narration was perfection.
I think this would have been a 5 star read for me if the miscommunication and trusting of clearly distrustful characters weren’t such a crux of the narrative. But, that’s typical Jane Austen so it could be classic Mansfield Park shinning through.
Truly I just love Nikki May, her books are thoughtful and working through difficult subjects sometimes but deeply FUN and don’t get too bogged down in seriousness, despite the serious nature of things… if that makes sense. I love how she does that, how easy it is to get swept up in her stories. One of my favourite authors for sure!
My thanks to @librofm and @harperaudio for the audiobook in exchange for my honest review.
reflective
slow-paced
We did high tea at @fawnresto for this month’s bookclub, @amandajuli3n’s pick was Maggie O’Farrell and it was a little polarizing but I think those who liked it really liked it and those who didn’t were just haterzzz (jk, points were for sure made, among them the slowness, plot spoiling (aka “dear reader this happens” before it happens), the hateable characters and the surplus of POVs). But we all agreed that O’Farrell is a beautiful and talented writer even if this particular book wasn’t for everyone.
Personally, I was in the really liked it category. I rated this one 4⭐️s and honestly I might have gone higher if I was more in the mood for meandering litfic. I did find I liked the beginning and the end more than the middle, it dragged for me too—I wish that it had been cut down a bit, there were certain POVs and characters that seemed a little superfluous but overall her writing was wonderful and I don’t mind some unlikeable characters as long as they make me feel something! Also, narratives about people just struggling to make their marriages work always appeal to me.
And so another season of bookclub concludes! Next meeting will mark our 20th book! Which is wiiiiiiild. Love bookclub love these ladies. Love high tea! 🫖
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced