Take a photo of a barcode or cover
birdykinsreads 's review for:
Tress of the Emerald Sea
by Brandon Sanderson
adventurous
lighthearted
slow-paced
No hate to Brandon Sanderson but Bookclub was not the biggest fan of his book… 😬 this takes the crown as our lowest rated book yet with a sad average of 2.65 stars… me, I skewed it lower too because I was not a fan! I rated it 2.
Tress of the Emerald Sea is a Princess Bride retelling, originally made to cater to Sanderson superfans, probably not the best intro to his work. Tress loses her beau and decides to do anything to save him, including becoming a pirate on a ship sailing through the dangerous aether oceans, seas made up of spores that react to water in wild and unexpected ways. There’s also a dragon, a sorcerer and a talking rat. Silly and whimsical, but unfortunately in a trying way too hard and not quite hitting the mark sort of way.
We all had pretty much the same issues with it—despite everyone agreeing there was fun imagination at play and great world building, we all found the narrator absolutely annoying as hell and his tendency to break the 4th wall and talk to the reader jarring and bad. Closing in at almost 400 pages this was just too long with too much time sailing on a boat with not a lot of action in-between to break it up which just got boring after a while.
On the whole, the plot was overly convenient and the ending pretty anticlimactic. But, several us really liked main character Tress and we all thought the aether oceans were pretty cool. As someone who loves the Princess Bride, this missed the mark of that for tone, I was picturing the Paperbag Princess the whole time instead. It felt like middle grade fiction to me, and if it was marketed as that it would be great, but as YA or Adult Fantasy (which was where it was in my bookstore), I expected more from it.
I was deep in a reading slump when I read this so that probably didn’t help either, in fact it felt like it kicked me down deeper and threw a pile of dirt on my face to boot.
I will give his high fantasy a go though…
Tress of the Emerald Sea is a Princess Bride retelling, originally made to cater to Sanderson superfans, probably not the best intro to his work. Tress loses her beau and decides to do anything to save him, including becoming a pirate on a ship sailing through the dangerous aether oceans, seas made up of spores that react to water in wild and unexpected ways. There’s also a dragon, a sorcerer and a talking rat. Silly and whimsical, but unfortunately in a trying way too hard and not quite hitting the mark sort of way.
We all had pretty much the same issues with it—despite everyone agreeing there was fun imagination at play and great world building, we all found the narrator absolutely annoying as hell and his tendency to break the 4th wall and talk to the reader jarring and bad. Closing in at almost 400 pages this was just too long with too much time sailing on a boat with not a lot of action in-between to break it up which just got boring after a while.
On the whole, the plot was overly convenient and the ending pretty anticlimactic. But, several us really liked main character Tress and we all thought the aether oceans were pretty cool. As someone who loves the Princess Bride, this missed the mark of that for tone, I was picturing the Paperbag Princess the whole time instead. It felt like middle grade fiction to me, and if it was marketed as that it would be great, but as YA or Adult Fantasy (which was where it was in my bookstore), I expected more from it.
I was deep in a reading slump when I read this so that probably didn’t help either, in fact it felt like it kicked me down deeper and threw a pile of dirt on my face to boot.
I will give his high fantasy a go though…