328 reviews by:

birdykinsreads

Filter
challenging dark informative

In one of the most hilarious bookclub moments ever one of us read the wrong book! She did not enjoy Minka Kelly’s memoir but strangely it did have a lot of similarities to our actual bookclub pick—Tell Me Everything by Erika Krouse. (Which I finished reading in the driveway of our bookclub meeting before it started! Cutting it close!)

This is a memoir about Krouse’s foray into private investigation and her work gathering witnesses and information for a 2003 sexual harassment and assault case against a Colorado university and its football team. It’s also (and this was not disclosed on the back of the book or any of its marketing materials) about her own brutal sexual abuse as a young child by her father (she leaves him unnamed, only called X, but it’s pretty clearly and easily deciphered). Had I known this was also about child abuse I would not have opted to read it—it’s such a difficult and challenging read, and it’s a testament to Krouse’s ability as a writer that she kept me engaged anyway. 

This was such an interesting bookclub discussion—our resident hacker tracked down the real names and photos of everyone involved despite Krouse keeping things anonymous (ha!) and we were all in agreement that this was a really compelling read, even if Krouse seemed to be a product of her time and stated some sus information about sexual assault, etc as tho it was fact. (She was in her mid-30s during this case).

All in all I think the strongest part about this book was the case she was working on, and for me, her personal life and extremely toxic relationship with her awful mother and family was taking over a book that doesn’t even mention it on the back flap. It felt like a trojan horse of a book sometimes, tbh. 

Really good writing though, and I gave it 4 stars even though I felt like I was duped into reading a book I did not sign up for and really broke my heart. (I was not emotionally prepared for it!) This was a really highly rated one for bookclub—mostly 3-4 stars and a 5 star. I would recommend it but go in knowing what you’re getting.
challenging emotional informative inspiring reflective sad medium-paced

A poignant and achingly profound book of increasingly intertwined notes—thoughts gathered from a myriad of sources that each strike a chord alone and together to create such a powerful and deeply poetic collection of  musings on the ordinary and extraordinary facets of Black existence. 

Christina Sharpe grapples with both public and personal loss, grief, trauma and the epigenetic inheritance of it—from slavery to our current state of systemic racism a lot of people can’t even acknowledge exists—and how we interact with and participate in that every day.

It’s a beautiful, tender and quietly devastating work of art that I wish I could convince everyone to read.


Let me preface this by saying I love Issa Rae. Insecure is one of my top 5 favourite shows of all time. She is a creative genius. So if you’re also a fan I would be wary about reading her book of essays. I came out of this liking her less, for sure.

First off, she drops an Asian racial slur for what seems like just for funsies. I’m sorry, whut? This was published in 2016 and I’m just jaw dropped wondering how that was ok even then? Where is the editor? Being a minority does not give you an all access pass to the racial slur buffet, it just doesn’t!

From there, the essays just didn’t save this one. They just weren’t that funny or saying anything especially interesting or insightful, imo. The essay about her relationship with her hair was good, but it was kind of on its own out there. The book as a whole fell flat and I just didn’t really know where she was trying to go with it. Some of the things she said honestly felt a little debasing, weird, and out of touch. She presents herself as “awkward” but actually seems just a little unwilling to consider other peoples’ feelings and opinions which plays more purposefully blind/ignorant/privileged/kinda rude than awkward. 

Maybe, she was trying to be tongue-in-cheek and it just missed the mark. Maybe her type of humour and life-observation is just made for the screen. I’m not sure. 

Maybe I just didn’t get it… but I’m probably going to stick to watching her screen presence and tv projects and avoid anything she publishes in the future. 
adventurous challenging emotional slow-paced

I wanted to love this one, and it started out strong but somewhere around the midpoint I started to lose interest. Previously, I DNFed this one when I got to that spot but I was determined to finish this buddy read with @thebookybird and @a.book.well.spent this time, and I am glad I did, with some caveats.

Washington Black is a Bildungsroman about a young boy enslaved on a brutal plantation and the well-meaning abolitionist Titch who takes him on as an assistant and sends his life spinning on a trajectory I don’t think anyone could predict—from a flying machine to the Arctic, my home province Nova Scotia, diving in the sea, and all over the world. Falling in love somewhat unbelievably and designing the first ever aquarium show in the world. (Yes I’m also confused how we got here). This is why there’s an octopus on the cover, I guess.

This book was so beautifully written and sometimes that’s enough to carry me through, but here the plot felt very meandering, a bit random, and almost as if I was reading a different book for each of the four parts it was broken into. In the group chat I said it reminded me of a tv series (which it’s being adapted into) when the writers aren’t sure what to do for a season so throw all kinds of ideas at the wall to see what sticks, abandoning formed plot lines willynilly as they go. I thought it would maybe come together in the end in a cohesive way, but it just didn’t for me. And I found that a bit frustrating.

I am glad I read it, though. As it’s been on my tbr forever. I do recommend it for the writing alone (I’ll definitely read any future books Esi Edugyan cares to write) as long as you don’t need a super tight or logical plot to enjoy a book.
lighthearted

As I mentioned before, times do be tough, which means I’m looking for something lighthearted to warm my ol’ cynical heart up. 

Did this book solve all my problems like I expected it to? No. Fail. Minus 2 stars. Did it deliver some pretty likeable characters, a predictable love story and something just fine to warm the winter up with? Sure! 

The Magic All Around by Jennifer Moorman is about Mattie Russell, she’s just lost her mother, so she goes home to her family’s strange semi-sentient magical house in a small town (wait, Deja vu, are you having flashbacks to my last review for The Wonder State? Also featuring magical houses? I’m sensing a theme… but that’s where the similarities end). There, she realizes she could inherit a tidy sum of money if she’s willing to do a list of odd tasks dictated by her late mother. In doing so she meets a bunch of people who change her life for the better. 🙂 They’re alright, I guess, nothing THAT special imo. 😒 I’d still be moving to San Fran if it was up to me.

It’s a cute premise and I enjoyed it well enough. I feel like it was just missing something essential to make me truly feel warmed to the core. The narration was fine, but not great. And I’m still sad. So. 🙁 I’m going to need something with a little more magic in it. A little more fizzle. Some pizazz if you will.

What’s the most heartwarming book you’ve ever read?

adventurous

There’s something about a magical semi-sentient house that just gets me, you know? I love a search for a portal to another world. I love magic confined to houses operating in limited conditions and circumstance. I love a group of plucky teenage misfits coming together for adventure, wonder and belief. I love that group now grown, summoned back to the place that started it all—to answer for their youthful indiscretions, choices, promises… with maybe a murder mystery all wrapped up in it, too.

The Wonder State by Sara Flannery Murphy was such an unexpected surprise. I haven’t heard anything about it since it came out last summer, and I went in pretty much blind. This was just scratching all the right itches for me. At its heart, it’s about friendship, about appreciating the place you’re from in all its small and wondrous ways. It’s about the magic that might be right here, under our noses, if we just look for it… just believe. It’s about the way we want to love and protect our earliest friendships even if we can’t, don’t have the capacity to do the type of saving we wish we could. It’s about the people we are when we’re young and if the choices we make then will always keep us tethered to the people we were, and if leaving is ever really a true escape. 

I’m going through some stuff right now, and mentally I’m not totally present, but this book managed to hold my attention and be exactly the right kind of escapism that I needed at the time. Could the characters have been a bit more fleshed out? Maybe. Did things get tied up a bit too conveniently at the end? Sure. But, the end got me EMOTIONAL and I really enjoyed Flannery Murphy’s writing and will definitely read Girl One soon too, as that’s been on my tbr for the past year. I definitely recommend this one, and hope I see it getting some more love on here soon.
lighthearted relaxing slow-paced

A somewhat lighthearted approach to the Vietnamese-Canadian experience and gentrification of the neighbourhoods that families have built their lives in and can no longer afford.

Sunshine Nails is about one such messy family—a daughter who recently ended an engagement and left her job to move home, a son who is stuck in a dead end tech job with no social life, a father whose alcoholism and gambling habits have left their finances in a precarious position, and a proud gossipy mom who is struggling to keep up appearances and keep it all together—they own a nail salon in a currently up and coming neighbourhood when an upscale fancy wellness boutique chain decides to move in next door. From there, it’s a descent into madness as they all vainly attempt to hang on to their livelihood as hard as they can.

I really enjoyed the characters in this novel, they were bright and comedic, despite the real challenges they were facing. I do think the book lost its way a bit half way through and felt a little bit like it was scrambling to connect all the dots and bring it home cohesively. 

Still, it was a good read, and I enjoyed the dynamics and the premise even if I felt it could have done more, been more. I was a little surprised to see it on the Canada Reads 2024 long list though, tbh.