4.0
challenging dark informative

In one of the most hilarious bookclub moments ever one of us read the wrong book! She did not enjoy Minka Kelly’s memoir but strangely it did have a lot of similarities to our actual bookclub pick—Tell Me Everything by Erika Krouse. (Which I finished reading in the driveway of our bookclub meeting before it started! Cutting it close!)

This is a memoir about Krouse’s foray into private investigation and her work gathering witnesses and information for a 2003 sexual harassment and assault case against a Colorado university and its football team. It’s also (and this was not disclosed on the back of the book or any of its marketing materials) about her own brutal sexual abuse as a young child by her father (she leaves him unnamed, only called X, but it’s pretty clearly and easily deciphered). Had I known this was also about child abuse I would not have opted to read it—it’s such a difficult and challenging read, and it’s a testament to Krouse’s ability as a writer that she kept me engaged anyway. 

This was such an interesting bookclub discussion—our resident hacker tracked down the real names and photos of everyone involved despite Krouse keeping things anonymous (ha!) and we were all in agreement that this was a really compelling read, even if Krouse seemed to be a product of her time and stated some sus information about sexual assault, etc as tho it was fact. (She was in her mid-30s during this case).

All in all I think the strongest part about this book was the case she was working on, and for me, her personal life and extremely toxic relationship with her awful mother and family was taking over a book that doesn’t even mention it on the back flap. It felt like a trojan horse of a book sometimes, tbh. 

Really good writing though, and I gave it 4 stars even though I felt like I was duped into reading a book I did not sign up for and really broke my heart. (I was not emotionally prepared for it!) This was a really highly rated one for bookclub—mostly 3-4 stars and a 5 star. I would recommend it but go in knowing what you’re getting.