birdykinsreads's profile picture

birdykinsreads 's review for:

Washington Black by Esi Edugyan
3.5
adventurous challenging emotional slow-paced

I wanted to love this one, and it started out strong but somewhere around the midpoint I started to lose interest. Previously, I DNFed this one when I got to that spot but I was determined to finish this buddy read with @thebookybird and @a.book.well.spent this time, and I am glad I did, with some caveats.

Washington Black is a Bildungsroman about a young boy enslaved on a brutal plantation and the well-meaning abolitionist Titch who takes him on as an assistant and sends his life spinning on a trajectory I don’t think anyone could predict—from a flying machine to the Arctic, my home province Nova Scotia, diving in the sea, and all over the world. Falling in love somewhat unbelievably and designing the first ever aquarium show in the world. (Yes I’m also confused how we got here). This is why there’s an octopus on the cover, I guess.

This book was so beautifully written and sometimes that’s enough to carry me through, but here the plot felt very meandering, a bit random, and almost as if I was reading a different book for each of the four parts it was broken into. In the group chat I said it reminded me of a tv series (which it’s being adapted into) when the writers aren’t sure what to do for a season so throw all kinds of ideas at the wall to see what sticks, abandoning formed plot lines willynilly as they go. I thought it would maybe come together in the end in a cohesive way, but it just didn’t for me. And I found that a bit frustrating.

I am glad I read it, though. As it’s been on my tbr forever. I do recommend it for the writing alone (I’ll definitely read any future books Esi Edugyan cares to write) as long as you don’t need a super tight or logical plot to enjoy a book.