Take a photo of a barcode or cover
46 reviews by:
orcinus_olive
funny
hopeful
informative
inspiring
lighthearted
mysterious
reflective
relaxing
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Loveable characters:
Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
The side characters are rather flat, but overall they and everything else is really quite charming, especially Elle and the humor. Generally though, this volume works mostly as a setup. It appears that the plot will only really start heating up in the next volume.
adventurous
mysterious
reflective
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
Yes
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
tldr/summary:
There’s a nice 300 page story hidden in here that mainly serves the purpose of setting up book 3. The plot of this book independent of the other two barely exists, yet takes up hundreds of pages in which nothing happens. The characters are also more miss than hit. The ones from the first book are generally elaborated on in a nice way, but mostly overshadowed by the new ones who are almost all rather underwhelming or really annoying.
Long version:
The one year time skip between Book 1 and 2 is nicely handled. It feels like characters and the world have significantly changed in believable ways without changing too much for only 12 months. Everyone has grown and is allowed to shine more, now that Kelsier is no longer overshadowing them all, making all the decisions and doing all the action. We finally get some proper insight into why Kelsier formed his team around these people and not other Skaa rebels/thieves. But even though he has died over a year ago and basically does not factor into the plot of this book at all, the characters feel a need to mention him fairly regularly. Like god, get over it guys.
The new characters are generally kind of lacking however. The new bad guys are, similar to the Lord Ruler, mostly a nebulous threat in the distance and aren’t given much attention until the plot heads for the final climax and resolution. The exception to this is Zane, and he is the worst character in the entire book. He is infuriatingly one note and has only two or three talking points he repeats over and over again. That paired with the fact how obviously wrong and scheming he is makes him become really annoying and really boring almost immediately.
On the side of good, a central new character is Tindwyl, an old companion/coworker of Sazed, the series’ best character so far. Sadly, she fails to come even close to his greatness. She seems weirdly obsessed with turning Elend into the kind of ruler he specifically tries to not be, and she really struggles to make her efforts appear in a sympathetic light. It is only when the other characters discuss Tindwyl and her motives that she stops appearing as a nuisance with bad intentions.
The only ‘new’, more important character that makes himself likeable is OreSeur, the shapeshifter Kelsier employed in the first book and is barely focused on there. In this book, he gets to form a really intimate relationship with Vin where they help each other grow in really compelling ways from beginning to end. Beyond that, he has interesting, meaningful things to say about the events and characters in this world and contributes to the plot in great ways no one else can replicate.
Vin herself also has great moments in this book. She is generally on par with how she was written in the first book, but sadly she is very much hampered by the way her romantic subplot with Elend is handled. Especially in the beginning, the feelings between the two really aren’t convincing. It usually feels like Vin cares more about Elend for political reasons than romantic ones. Yet when she doubts her love, it also feels cheap and unreal, because those doubts are only very surface level and cliché – and forced onto her by someone who explicitly wants to destroy their relationship. The two of them are roped into a sort of miscommunication plot by Zane, and like most of these, this one is annoying, contrived, shallow and could be resolved by 30 seconds of talking. Luckily, this part of the story does get better as it approaches its finale.
Elend however is much less complicated to judge. His feelings towards Vin feel much more genuine and it’s nice to see how he cares for her. But even beyond Vin, the way he gets to act and grow in this story is great. It’s quite impressive how the flaws that make him an unpopular ruler emerge directly out of his idealism that makes him popular too. He gave the people the tools to depose him, he neglects government meetings to fight for the government’s chance to continue existing. He is a great guy both in the beginning and end, but he still undergoes some compelling and meaningful character development.
Though one can say a lot about the characters in this book, it’s hard to really talk about the plot. Because there isn’t all that much of it in these countless pages. While the beginning does a nice job of reintroducing the reader to this world and these characters, once they’ve found their footing, the overwhelmingly large middle part consists of the characters sitting around, literally just waiting and contemplating what to do when the plot actually starts. There are some things happening in this middle part, but most of them are not elaborated on enough to really feel like more than fluff and rambling.
Though one can say a lot about the characters in this book, it’s hard to really talk about the plot. Because there isn’t all that much of it in these countless pages. While the beginning does a nice job of reintroducing the reader to this world and these characters, once they’ve found their footing, the overwhelmingly large middle part consists of the characters sitting around, literally just waiting and contemplating what to do when the plot actually starts. There are some things happening in this middle part, but most of them are not elaborated on enough to really feel like more than fluff and rambling.
It is only around chapter 50 (of 60) that the plot kicks into higher gear, when all that’s left is the final climax. This final climax is weirdly paced, as it is very clearly split into two with a little break inbetween. The first half is rather weak. The action is quite nice but certain circumstances are really annoying, especially in regards of what is going on around Vin. Quite a lot of the pain and suffering here was completely pointless and avoidable.
The second final climax is nicer, but it also exists pretty much exclusively to set up the third book. While the prospect of what will happen in it is intriguing, it feels really cheap how much of this final twist is based on just straight up lying to the reader all throughout the novel. As a result, Sanderson’s need to over-explain his world, plot twists and the like gets really annoying at times in this last segment.
challenging
dark
mysterious
reflective
tense
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
I'm glad I was forced to read this. It's an experience worth having. But it wasn't pleasant.
challenging
dark
reflective
sad
Plot or Character Driven:
Plot
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
I gotta admit, this interpretation Lear (the character) is truly deserving of everything that happens to him. However that doesn’t matter all too much, since every other character is just as terrible as him. The constant absence of any real character motivations. goals and any other form of establishing personality means that everyone seems to always make the worst and/or most vile choice they could make for no reason, seemingly at random.
This feeling carries on to the story as well. So much stuff happens off-stage, without the audience ever really being caught up on them. Everything feels like such a big mess that even the characters have lost the plot – and not in a way that the writer intended. The moment to moment interactions always feel like the characters are talking past each other. Every sentence spoken feels super clumsy, like no one knows what real conversation sounds like. Topics are picked and dropped at random, because the characters barely ever react to what the others on stage have just said and done. And when the topic/action changes to a new focus, there is no sensible transition – characters just randomly start talking about something new or doing something new without any catalyst. This extents to the larger scale story too. At several point, the writer just pulled new plot threads out of nowhere because he seemingly failed to create a plot that could span across all three acts.
In conclusion: Everything about this play feels like a first draft that is still unfinished.
This feeling carries on to the story as well. So much stuff happens off-stage, without the audience ever really being caught up on them. Everything feels like such a big mess that even the characters have lost the plot – and not in a way that the writer intended. The moment to moment interactions always feel like the characters are talking past each other. Every sentence spoken feels super clumsy, like no one knows what real conversation sounds like. Topics are picked and dropped at random, because the characters barely ever react to what the others on stage have just said and done. And when the topic/action changes to a new focus, there is no sensible transition – characters just randomly start talking about something new or doing something new without any catalyst. This extents to the larger scale story too. At several point, the writer just pulled new plot threads out of nowhere because he seemingly failed to create a plot that could span across all three acts.
In conclusion: Everything about this play feels like a first draft that is still unfinished.
challenging
emotional
informative
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
After the whole controversy caused by this: Wow, this is even milder than I expected. Sure, the novel very heavily discusses sexual topics, but to me they always had a very much sex education vibe. In fact, I would actively recommend this book more to teenagers, rather than adults who have already lived their queerness for a while or read a queer autobiography or two. Few things really stand out as unique, but the stuff that is discussed is very much important to learn for someone who is still figuring out what their identity is, regardless of whether they are queer or not.
The only thing you’ll have to keep in mind: Kobabe very much focuses on the challenges, difficulties and negative experiences of eir life, which is fair, but there’s a lot of happiness in being queer and/or yourself. Things will get better. You deserve to be happy and will be if you celebrate your own identity.
The only thing you’ll have to keep in mind: Kobabe very much focuses on the challenges, difficulties and negative experiences of eir life, which is fair, but there’s a lot of happiness in being queer and/or yourself. Things will get better. You deserve to be happy and will be if you celebrate your own identity.
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Yes
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
If you’re only interested in the vampires: Carmilla is so much cooler and more mesmerizing than Count Dracula. Laura is also quite compelling as a young, polite, distinguished, victorian woman who desperately craves a friend like her. Aside from these two, there aren’t all that many characters. These side characters are nice in the job they have in the narrative, but ultimately a little flat. It doesn’t help that they (and Laura too, admittedly) have a habit of not communicating crucial information to others for no/bullshit reasons, even if doing so could save multiple lives.
Aside from the characters, the vibes of the world are immaculate; it’s so elegant in its magnificent castle and rural outside, yet increasingly unsettling as the story progresses, even if you have a hunch of what is going on. This isn’t all that difficult, sadly. The story may be predictable in large parts, but the tense moments are nevertheless gripping, the creepy parts unsettling. In the details, following the narrative is still really fun. The ending however is very sudden, fast and kinda anticlimactic – but nevertheless beautifully conveyed.
Aside from the characters, the vibes of the world are immaculate; it’s so elegant in its magnificent castle and rural outside, yet increasingly unsettling as the story progresses, even if you have a hunch of what is going on. This isn’t all that difficult, sadly. The story may be predictable in large parts, but the tense moments are nevertheless gripping, the creepy parts unsettling. In the details, following the narrative is still really fun. The ending however is very sudden, fast and kinda anticlimactic – but nevertheless beautifully conveyed.
hopeful
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
Complicated
Loveable characters:
No
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
tldr:
Everyone always says the less you know the better. But I'd loved to have known beforehand that the story is advertising itself as something it barely is. The exploration of Piranesi's House is really lovely and should have remained the focus of the story beyond the opening third. Instead, it becomes really tangential to a super predictable plotline that might as well have happened in the real world with minimal changes. It doesn’t help the novel’s case that in both parts the characters are kind of whatever; they are not bad, but also not that interesting.
Long version:
The beginning third is easily the best part of the novel. The House is a great and interesting place. It is unique but also very fantastical, especially in the way it is described. But very early on, you already get to ask yourself meaningful questions about the inner/hidden working of this world and construct some loose theories about potential twists. It is really fun to pick up and put together the hints of how this world is working and what is happening.
With the arrival of the Prophet around page 83 however, the plot very suddenly becomes something entirely different from the first third of the novel. He just straight up tells Piranesi what this world is, how it works and what it means with no subtlety. It is one of the most clumsy lore-dumps you can come across in a novel of this acclaim.
From here onward, the story shifts from exploring a fantastical otherworld to becoming a moderately grounded, very academic crime story to which the house is only tangentially relevant. It is also incredibly predictable. The investigation is interesting for a while, but as a reader you come to all the answers way too quickly and then the book just meanders on about the same few revelations again and again. At that point, the only real surprise is how underwhelming the reveal of 16's identity is.
It doesn’t help that Piranesi is a complicated character to enjoy, not good and not bad. He is generally very well written and likeable, but also naive to the point it can become really really annoying. This makes perfect sense within the story and creates a fresh and unique-feeling sense of dramatic irony, but the further you get, the more frustrating Piranesi’s inability to put 2 and 2 together becomes. In the second half, you have a lot of information that is really easy to puzzle together – to the point nothing really surprises you anymore – yet Piranesi consistently fails to do so.
Ketterly is also just a rather boring villain. Not only is the final climax and his demise really underwhelming, from his first appearance it is incredibly obvious that he is purposefully hiding crucial information from Piranesi. Whenever Piranesi asks a question, all he can do to hide his sinister motives is to say "Don't disturb me.” which is not helping his case. And nevertheless, the story makes a really big deal out of Piranesi realizing that Ketterly was evil the whole time.
Everyone always says the less you know the better. But I'd loved to have known beforehand that the story is advertising itself as something it barely is. The exploration of Piranesi's House is really lovely and should have remained the focus of the story beyond the opening third. Instead, it becomes really tangential to a super predictable plotline that might as well have happened in the real world with minimal changes. It doesn’t help the novel’s case that in both parts the characters are kind of whatever; they are not bad, but also not that interesting.
Long version:
With the arrival of the Prophet around page 83 however, the plot very suddenly becomes something entirely different from the first third of the novel. He just straight up tells Piranesi what this world is, how it works and what it means with no subtlety. It is one of the most clumsy lore-dumps you can come across in a novel of this acclaim.
From here onward, the story shifts from exploring a fantastical otherworld to becoming a moderately grounded, very academic crime story to which the house is only tangentially relevant. It is also incredibly predictable. The investigation is interesting for a while, but as a reader you come to all the answers way too quickly and then the book just meanders on about the same few revelations again and again. At that point, the only real surprise is how underwhelming the reveal of 16's identity is.
It doesn’t help that Piranesi is a complicated character to enjoy, not good and not bad. He is generally very well written and likeable, but also naive to the point it can become really really annoying. This makes perfect sense within the story and creates a fresh and unique-feeling sense of dramatic irony, but the further you get, the more frustrating Piranesi’s inability to put 2 and 2 together becomes. In the second half, you have a lot of information that is really easy to puzzle together – to the point nothing really surprises you anymore – yet Piranesi consistently fails to do so.
Ketterly is also just a rather boring villain. Not only is the final climax and his demise really underwhelming, from his first appearance it is incredibly obvious that he is purposefully hiding crucial information from Piranesi. Whenever Piranesi asks a question, all he can do to hide his sinister motives is to say "Don't disturb me.” which is not helping his case. And nevertheless, the story makes a really big deal out of Piranesi realizing that Ketterly was evil the whole time.
challenging
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
Mesmerizingly miserable.
You constantly feel the need to stop reading, but just can't.
You constantly feel the need to stop reading, but just can't.
dark
hopeful
informative
reflective
medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
A mix
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
All of the Beggar's Opera's interesting parts made good and all of the bad parts removed. In fact, Brecht went out of his way to not only remove all of the unnecessary misogyny, but elevate the female roles and make them trash-talk the men in their life (and be overall much more compelling in their actions, personality etc.). Though as a result, some of their behaviors don't really make sense. They say one thing and then act contradictory to that later.
However generally, the characters are all much more compelling and interesting and the plot seems executed more elegantly. The only slightly confusing thing is the ending. It makes sense why Brecht would want to save Macheath, but it is weird that everyone suddenly celebrates him surviving when most of them actively worked to get him executed in the first place. The fact that this deus ex machina comes in the form of a police officer delivering a message from the queen also feels very antithetical to Brecht's usual messages.
However generally, the characters are all much more compelling and interesting and the plot seems executed more elegantly. The only slightly confusing thing is the ending. It makes sense why Brecht would want to save Macheath, but it is weird that everyone suddenly celebrates him surviving when most of them actively worked to get him executed in the first place. The fact that this deus ex machina comes in the form of a police officer delivering a message from the queen also feels very antithetical to Brecht's usual messages.
challenging
dark
reflective
tense
fast-paced
Plot or Character Driven:
Character
Strong character development:
No
Loveable characters:
Complicated
Diverse cast of characters:
No
Flaws of characters a main focus:
Yes
The play is generally fine. The plot is quite nice and while I’m not sure if I would call the characters interesting or likeable, it is fun enough to follow them around. The central problem though is that the play is so densely packed with sexism and other hostilities towards women that it just becomes unpleasant. Even when all characters on stage are women, they cannot stop talking about how useless and vile all women are. It definitely goes way beyond what is necessary for social commentary or characterization and veers into making you wonder if those are just the writer’s genuine feelings towards women (which I cannot make a statement on).