orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

The Well of Ascension by Brandon Sanderson
2.0
adventurous mysterious reflective slow-paced
Plot or Character Driven: Character
Strong character development: Yes
Loveable characters: Complicated
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

tldr/summary: 
There’s a nice 300 page story hidden in here that mainly serves the purpose of setting up book 3. The plot of this book independent of the other two barely exists, yet takes up hundreds of pages in which nothing happens. The characters are also more miss than hit. The ones from the first book are generally elaborated on in a nice way, but mostly overshadowed by the new ones who are almost all rather underwhelming or really annoying. 

Long version: 
The one year time skip between Book 1 and 2 is nicely handled. It feels like characters and the world have significantly changed in believable ways without changing too much for only 12 months. Everyone has grown and is allowed to shine more, now that Kelsier is no longer overshadowing them all, making all the decisions and doing all the action. We finally get some proper insight into why Kelsier formed his team around these people and not other Skaa rebels/thieves. But even though he has died over a year ago and basically does not factor into the plot of this book at all, the characters feel a need to mention him fairly regularly. Like god, get over it guys. 
The new characters are generally kind of lacking however. The new bad guys are, similar to the Lord Ruler, mostly a nebulous threat in the distance and aren’t given much attention until the plot heads for the final climax and resolution. The exception to this is Zane, and he is the worst character in the entire book. He is infuriatingly one note and has only two or three talking points he repeats over and over again. That paired with the fact how obviously wrong and scheming he is makes him become really annoying and really boring almost immediately. 
On the side of good, a central new character is Tindwyl, an old companion/coworker of Sazed, the series’ best character so far. Sadly, she fails to come even close to his greatness. She seems weirdly obsessed with turning Elend into the kind of ruler he specifically tries to not be, and she really struggles to make her efforts appear in a sympathetic light. It is only when the other characters discuss Tindwyl and her motives that she stops appearing as a nuisance with bad intentions. 
The only ‘new’, more important character that makes himself likeable is OreSeur, the shapeshifter Kelsier employed in the first book and is barely focused on there. In this book, he gets to form a really intimate relationship with Vin where they help each other grow in really compelling ways from beginning to end. Beyond that, he has interesting, meaningful things to say about the events and characters in this world and contributes to the plot in great ways no one else can replicate. 
Vin herself also has great moments in this book. She is generally on par with how she was written in the first book, but sadly she is very much hampered by the way her romantic subplot with Elend is handled. Especially in the beginning, the feelings between the two really aren’t convincing. It usually feels like Vin cares more about Elend for political reasons than romantic ones. Yet when she doubts her love, it also feels cheap and unreal, because those doubts are only very surface level and cliché – and forced onto her by someone who explicitly wants to destroy their relationship. The two of them are roped into a sort of miscommunication plot by Zane, and like most of these, this one is annoying, contrived, shallow and could be resolved by 30 seconds of talking. Luckily, this part of the story does get better as it approaches its finale. 
Elend however is much less complicated to judge. His feelings towards Vin feel much more genuine and it’s nice to see how he cares for her. But even beyond Vin, the way he gets to act and grow in this story is great. It’s quite impressive how the flaws that make him an unpopular ruler emerge directly out of his idealism that makes him popular too. He gave the people the tools to depose him, he neglects government meetings to fight for the government’s chance to continue existing. He is a great guy both in the beginning and end, but he still undergoes some compelling and meaningful character development. 

Though one can say a lot about the characters in this book, it’s hard to really talk about the plot. Because there isn’t all that much of it in these countless pages. While the beginning does a nice job of reintroducing the reader to this world and these characters, once they’ve found their footing, the overwhelmingly large middle part consists of the characters sitting around, literally just waiting and contemplating what to do when the plot actually starts. There are some things happening in this middle part, but most of them are not elaborated on enough to really feel like more than fluff and rambling. 
It is only around chapter 50 (of 60) that the plot kicks into higher gear, when all that’s left is the final climax. This final climax is weirdly paced, as it is very clearly split into two with a little break inbetween. The first half is rather weak. The action is quite nice but certain circumstances are really annoying, especially in regards of what is going on around Vin. Quite a lot of the pain and suffering here was completely pointless and avoidable. 
The second final climax is nicer, but it also exists pretty much exclusively to set up the third book. While the prospect of what will happen in it is intriguing, it feels really cheap how much of this final twist is based on just straight up lying to the reader all throughout the novel. As a result, Sanderson’s need to over-explain his world, plot twists and the like gets really annoying at times in this last segment.