You need to sign in or sign up before continuing.

orcinus_olive's profile picture

orcinus_olive 's review for:

Piranesi by Susanna Clarke
2.0
hopeful mysterious reflective medium-paced
Plot or Character Driven: A mix
Strong character development: Complicated
Loveable characters: No
Diverse cast of characters: No
Flaws of characters a main focus: Yes

tldr:
Everyone always says the less you know the better. But I'd loved to have known beforehand that the story is advertising itself as something it barely is. The exploration of Piranesi's House is really lovely and should have remained the focus of the story beyond the opening third. Instead, it becomes really tangential to a super predictable plotline that might as well have happened in the real world with minimal changes. It doesn’t help the novel’s case that in both parts the characters are kind of whatever; they are not bad, but also not that interesting.

Long version:
The beginning third is easily the best part of the novel. The House is a great and interesting place. It is unique but also very fantastical, especially in the way it is described. But very early on, you already get to ask yourself meaningful questions about the inner/hidden working of this world and construct some loose theories about potential twists. It is really fun to pick up and put together the hints of how this world is working and what is happening.
With the arrival of the Prophet around page 83 however, the plot very suddenly becomes something entirely different from the first third of the novel. He just straight up tells Piranesi what this world is, how it works and what it means with no subtlety. It is one of the most clumsy lore-dumps you can come across in a novel of this acclaim.
From here onward, the story shifts from exploring a fantastical otherworld to becoming a moderately grounded, very academic crime story to which the house is only tangentially relevant. It is also incredibly predictable. The investigation is interesting for a while, but as a reader you come to all the answers way too quickly and then the book just meanders on about the same few revelations again and again. At that point, the only real surprise is how underwhelming the reveal of 16's identity is.

It doesn’t help that Piranesi is a complicated character to enjoy, not good and not bad. He is generally very well written and likeable, but also naive to the point it can become really really annoying. This makes perfect sense within the story and creates a fresh and unique-feeling sense of dramatic irony, but the further you get, the more frustrating Piranesi’s inability to put 2 and 2 together becomes. In the second half, you have a lot of information that is really easy to puzzle together – to the point nothing really surprises you anymore – yet Piranesi consistently fails to do so.
Ketterly is also just a rather boring villain. Not only is the final climax and his demise really underwhelming, from his first appearance it is incredibly obvious that he is purposefully hiding crucial information from Piranesi. Whenever Piranesi asks a question, all he can do to hide his sinister motives is to say "Don't disturb me.” which is not helping his case. And nevertheless, the story makes a really big deal out of Piranesi realizing that Ketterly was evil the whole time.